- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1(−1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1(−1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introdcues AutoSella, an LLM-based framework that modifies the molecular geometry and reduce the number of force evaluations. The paper develop two variants and test them on four benchmarks. The results show that the approach reduces computational costs while maintaining accuracy.
Critical strengths
Generalization evaluation: the experiments cover four benchmarks and provide some evidence of generalization beyond the training setting.
Critical weaknesses
Limited technical contribution: the mathematical formulations and explanations provide little insight into why the proposal works.
Questions for authors
Can the author explain why the discovered modifications imrpove Sella?
How robust are the proposed framework?
Can the author provide more detailed experiments to explain the improvement?
Response to Reviewer gnVg
Weakness 1 — Limited technical insight into the modifications
Answer. We added Sections 4.3–4.4 to describe the changes to Sella, trace their relationship to existing optimizers, and report the effect of removing each component or group of related changes. Appendices G–I give pseudocode and mathematical formulations, while Appendix J gives ablations results.
Question 1 — Why do the discovered modifications improve Sella?
Answer. We have added sections 4.3, 4.4 and Appendices G, H, I to the manuscript.
Question 2 — How robust is the search?
Answer. We have conducted three additional independent 66-hour searches with the same GPT-6.1-Sol Max configuration and one search with Claude Opus 5.5 Max. All runs produced optimizers that saved force calls on validation and exceeded Sella’s mean energy recovery. Please see the newly added Appendix M and Table 10 for details.
Question 3 — What further experiments explain the improvement?
Answer. We performed the search using GFN2-xTB and tested transfer to two unseen potentials, GFN-FF and r2SCAN-3c DFT. We have also tested generalization to new chemical domains: amino acid–ligand pairs and solvated drug-like molecules. AutoSella-F used 31.4% and 59.8% fewer DFT force calls per molecule than Sella, respectively, with greater mean energy recovery on both. These experiments demonstrate generalizability of the optimizer.