- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes RFMVC, a federated multi-view clustering method in which (i) each client learns a "denoised" representation "Z" ^"(m)" regularized by a fidelity term "‖" "X" ^"(m)" "-" "Z" ^"(m)" "‖" _"F" ^"2" and performs k-means-like clustering on the induced distance matrix, and (ii) the server couples the stacked indicator matrices with a tensor Schatten p-norm plus an auto-weighted client weighting "α" _"m" ^"r" . Experiments on six benchmarks report ACC/NMI/PUR, an ablation, parameter sensitivity and convergence curves.
Critical strengths
1.The problem setting (robustness of FMVC against client-side noise) is relevant and under-explored.
-
The optimization is fully worked out, and the use of cluster statistics ("N" _"k" "," "s" _"k" "," "q" _"k" ) to avoid materializing the distance matrix is a sensible practical choice (O(NCd_m) per iteration).
-
Only a scalar T^((m)) and the indicator Y^((m)) are uploaded, which is a lightweight communication design.
Critical weaknesses
- The title, abstract and contributions are entirely about noise, outliers and local distortions, yet all experiments use clean benchmarks. There is no noise injection, no outlier ratio sweep, no corrupted client, no comparison with robust (l_2,1/Huber/trimmed) clustering, and no Byzantine/abnormal-client analysis — even though the weighting in Eq. (14) can assign the largest weight to a collapsed (thus corrupted) client.
- FedMVL (Huang et al., 2022), FedDMVC (Chen et al., 2023) and TensorFMVC (Feng et al., 2024a) are discussed in the introduction but never compared, while only two FMVC methods are evaluated.
- Formulation and notation errors that block reproduction: Eq. (1) minimizes over α_m, which is a global variable under a cross-client constraint; Eq. (2) defines J^((m))circularly J^((m))=f_m (J^((m)),X^((m))) and J^((m)) is never defined; the dual variable W appears in Eqs. (4)–(6) without definition;
Questions for authors
What is the exact objective of ablation Case 1, and how do you exclude degeneration as the cause of its drop?