- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of reducing manual resets in autonomous reinforcement learning (ARL) with irreversible states. The authors argue that detecting irreversible states only when the agent is already close to them may leave insufficient time for recovery, while directly switching policies after early termination may expose the agent to further risks. To address these issues, the paper proposes a multi-step irreversibility estimator and a transition policy. The estimator uses VLM-generated labels to predict potential irreversible transitions several steps in advance, while the transition policy guides the agent toward suitable states for resuming learning. Experiments on four navigation and manipulation environments show that the proposed method reduces manual resets while maintaining competitive task success rates.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical problem in ARL. I find the motivation reasonable, particularly the observation that early termination alone may not be sufficient if the agent cannot safely resume learning from the aborted state.
- The paper combines multi-step irreversibility prediction with a transition policy to address both early risk detection and safe policy switching. The experimental results show clear reductions in manual resets across four environments, and the ablation studies provide evidence that both components contribute to these improvements.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited comparison with related work and insufficient validation of multi-step irreversibility prediction. The paper lacks a comparison with Robust and Scalable Autonomous Reinforcement Learning in Irreversible Environments (NeurIPS 2025), which addresses a similar problem and shares some underlying mechanisms and experimental settings. A direct comparison would help clarify the advantages of the proposed approach. In addition, although multi-step irreversibility prediction is well motivated, the N-step label expansion relies on future trajectory outcomes that also depend on subsequent actions, raising questions about how accurately the estimator captures action-dependent risks. Fig. 5 mainly provides qualitative results, without a sensitivity analysis of N or quantitative evaluation of prediction lead time and false positive rates. Further experimental evidence would help establish the effectiveness of the proposed multi-step prediction mechanism.
- The safety of the transition policy is not sufficiently established. Some aspects of the proposed framework require further justification. First, Eq. (8) excludes states with high estimated reachability, although such states may be preferable for safe recovery. Moreover, Algorithm 2 does not explicitly check irreversibility risks during transition execution, and the current experiments provide limited evidence of transition safety. Second, although the paper claims to avoid task-specific knowledge, Appendix B.2 shows that the VLM is fine-tuned separately for each environment using labeled reversible and irreversible images. While eliminating online human annotation is valuable, the method still relies on environment-specific supervision. Further clarification of these design choices and supervision requirements would strengthen the paper's claims regarding safety and real-world applicability.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors provide a direct comparison with Robust and Scalable Autonomous Reinforcement Learning in Irreversible Environments (NeurIPS 2025), at least on the shared environments? This would help clarify the benefits of the proposed irreversibility estimator and transition policy over existing approaches.
- What value of N is used in the experiments, and how sensitive is the method to this choice? Fig. 5 shows the effect of introducing N-step expansion, but does not examine different values of N. A comparison of prediction lead time, false positive rates, manual resets, and success rates under different settings would be useful.
- Why does Eq. (8) exclude states with high estimated reachability? Also, how are potentially irreversible actions handled during the execution of the transition policy? It would be helpful to report the transition success rate and the frequency of irreversible events during these transitions, as well as clarify what happens when the selected switching state cannot be reached.
6 comments
[W1-2 & Q2] Validation of multi-step prediction
Your comments led us to validate the multi-step prediction quantitatively. To address your concern, we added a quantitative evaluation of the irreversibility estimator (Table 13 of Appendix F.3) and a sensitivity analysis for (Figure 11 and Table 14 of Appendix F.4), and we now state that is used in all environments (Table 2 of Appendix B.1). We freeze the trained irreversibility estimator, collect rollouts without early aborts, and use as the target whether each is followed by an irreversible transition within steps. The lead time is the median number of steps from the first warning prediction to the irreversible transition, and the false positive rate (FPR) is the fraction of pairs not followed by an irreversible transition within steps that receive a warning prediction.
With , the irreversibility estimator issues warnings at least 7 steps before the irreversible transition, compared with 1 step without -step expansion. The AUROC is at least 0.91, and at the FPR is at most 5.2%.
| Metric | PointMaze-Trap | AntOpen-Trap | Fetch-Reach-Trap | Highway-Parking-Trap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lead time (steps), | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Lead time (steps), | 8 | 8 | 7 | 9 |
| FPR (%) | 1.1 | 1.4 | 0.9 | 5.2 |
| AUROC | 0.97 | 0.95 | 0.98 | 0.91 |
Evaluation of the irreversibility estimator in the four environments (Table 13 of Appendix F.3). The columns other than the lead time are for .
As increases from 0 to 20, the lead time grows from 1 step to at least 15 steps, and the FPR also rises. Increasing from 0 to 10 reduces manual resets in both environments, while the success rate stays at 100.0% in PointMaze-Trap and rises in Highway-Parking-Trap. Increasing from 10 to 20 reduces manual resets by no more than a further 5.3% and lowers the success rate in Highway-Parking-Trap.
| Environment | Lead time (steps) | FPR (%) | Manual resets | Success rate (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PointMaze-Trap | 0 | 1 | 0.3 | 226 | 100.0 |
| 5 | 4 | 0.6 | 203 | 100.0 | |
| 10 | 8 | 1.1 | 181 | 100.0 | |
| 20 | 15 | 2.4 | 176 | 98.3 | |
| Highway-Parking-Trap | 0 | 1 | 1.0 | 1,012 | 83.8 |
| 5 | 4 | 2.4 | 931 | 85.4 | |
| 10 | 9 | 5.2 | 847 | 85.0 | |
| 20 | 16 | 10.8 | 802 | 76.3 |
Results for different values of (Table 14 of Appendix F.4).
These results show that the multi-step prediction issues accurate warnings several steps before the irreversible transition and distinguishes the pairs that lead to irreversible transitions, which captures action-dependent risks. A larger issues warnings earlier and reduces manual resets, but the additional reduction beyond is small, so we use . Table 13 is newly added in Appendix F.3, and Figure 11 and Table 14 are newly added in Appendix F.4.
[W2-1 & Q3-1] Upper threshold in Eq. (8)
Your question helped us explain the role of the upper threshold in Eq. (8). We would like to note that the upper threshold excludes candidates that are too close to the aborted state. An early abort occurs when the agent approaches an irreversible state, so candidates with very high estimated reachability from the aborted state usually lie within a few steps of it and are still close to the irreversible state.
To verify this claim, we conducted an additional experiment that removes . Removing increases manual resets from 181 to 232 in PointMaze-Trap and from 455 to 618 in Fetch-Reach-Trap (Table 15 of Appendix F.5).
| Manual resets | PointMaze-Trap | Fetch-Reach-Trap |
|---|---|---|
| Ours | 181 | 455 |
| w/o λ_high | 232 | 618 |
Effect of removing the upper threshold λ_high (Table 15 of Appendix F.5). The fewer manual resets are in bold.
These results show that resuming training next to the aborted state easily leads the agent into irreversible states again, and that provides a margin from the aborted state. Table 15 is newly added in Appendix F.5.
[W2-2 & Q3-2] Irreversibility risks during transition execution
Your question led us to measure the safety of the transition policy directly. To address your concern, we added the transition success rate and the frequency of entries into irreversible states during transitions (Table 15 of Appendix F.5), and we now describe in Appendix A and Algorithm 2 how the transition policy is executed, including the case in which the selected state is not reached.
The transition policy does not evaluate during execution. The transition starts from the aborted state, where the predicted risk is high, so an early abort could stop the transition before the agent moves away from that state. Instead, the transition policy moves the agent toward the selected safe switching state, and an entry into an irreversible state during a transition is counted as a manual reset. If the agent does not reach the selected state within steps, training resumes from the state where the transition ends (line 11 of Algorithm 2). The next policy evaluates at every step from that state, so an early abort is triggered again if the agent selects a risky action.
The transition policy reaches the selected safe switching state in at least 85.7% of transitions in all four environments (89.4% on average), and entries into irreversible states during transitions account for at most 4.9% of all manual resets (3.9% on average).
| Environment | Reached the selected state (%) | Manual resets during transitions (%) |
|---|---|---|
| PointMaze-Trap | 94.1 | 2.8 |
| AntOpen-Trap | 86.5 | 4.9 |
| Fetch-Reach-Trap | 91.2 | 3.1 |
| Highway-Parking-Trap | 85.7 | 4.6 |
Transition policy statistics (Table 15 of Appendix F.5).
These results show that, even though the transition policy does not evaluate during execution, most transitions reach the selected safe switching state and only a small fraction of manual resets occurs during transitions. Table 15 is newly added in Appendix F.5.
Thank you for carefully reading our paper and for your specific comments. In particular, your comments on the comparison with RSA, the sensitivity to N, the safety of the transition policy, and the environment-specific supervision helped us present our contributions more clearly. We have revised the paper to address all of your comments and marked all changes in blue.
[W1-1 & Q1] Direct comparison with RSA
The direct comparison you suggested allowed us to show the benefits of our irreversibility estimator and transition policy over RSA. To address your concern, we added RSA as a baseline in all four environments, including PointMaze-Trap and AntOpen-Trap, which are shared with the RSA paper. We also included RSA in a controlled comparison in which every condition uses the same curriculum with the state information estimator (Table 12 of Appendix F.2). For a fair comparison, RSA is trained with the same hyperparameters as our algorithm.
In the shared environments, our algorithm requires 30.6% fewer manual resets than RSA in PointMaze-Trap (184 vs. 265) and 52.1% fewer in AntOpen-Trap (68 vs. 142), with equal or higher success rates. In all four environments, it requires at least 29.7% fewer manual resets than RSA (Table 16 of Appendix F.6). In the controlled comparison, our irreversibility estimator alone, without the transition policy, requires at least 17.4% fewer manual resets than RSA, and adding the transition policy reduces them by at least a further 11.8%.
Success rates (%) and manual resets, mean over five random seeds (Table 12 of Appendix F.2). Estimator (N=10) is our irreversibility estimator without the transition policy. The fewest manual resets are in bold.
These results show that each of our two contributions reduces manual resets. Unlike RSA, which passes state inputs through a mapping function and uses successor features to detect irreversible actions, our irreversibility estimator requires no mapping function and predicts an irreversible transition N steps in advance from the image observation and action. The transition policy then guides the agent to a safe switching state before the next policy starts. Table 12 is newly added in Appendix F.2, and RSA is newly added as a baseline in Figure 4 and Table 16 of Appendix F.6.