acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Prefix-Adaptive and Utility-Aware Stopping for EEG Closed-Loop Resource-Efficient Sleep Staging

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Continuous EEG acquisition dominates the resource budget of wearable sleep staging. Efficiency-oriented models fully observe a time period for decision, which is difficult to apply to resource-constrained actual deployment systems. Early time-series classification (ECTS) would stop once the observed prefix is decisive, but its instance-wise formulation assumes a stopping decision affects only the instance that made it. However, consecutive epochs are dependent, so stopping early truncates the history later epochs rely on, and a model trained on complete histories meets policy-induced covariate shift at inference. We introduce Prefix-Adaptive and Utility-Aware Stopping (PAUSE), a closed-loop framework in which each stopping decision controls both the current acquisition and the memory passed forward. A utility-aware finite-horizon stopper weighs stopping risk against expected continuation risk plus acquisition cost, a causal endpoint-memory backbone conditions each epoch on summaries taken at the policy-determined stopping points of its predecessors, and paired-history training combines complete and randomly truncated histories to reduce sensitivity to policy-induced history truncation. On four public datasets validation, PAUSE raises the macro-F1 versus acquisition frontier by 11.4 to 13.7 points over state-of-the-art ECTS baselines with 5.5 to 7.4 times less EEG. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAUSE for evidence-driven EEG acquisition in resource-constrained sleep monitoring.

Primary area:
applications to neuroscience & cognitive science
Keywords:
EEG, Sleep Staging, Early Classification of Time Series, Machine Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_1Ch2OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes PAUSE, an adaptive EEG acquisition framework for sleep staging. The approach works based on 30-second epochs. In each 30-second epoch, the model sequentially processes 1-second patches and decides whether to acquire more data or stop. The goal is to reduce energy consumption due to keeping the EEG sensor running, stopping recording early and placing the sensing hardware in standby until the next epoch. The approach combines a causal transformer that incorporates historical context, training with complete and randomly truncated histories, and a stopping rule that balances classification risk against reducing data acquisition cost. In experiments on four public datasets, the authors show improved macro-F1 while acquiring substantially less EEG than the evaluated early-classification baselines.

Critical strengths

The experimental evaluation covers four public datasets and examines classification performance across different acquisition budgets. This helps assess the trade-off between how much EEG is acquired and how accurately sleep stages are classified. Reporting separate results for the difficult minority N1 stage is also useful, as it shows whether reduced acquisition disproportionately affects a stage that is already challenging to recognize.

Critical weaknesses

I am not convinced by the motivation as currently presented. The authors do not clearly specify which wearables they target or why EEG-based sleep staging is needed in that setting. In my experience building and deploying sleep-staging algorithms on smartwatches, PPG and accelerometry are the industry-standard for sleep staging on wearables and achieve strong performance using computationally efficient architectures such as TCNs and LSTMs. The paper does not discuss these alternatives or explain the practical advantage of its EEG-based approach. This related work is missing entirely and would be important in the motivation. While the focus is on reducing acquisition costs, the proposed transformer and repeated stopping decisions introduce computational overhead. Without an end-to-end comparison on representative hardware, it is unclear whether the savings from stopping the sensor early justify this additional complexity and continuous evaluation through this complex model.

Questions for authors
  1. The motivation needs to be clearer. Why does this work focus solely on EEG-based sleep staging? Consumer wearables already use PPG and accelerometry for sleep staging which is efficient and quite accurate. Why is EEG preferable for the intended use case? This related work and discussion are missing.

  2. What wearables are you targeting exactly, and what is the main resource bottleneck? Sleep-staging algorithms can already run efficiently on-device. Typically PPG can be collected in a low-power mode over night via a separate co-processor, this doesnt cost many resources. Then the sleep staging is typically done based on full-night recordings in a single forward pass of a model that can run on the watch. If your argument is that EEG acquisition dominates the energy budget, this needs to be demonstrated for the target hardware. There is no statement in the introduction how much EEG acquisition takes up in terms of energy consumption and on which device.

2.1 Specifically: The proposed approach uses a transformer and repeatedly evaluates whether to stop. How much computation and energy does this require? Does this really save energy compared to just keeping the EEG sensor running without having a model to decide when to stop? The whole argument of the paper depends on this yet there is no statement about this. The estimation using Analog Front End power savings does not estimate device power savings.

  1. Why is adaptive acquisition more energy-efficient overall than continuous sampling and classifying the whole full-night recording at once in the end. Please include the costs of incremental backbone inference, stopping decisions, and standby/wake-up transitions in a comparison on representative hardware.

  2. You compare against ULW-SleepNet, a lightweight model suitable for on-device inference. PAUSE achieves better classification performance, but how do the approaches compare in total energy, memory, and latency at comparable accuracy?

Overall, I have the impression that the paper introduces a complicated approach to a narrow problem without sufficiently establishing the practical need or showing that the additional complexity pays off.

Reviewer_qCGWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper treats sleep staging as acquisition control. After each 1-s patch of a 30-s epoch, the system decides whether to stop recording, and the unrecorded suffix is lost to later epochs too (Eq. 1). PAUSE has three parts. A causal Transformer looks at the current prefix and at the stopping endpoints of earlier epochs in a 32-epoch window (Eqs. 3-5). A FIRMBOUND-style finite-horizon GP stopper uses a class-weighted stopping risk and a per-patch cost η\eta (Eqs. 6-9). Training mixes full and uniformly truncated histories (Eq. 10). On four sleep datasets with 20-fold subject-wise CV, the paper reports average Pareto gains of 11.4-13.7 macro-F1 points over four ECTS methods, 5.5-7.4× less EEG at operating points above their peaks, and lower estimated front-end power.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem is real and clearly stated. Stopping early on epoch nn also removes evidence for epoch n+1n+1, which instance-wise ECTS ignores. Eq. 1 and the Eq. 3 mask make it concrete, and the MASS contrast (L045-049) is clear. This matters for wearables, where the paper argues continuous acquisition is most of the resource budget (L013-014; Section 4.5 estimates front-end power).

  2. The experiments try to separate the parts. Section 4.4 compares five stopping rules on one frozen backbone and calibrated posterior (Figure 3). Table 1 ablates both cross-epoch components over eight cost levels. Temperatures and GP stoppers are fitted out-of-fold (L295-296), and N1 F1 is reported separately (Figure 2, bottom row).

Critical weaknesses
  1. Headline gains mostly come from cross-epoch context, not adaptive acquisition. The abstract (L026-028) credits PAUSE with an 11.4-13.7 point Pareto gain and 5.5-7.4× less EEG than "state-of-the-art ECTS baselines", and the conclusion (L481-482) repeats the 5.5-7.4× figure. But those four baselines classify each epoch from its own prefix. The paper calls them "instance-wise baselines" (L370) and matches them to PAUSE only in parameter count (L316-317), while PAUSE sees the endpoints of up to 31 earlier epochs. The paper's own numbers show where the margin comes from. Without endpoint memory, the variant "trails PAUSE by 5.8 to 12.5 macro-F1, accounting for most of the margin over the instance-wise baselines" (L369-370). With the backbone fixed, the utility-aware stopper beats the upper envelope of the other four rules (a fixed prefix among them) by 1.78-3.92 points on average (L426-428). So Figure 2 mainly compares a sequence model with single-epoch models. That is my biggest problem with the paper. The paper cites sequence models showing that context helps sleep staging (Zhao et al., 2022; Phan et al., 2023; L060-061), yet Table 2 doesn't include them. Adding to Figure 2 a context-aware baseline without adaptive stopping (the backbone or a cited sequence model at fixed prefixes, or the ECTS stoppers given endpoint memory), and reporting the breakdown in the abstract, would resolve this.

  2. Part of the stopper's gain may come from a class-weighted decision rule, not from when it stops. With Λc,a=ρwc I[c≠a]\Lambda_{c,a}=\rho w_c\,\mathbb{I}[c\neq a] (Eq. 6), the expected cost of predicting aa is ρ(∑cπcal(c)wc−πcal(a)wa)\rho\big(\sum_c \pi^{cal}(c)w_c - \pi^{cal}(a)w_a\big), so Eq. 7 predicts arg⁡max⁡awa πcal(a)\arg\max_a w_a\,\pi^{cal}(a). For α>0\alpha>0 this pushes the posterior toward rare classes such as N1 at every stopping point, no matter when it stops. Macro-F1 and N1 F1 are exactly the metrics this kind of reweighting raises. Apart from that, the stopper follows FIRMBOUND's finite-horizon GP regression (L217-218). I couldn't find in the main text whether FIRMBOUND, Threshold and AAGC in Figure 3 predict with the same class-weighted rule or with the arg-max of the calibrated posterior, or the values of α\alpha and ρ\rho. If the baselines use plain arg-max, then part of the 1.78-3.92 point gain in Figure 3 and of the N1 result in Section 4.2 (L345-355) is due to the decision rule, which any baseline could use too. Reporting PAUSE with α=0\alpha=0, or the baselines with the same decision rule, would settle this.

A few smaller points. Tables 1-3 and Figures 2-3 give single numbers with no fold-level spread or paired test, so I can't judge margins such as 0.54 macro-F1 on Sleep-EDF-78 (Table 2) or the 0.71-point peak difference (L428-429). The 20 folds would give a spread directly. The history shift is inferred from the ablation pattern (L377-383) but never measured, and the Unif{1,…,P}\mathrm{Unif}\{1,\dots,P\} endpoints (Eq. 10) differ from the short endpoints produced at tight budgets. Table 1 compares variants at equal η\eta, not at equal budget (DREAMS-SUB, η=0.5\eta=0.5: 60.34 at 1.1 patches vs. 55.85 at 2.4). Since memory is limited to 32-epoch windows (L107-131), what does the first epoch of a window see at test time?

Questions for authors
  1. Do the Figure 3 baselines predict with the class-weighted rule of Eq. 7 or with the posterior arg-max? Which α\alpha and ρ\rho are used, and what do Figures 2-3 look like with α=0\alpha=0?
  2. How does a context-aware system without adaptive stopping compare with the ECTS baselines in Figure 2?
  3. What is the fold-level spread (or a paired test over folds) for the Pareto gains in Figures 2-3 and the margins in Table 2?
  4. Were all hyperparameters searched within training folds, with the same budget for the baselines?

Measuring the history shift directly (backbone accuracy with full vs. stopper-produced histories) would also back up Section 3.4 better than the ablation pattern does.

Reviewer_WNTNOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposed PAUSE for early classification which determines if enough observations have arrived for classification, or should sensing continue. The problem set up is on wearable device where sensing is costly (battery life?), and hence an early prediction is appropriate. The method also creates a summary vector that compresses earlier prefixes that it sensed, allowing for encoding/capturing temporal dependencies. Experiments on sleep datasets show that method is effective in finding a tradeoff between performance and earliness.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem motivation is timely given all of the wearables.
  2. Architecture including the stopping mechanism for sensing and summary creating for prefixes is straightforward, noting too twisted.
  3. Performance is convincing that the architecture is useful.
Critical weaknesses
  1. I think the most consequential drawback is ignoring most important baselines and past works that more or less established the ECTS works. Literature is focusing on sleep staging but the architecture and problem formation is of the ECTS, so most literature is missing. What I am little perplexed by is that early stopping by looking into expected value formation is something that earlier ECTS frameworks have addresses using various approaches, so it’s not merely literature missing, it is entirely the class of algorithms that could possibly be state of the art are missing from comparison. See some references below (not exhaustive).
  2. The other thing, which is more subjective, is that what exact problem are we trying to solve for becomes clear only in Section 2. Entire Section 1 is devoted to motivation, but the problem formation is quite confusing over there. May be translate the equations of Section 2 into words in Section 1 to make the reading better.

Other minor things:

  1. The entire section of REPRODUCIBILITY STATEMENT is quite unique. May be just write one sentence instead of full paragraph.
  2. Do a review of Section 1 to make the read more pleasant.

References

  1. Romain Tavenard and Simon Malinowski. 2016. Cost-aware early classificationof time series. In ECML/PKDD.
  2. Asma Dachraoui, Alexis Bondu, and Antoine Cornuéjols. 2015. Early classification of time series as a non myopic sequential decision making problem. In ECML/PKDD.
  3. Nima Hatami and Camelia Chira. 2013. Classifiers with a reject option for early time-series classification. In CIEL.
  4. Zhengzheng Xing, Jian Pei, and S Yu Philip. 2012. Early classification on time series. Knowledge and information systems
  5. U. Mori, A. Mendiburu, S. Dasgupta, J.A. Lozano. 2017. Early classification of time series by simultaneously optimizing the accuracy and earliness. IEEE Trans. Neur. Netw. Learn. Sys.
  6. M.F. Ghalwash, Z. Obradovic. 2012. Early classification of multivariate temporal observations by extraction of interpretable shapelets. BMC Bioinformatics.
  7. Shekhar, S., Eswaran, D., Hooi, B., Elmer, J., Faloutsos, C., & Akoglu, L. 2023. Benefit-aware early prediction of health outcomes on multivariate EEG time series. Journal of biomedical informatics.
Questions for authors
  1. The does the summary description deal with EEG signals that are may be non-stationary, or do rapid changes right at the truncation? I wonder if it would have negative impact on the summary and consequently on the temporal dependency in coming segments?

  2. How robust the method is to changing segment sizes? How does it do if segment size is like 64 or 16 or something like that?

  3. The premise of the paper is resource efficiency in wearables. The paper is using transformers, how much resource drain will that do for doing matrix multiplications for attention computation on device?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.