- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the GrabVG, a visual grounding framework inspired by human visual search. In its scheme, it explicitly decomposes a grounding task into two sequential stages: preattentive hypothesis search and graph-attentive feature binding. Moreover, it generates a compact set of reliable object hypotheses through distillation-guided proposal induction and text-aware hypothesis filtering to reduce background distractions and semantic mismatches. Extensive experiments on AerialVG and AerialSense are reported to demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of proposed GrabVG framework.
Critical strengths
There are some Critical Strengths in this paper.
- It reformulates a crowded UAV visual grounding task as a search-before-binding problem, proposing a visual grounding framework GrabVG.
- Two strategies: preattentive hypothesis search and graph-attentive feature binding, are designed to enhance the visual grounding performance of GrabVG framework.
- Extensive experiments on two public datasets: AerialVG Liu et al. (2025) and AerialSense Guo et al. (2025) , are performed to demonstrate the effectivenss and superiority of proposed GrabVG framework.
Critical weaknesses
Although this paper has some highlights, it has some Critical Weaknesses.
- This paper is with limited novelty. The pimary ideas, including preattentive hypothesis search and graph-attentive feature binding, have been similarily explored in existing methods, e.g., [1] RCCF: Recursive Content-Candidate Filtering for Robust Visual Grounding, [2] QueryRec: Two-Stage Query refinement for Visual Grounding, [3] GraphDET: Graph-Attentive Topology Reasoning for UAV Small Object Detection, and [4] VR-GAT: Visual Relationship Graph Attention Transformer. Inspired by these methods, this paper uses the similar ideas to specially constuct a new framework for UAV Imagery scenes, limiting its orignal novelty and contributions.
- In the explanation to GrabVG framework, the definitions of some loss terms are missed, e.g., the L_filt and L. Moreover, for easily understanding, in Fig 2(a), it is better to briefly show how to compute its training loss.
- In experiments, e.g., Table 1 and Table 2, too few methods (especially 2026-published methods) are used for performance comparisons. In table 2, even no 2026-published method is compared. Moreover, only IoU metric is used for performance evaluation. Other metrics, e.g., mAP could be adopted? In Table 4, only Inference-speed is presented. For deep learning models, parameter scale and FLOPs are two usual metrics.
- The viualization evidences to demonstrate the effectivenss and superority of GrabVG are unsufficient. Only resutant evidences are demonstrated in experiments (including in Supplementary Material).
Questions for authors
I have some concerns for this paper. They are listed as follows. Please further clarify or explain them.
1.This paper is with limited novelty.
The pimary ideas, including preattentive hypothesis search and graph-attentive feature binding, have been similarily explored in existing methods, e.g., [1] RCCF: Recursive Content-Candidate Filtering for Robust Visual Grounding, [2] QueryRec: Two-Stage Query refinement for Visual Grounding, [3] GraphDET: Graph-Attentive Topology Reasoning for UAV Small Object Detection, and [4] VR-GAT: Visual Relationship Graph Attention Transformer. Inspired by these methods, this paper uses the similar ideas to specially constuct a new framework for UAV Imagery scenes, limiting its novelty and contributions.
2.Loss definition and presentation
In the explanation to GrabVG framework, the definitions of some loss terms are missed, e.g., the L_filt and L. Moreover, for easily understanding, in Fig 2(a), it is better to briefly show how to compute its training loss.
3.Compared methods and metrics
In experiments, e.g., Table 1 and Table 2, too few methods (especially 2026-published methods) are used for performance comparisons. In table 2, even no 2026-published method is compared. I wonder if these methods have truly contained the current SOTA ones in visual gounding field of UAV Imagery. Moreover, only IoU metric is used for performance evaluation. Other metrics, e.g., mAP could be adopted? In Table 4, only Inference-speed is presented. For deep learning models, parameter scale and FLOPs are two usual metrics.
4.Viualization evidences
The viualization evidences to demonstrate the effectivenss and superority of GrabVG are unsufficient. Only resutant evidences are demonstrated in experiments (including in Supplementary Material).