- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents AA-TTT, a framework for accelerating the convergence of test-time training for 3D reconstruction. AA-TTT formulates test-time optimization as a fixed-point problem and uses Anderson acceleration to improve its convergence speed. The method presented can be applied to different reconstruction architectures and optimization variables.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a formulation of test-time training that is independent of the architecture and of the variables being optimized. This general-purpose framework can be applied to optimize Gaussian parameters, implicit tokens, feature maps, or network adapters.
The paper provides consistent speed-up in all the evaluations reported without any loss in quality of the reconstructed outputs
Critical weaknesses
The paper does not report enough details of the evaluation setup for the experiments. It does not specify what datasets and scenes each method is evaluated on. It also does not specify what scenes the learning rate is tuned on and whether they are part of the evaluation set.
The paper only compares against other first-order optimizers. Since Anderson acceleration can be interpreted as a quasi-Newton method, it would be useful to compare against second-order baselines like 3DGS-LM [1], and quasi-Newton baselines like L-BFGS. Additionally, the paper should discuss learned acceleration methods like ReSplat [2].
[1] 3DGS-LM: Faster Gaussian-Splatting Optimization with Levenberg-Marquardt, Hollen et al., ICCV 2025
[2] ReSplat: Learning Recurrent Gaussian Splatting, Xu et al., ECCV 2026
The paper does not provide any visualizations of the method outputs.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide the missing details for the experiments? Additionally, the 40 scenes subset used in Table 3 seems too small to draw general conclusions, can the authors provide results on the full evaluation set?
Can the authors include a comparison against L-BFGS in Table 3?