- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents GAUGE3D, which is a framework designed to assess and enhance the "coordinate-gauge consistency" in dense 3D visual-language grounding. The core observation is that a model's excellent performance in a single world coordinate system does not necessarily mean that it will maintain consistent performance when using equivalent coordinate transformation representations for the same RGB-D scene. Therefore, this paper defines corresponding transformation rules for different output modalities: geometric masks should be equivariant; the area pointed to by language localization should always be associated with the same physical entity; for queries independent of the coordinate system, the answers should remain unchanged; and for queries related to the coordinate system, the answers should be adjusted accordingly based on the corresponding coordinate transformation.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper demonstrates a very weak understanding and analysis of the problem, and the authors appear to lack even the most basic academic writing skills. As a result, the manuscript suffers from pervasive and serious issues in presentation and exposition, including, but not limited to, poorly defined mathematical formulations, inconsistent or inappropriate notation, and problematic formatting throughout the paper.
2.Moreover, the manuscript does not comply with the ICLR submission requirements. In particular, the paper exceeds the page limit specified by the official template. Given these substantial issues with both the technical understanding and the submission format, I recommend a direct desk rejection.
Questions for authors
see above