W1. The methodological advance is narrow, and the advantage over stronger simple estimators is limited
Equation 3 is a nearest-neighbor distance restricted to a registered local memory. Nearest-neighbor normal-memory scoring is already established in PatchCore (Roth et al., 2022), while the registered local-memory pipeline is inherited from COSSAD (Tarvo et al., 2026), as acknowledged in Section 2. The centroid example and feature-space stability bound clarify the rule, but do not establish a distinctive new estimation principle. The paper therefore needs a sufficiently consequential empirical insight to justify the contribution beyond this straightforward combination.
The strongest controls temper that case. At three templates on Real3D, shrinkage achieves 98.44/63.65 AUROC/AP versus 98.41/62.98 for SES (Table 4); both paired differences are unresolved in Table 18. On ShapeNet-50, SES improves AUROC over the centroid by 0.35 percentage points, but the AP difference is only 0.45 points with a 98.75% interval of [-0.29, 1.41]. I recognize the positive ShapeNet AP result against shrinkage, but the very large headline gains are primarily against the unregularized effect-size comparator. Transfer is also representation dependent: with Point-M2AE at four templates on ShapeNet, SES loses 1.76 AUROC points and 1.78 AP points relative to effect-size scoring (Table 23).
These results establish a useful practical scoring alternative, but provide limited evidence for a broadly preferable model of local normality. In particular, Appendix A.1 defines shrinkage at fewer than three references, yet the primary two-template comparison omits this directly relevant alternative.
W2. The few-template and benchmark conclusions depend on support and coverage choices that remain insufficiently resolved
Appendix A.2, lines 655-658, constructs the shared slot set using finite features from the entire available normal bank before selecting a size-T subset. This is a sensible control for isolating scoring differences, but it does not establish what happens when only T normal shapes are available to construct the support in the first place. The omitted references can influence which slots contribute to projection. The paper should quantify whether rebuilding support from the selected subset changes coverage or performance; if the masks are identical, documenting that would resolve this concern.
The main Real3D results also cover 1,172 of 1,206 test inputs, excluding 34 registration failures, while the controlled retrieval and budget experiments use a separate 587-scan subset (Section 4.1; Appendix C). Table 1 combines these conditional results with published results under other methods' native protocols. The matched Template3D comparison is helpful, but uses one reference for Template3D and the available bank for SES. Moreover, the reference counts for the headline full-inventory Real3D results are explicitly unavailable in Table 9.
The authors disclose these limitations, and they do not negate the within-cohort improvement. Nevertheless, the available evidence does not fully establish performance under a strict reference budget or an equivalent full-benchmark protocol. This matters because few-template operation is central to the paper's claimed significance.