acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

–RSG: Support-Critical Reasoning Supervision from Self-Certifying Theorem Structures

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) can often derive plausible conclusions from available premises, yet remain prone to asserting conclusions when indispensable support is missing. Existing reasoning supervision primarily emphasizes whether a conclusion follows, providing much weaker supervision about the boundary between sufficient and insufficient evidence. We investigate self-certifying theorem structures generated by the automated theorem generator as a formally grounded source of LLM reasoning supervision, and introduce -based Reasoning Supervision Generation (–RSG) to exploit their support-critical structure. Each theorem has an exact support boundary: its complete premise set entails the conclusion, whereas removing any indispensable premise makes the available support insufficient. –RSG deterministically compiles this structure into complementary supervision for conclusion inference, support sufficiency, support-based abstention, missing-support identification, and support repair, with labels justified by construction rather than external theorem verification. Experiments with Qwen2-1.5B show that self-certifying theorem supervision substantially improves controlled reasoning, while full –RSG further develops support-critical behaviour. On structurally held-out theorem configurations, –RSG achieves 98.9% inference accuracy and 100% support-sufficiency accuracy while reducing the unsupported conclusion rate from 70% for the base model to 1%. It further achieves 97% F1 for missing-support identification and 99.5% F1 for support repair. These results demonstrate that self-certifying theorem structures can provide effective, formally grounded supervision for learning both what follows from available evidence and when that evidence is insufficient to license a conclusion.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Reasoning Supervision, Automated Theorem Generation, Formal Reasoning, Support-Critical Reasoning, Trustworthy AI

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_BpMgOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ∆1-RSG, a framework that generates formally grounded reasoning supervision data from self-certifying theorem structures. It constructs five tasks: conclusion inference, support sufficiency, abstention, missing-support identification and support repair. Experiments on Qwen2-1.5B show that ∆1–RSG improves reasoning performance when evidence is insufficient.

Critical strengths
  1. Compared with training only on samples with complete premises, training on RSG data improves the model's reasoning performance when evidence is insufficient.

  2. The proposed data synthesis method is lightweight and does not require LLM API calls.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments are limited. The experiments do not adequately support the paper's claims. For example, the paper lacks comparisons with existing logical reasoning methods and ablation studies investigating the contributions of the five tasks.

  2. The mathematical proof provides limited justification for the design of the five supervision tasks.

  3. The main contribution is a new method for generating logical reasoning supervision data. Although Appendix E provides illustrative examples, actual samples from the generated dataset are missing. It is unclear whether the data consists of abstract logical statements (e.g., "red is warm", "warm is Alice") or meaningful natural language statements (e.g., "the sun rises in the east", "the Earth rotates"). This distinction is important for assessing generalization to real-world natural language reasoning.

Some Suggestions (Do Not Affect the Rating)

  1. The Keywords below the abstract should be revised to comply with the template.

  2. The paper addresses problems closely related to the following works, but does not discuss them:

    • A Balanced Neuro-Symbolic Approach for Commonsense Abductive Logic, ICLR 2026.
    • Open-World LLM Logical Reasoning, ICML 2026.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors provide more detailed statistics on the training and test data distributions?

  2. Since Missing-support Identification and Support Repair use identical supervision targets, why are they treated as two separate tasks?

  3. Suppose the complete premise set is {A → B, B → C, C → D}, and C → D is removed. If the model instead adds A → D, how would this response be evaluated in the Missing-support Identification and Support Repair tasks?

  4. How do proprietary LLMs, like GPT-5.6 and Claude Opus, perform on the five tasks?

Reviewer_1xEZOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Δ₁–RSG, a reasoning supervision generation framework based on the existing Δ₁ automated theorem generator. It generates five types of training tasks: Conclusion inference, Support sufficiency, Abstention, Missing-support identification, and Support repair. The authors conduct experiments on Qwen2-1.5B and compare Base, Conclusion-SFT, and Full Δ₁–RSG. The results show improvements in conclusion inference and in handling insufficient support on controlled reasoning tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The idea is interesting.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The framework primarily converts existing ∆1 theorem structures into predefined supervision tasks, without introducing substantial algorithmic innovations. The underlying logical properties and training techniques are not novel, leaving the methodological contribution relatively incremental.
  2. The comparisons mainly show that explicit multi-task supervision outperforms conclusion-only fine-tuning, rather than establishing the unique effectiveness of the proposed method.
  3. Both ID and S-OOD datasets are generated using the same ∆1 framework, without evaluation on independent logical reasoning benchmarks or real-world natural language tasks.
  4. The task involves predicting predefined premise identifiers rather than generating missing logical premises, limiting its practical significance.
  5. The experiments only consider removing a single indispensable premise, without evaluating redundant premises, multiple missing premises, or alternative reasoning paths.
Questions for authors

None

Reviewer_RtVrOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Δ₁–RSG uses support-critical structures from an existing theorem generator to construct supervision for reasoning under sufficient and insufficient evidence. Each source theorem entails its conclusion with all premises present, while every proper subset loses that support. The method compiles these structures into conclusion inference, sufficiency classification, abstention, missing-support identification, and support repair. Experiments compare an unadapted Qwen2-1.5B model, conclusion-only fine-tuning, and the full supervision package on in-distribution and held-out generator configurations. The authors report improved inference and support recognition, with S-OOD inference accuracy of 98.9% and an unsupported conclusion rate of 1% for the full model.

Critical strengths

The paper studies an important aspect of reliable reasoning: recognizing when the available evidence no longer licenses a conclusion. This has potential relevance to question answering and problem solving, where confidently answering from incomplete evidence can be harmful. The construction provides a useful controlled setting: necessary premises can be removed deliberately, and the corresponding sufficiency, missing-support, and restoration targets follow from the source structure. This makes the supervision traceable and gives the study a clear way to examine responses to the loss of necessary support.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence for a benefit beyond the controlled generation process is limited. The experiments use one Qwen2-1.5B model, controlled renderings from the same Δ₁ construction, and only deficit-one cases, where exactly one necessary premise is removed. S-OOD holds out configurations within this generator, but the paper does not report transfer to independently constructed reasoning problems or natural-language evidence tasks. Task-specific fine-tuning improving performance on related synthetic tasks is a reasonable outcome; the important remaining question is what additional, transferable capability this supervision develops. Evaluation on an independent resource such as FOLIO or a natural-language context-sufficiency task, together with a stronger instruction-tuned model, would help establish the method's range of usefulness. Section 7 acknowledges these limitations, but the current evidence still leaves the practical significance of the gains uncertain.

  2. The comparisons do not sufficiently isolate the source of the gains. Base, Conclusion-SFT, and Full compare no task adaptation, positive inference training, and four additional supervision families introduced together. There is no task-wise ablation, explicit instruction/few-shot comparison, or sufficient accounting of per-condition examples and training tokens or updates. The paper gives task definitions and illustrative decision prompts, but Appendix E.1 states that the examples do not specify a particular surface template; the actual prompts used for the three conditions are not fully provided. Task distinctions also need stronger experimental support: sufficiency and abstention share the same decision boundary, and Appendix B.2 specifies identical canonical targets for missing-support identification and repair. Table 3 does evaluate the latter two tasks, reporting S-OOD EM/F1 of 95.0/97.0 and 99.0/99.5 for Full, but provides no corresponding Base or Conclusion-SFT results. These omissions make it difficult to separate the effects of explicit negative examples, output-format adaptation, alternative task wording, and the complete supervision design.

Questions for authors
  1. Please provide the actual test prompts and output instructions for Base, Conclusion-SFT, and Full, including whether the first two explicitly receive sufficient/insufficient and answer/withhold options. How does the benefit of training compare with explicit zero-shot or few-shot instructions under the same evaluation protocol? This comparison would help determine how much of the gain comes from inducing an existing capability versus task adaptation.

  2. How many examples, optimizer updates, and training tokens does each condition receive? Can you compare budget-matched variants that add sufficiency or abstention supervision separately, and then add missing-support or repair supervision? The shared gold targets make these comparisons important for establishing the contribution of each task family.

  3. Which structural configurations and parameter ranges are held out for S-OOD? A comparison on independently constructed logical or natural-language evidence problems, and with a stronger instruction-tuned model, would help establish whether the gains extend beyond this generator and backbone.

  4. What source-premise information, candidate lists, or canonical identifiers are visible in the missing-support and repair inputs? Appendix B defines the gold as restoring Γ\A, whereas other additions can also make a conclusion follow. For example, with P and (P∧Q)→R available and P∧Q∧R as the goal, adding Q also suffices after P→Q is removed. Please clarify how the source-restoration restriction is communicated and how alternative valid additions are scored. This determines the scope of the reported repair capability.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.