- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes FATUM, a conditional survival model that learns two times per patient: when the patient would leave the study and when the event (e.g. death) would occur. To achieve this they use a diffusion model with a geometric-Brownian-motion noise schedule so that the forward process is Gaussian in log-time. Since only the earlier time is observed, they train the model with an EM procedure which imputes the missing data. The paper has two goals: to predict survival probabilities and, together with TabDiff as a generative backbone for the patient covariates, to synthesize patient cohorts. Evaluation takes place on six survival datasets against multiple survival models and data generators.
Critical strengths
- Modelling censoring as a distribution. By treating the censoring time as a latent outcome to be sampled (rather than as a weight) the authors allow the resampling of a cohort under an altered dropout regime. This could potentially be useful for simulation and study planning.
- Clean technical construction. I especially like the design choice of running the diffusion in log-time so that the censoring constraint becomes an exact truncated-normal draw. This makes the imputation step simple and exact, which gives the method a solid foundation.
Critical weaknesses
1. The framing around survival models is misleading and unsupported, and the paper's goals are unclear.
- The abstract claims survival models "treat when the patient left as a nuisance. That discard is why none of them yields a synthetic cohort a statistician can analyse." Lines 39–40 state that modelling "is enough to rank patients and not enough to write down a cohort."
- This is a category mismatch: discriminative survival models are not designed to generate cohorts. The relevant comparison class (SurvivalGAN, SurvDiff, Ashhad & Henao), which already generates censoring patterns, appears only in related work.
- FATUM itself does not generate cohorts either but requires TabDiff as a backbone for the covariates. Any Table 1 baseline that outputs a survival curve could be composed with TabDiff the same way: one model fit to for events and one fit to for censoring. No experiments show that survival models fail at this.
- The paper pursues two legitimate goals (prediction and cohort generation) but states neither plainly or with a concrete motivation. The abstract relies on undefined terms ("censoring channel", "one lever, truncation") and lists results before establishing what the method is for.
2. Reporting and evaluation do not fully support the claims at the level presented.
- No standard deviations or per-cohort results. Tables 1 and 2 show only summary values. Per-cohort results exist only for IBS (Table 7), with a standard deviation for FATUM only. No baseline has a standard deviation anywhere in the paper.
- Median in Table 2. The median is justified by FATUM's own two outlier cohorts ( of 1.30 and 0.96 vs. 0.09–0.19 elsewhere). The median hides this failure on a third of the cohorts. Table 1 uses means, so the two tables are not consistent.
- Mixing scales. Table 1 averages IBS over cohorts where typical values range from 0.06 to 0.20, so a few cohorts dominate the average. The authors' own Appendix E shows the significant results change when the scale is normalised.
- Generation is evaluated on times only. Table 2 measures fidelity only for the time distribution. There is no covariate fidelity, no check of the relationship between covariates and times, no synthetic censoring rate, and no privacy metric, even though the ethics statement raises privacy.
I would be glad to raise my score if the authors clarify the framing and goals, add the TabDiff + standard survival model baseline, and report per-cohort results with standard deviations (mean and median), together with covariate and joint fidelity metrics.
Questions for authors
- How does TabDiff composed with standard survival models (e.g., a parametric AFT and DeepSurv or RSF, each fit to both the event and the censoring distribution) compare to TabDiff + FATUM?
- Which cohorts have of 1.30 and 0.96, and what causes the failure?
- Do the per-cohort results (mean ± SD for all methods and metrics in Tables 1 and 2) support the summary-level claims?
- Why are C-index and RMST gap omitted from Table 2 when they are computed for Fig. 8, and why were TVAE and CTGAN not run with clipped or log-transformed times?