- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Projector-JEPA, a two-expert residual projector that improves world-dynamics understanding in Video-LLMs by explicitly modeling local motion and global state transitions. With Gated DeltaNet branches and JEPA-style auxiliary objectives, the proposed module can be plugged into pretrained Video-LLMs without modifying remaining architecture. Across models and benchmarks, Projector-JEPA consistently improves performance compared to the baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed Projector-JEPA is of a plug-and-play design, which can be easily applied to existing Video LLMs without additional modifications over their original architectures.
-
The idea of enhance spatial and temporal modeling with Gated DeltaNet and JEPA training objective is well-motivated.
-
The experiments are extensive and the performance improvements are consistent across models and benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
-
My major concern is the limited technical novelty. The proposed Projector-JEPA a more of a combination of existing techniques rather than a substantial novel spatial-temporal modeling mechanism for video understanding. In table2, the performance improvement of Full over State-only is relatively modest, which raises concerns about the justification of the dual-branch design.
-
The effectiveness of Projector-JEPA with different scales of training data remains unclear. As a plug-in module, it would be helpful to investigate whether the performance improvements over simpler adaption baselines will be consistent under varying training data scales.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
Final Request for Discussion and Feedback Before the Deadline
Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,
Thank you for your time and effort in evaluating our submission.
We submitted detailed rebuttal responses on November 8, including substantial additional experiments, analyses, and clarifications specifically addressing the concerns raised by all three reviewers. We also posted follow-up reminders on November 16. Unfortunately, we have not yet received any feedback or follow-up discussion.
With less than nine hours remaining before the discussion deadline, we must admit that this situation is somewhat disheartening. We invested considerable time and effort in conducting the additional experiments requested by the reviewers and submitted our responses early in the rebuttal period specifically to allow sufficient time for meaningful discussion. It would be particularly unfortunate if the discussion period were to conclude without any opportunity to learn whether these efforts have addressed the reviewers' concerns.
We would sincerely appreciate even a brief acknowledgment from the reviewers regarding whether their main concerns have been resolved or whether any questions remain. We would also be grateful if the Area Chair could help facilitate the discussion and ensure that our rebuttal and additional experimental evidence receive due consideration in the final assessment.
We fully understand the demanding schedules of everyone involved, and we remain deeply appreciative of your time and service to the reviewing process. Our hope is simply to have a meaningful opportunity for dialogue before the discussion period closes.
Best regards,
The Authors