- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SurgCouple addresses surgical video question answering. It builds an Evidence Chain and a Reasoning Chain on a frozen Qwen3-VL-8B backbone. The model selects relevant clips, then uses earlier reasoning states to guide spatial and fine-grained evidence selection. A consistency verifier provides additional supervision during training. On SurgCoT, the authors report 89.31% final-answer accuracy and 58.92% joint accuracy across the three stages. The paper also includes component ablations and transfer results on two external datasets.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses a meaningful problem. Important changes in surgical videos are often brief and localized. Using global context to guide progressively finer evidence selection is a sensible approach. 2.Comparisons using the same backbone show substantial gains, especially in third-stage accuracy and joint accuracy across all three stages. These results support the value of hierarchical evidence selection for this task.
Critical weaknesses
1.The contribution of the central mechanism is not clearly isolated. Table 2 includes a coupling ablation, but the paper does not specify which connections or losses are removed. This makes it hard to tell whether the gains come from reasoning feedback or changes in evidence supervision and training. The evidence-matching rules are also underspecified. These gaps make the core results difficult to interpret and reproduce. 2.The claims about consistency verification are stronger than the evidence supports. The verifier distinguishes original chains from artificially corrupted ones. This does not establish that it can assess whether the evidence supports a conclusion. Joint accuracy only measures whether all three answers are correct. It does not directly measure reasoning consistency. In Figure 3, all three methods reach the correct final answer. The example shows better intermediate answers and localization, but does not establish that the final decision depends on the selected local evidence.
Questions for authors
1.Which modules, connections, and losses are retained or removed in the coupling ablation? Are evidence supervision and training settings kept the same? 2.How are temporal, spatial, and fine-grained predictions matched to the annotated evidence? Please provide the thresholds and matching rules. 3.Have you evaluated text-only inputs, mismatched videos, or inputs with key evidence masked out? These checks would help establish whether the model actually uses local visual information.