- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose a multimodal generative model with a clear structure, but the novelty of each modality is insufficient. For example, the use of circular convolution and ray-drop for LiDAR range images are existing and mature solutions.
Critical strengths
- It can generate LiDAR and RGB simultaneously and reaches 10 fps, which is relatively fast.
- Using cross-modal masks with 3D geometric constraints to suppress spurious alignment is intuitive.
Critical weaknesses
- The camera setup uses only 3 views and does not achieve full coverage.
- The authors claim closed-loop evaluation, but there are no true closed-loop evaluation experiments.
- The title is “xxx for Autonomous Driving,” but the work ultimately does not extend to trajectory planning; it is only data generation for AD scenes.
- Whether the use of independent short clips affects practical utility, e.g., cumulative error and related information cannot be analyzed.
- Insufficient comparison methods.
- The ablations are conducted on a 20-epoch checkpoint that has not fully converged, so the conclusions can only indicate relative trends.
- The details of the MoE are unclear.
- How exactly is the temporal decay applied?
- The mask construction is unclear: if objects move, is the mask still correct? What are the details of the Plücker for LiDAR method, and how is it specifically implemented?
Questions for authors
Please refer to weaknesses.