- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes SGFA for ultrasound lesion segmentation. It combines Shared Texture Projection (STP) with Quadrant-wise Boundary Box Prompting (QBBP). The prompts are generated from ground-truth lesion contours. The paper evaluates the method on pancreatic and ovarian ultrasound data and reports patient-level results for pancreatic EUS.
Critical strengths
Patient-level evaluation reduces the influence of unequal image counts.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not justify the main design choices. The reported comparison shows no clear benefit from STP over a simpler adapter. Results for individual diseases are also missing, so the experiments do not establish that the proposed design addresses the disease differences used to motivate it. The need for the main module remains unproven.
- The evaluation relies on quadrant boxes built from ground-truth lesion contours, but the paper does not show how these boxes would be obtained when the contour is unknown. The reported results therefore do not establish how the method would perform in practice. The proposed method also receives more ground-truth information than several comparison methods, making it difficult to separate better design from extra information.
These make the claimed advantages insufficiently supported.
Questions for authors
- Your pipeline builds quadrant boxes from ground-truth lesion contours, so the segmentation is already known when these prompts are generated. How would this method be used in practice, and how would the boxes be obtained when the contour is unknown?
- Do the reported gains remain when all comparison methods receive the same ground-truth information?
- Can you provide code and report the numbers of patients and frames in the EUS training and validation sets, along with how the patients were split to train the source checkpoints? These details are missing from the paper and supplement.