- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper improves the accuracy and efficiency of OSFL by utilizing synthetic data and low-rank adaptation. The experimental results show significant improvements compared to the baseline methods.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- This paper proposes an OSFL method based on synthetic data, whereas the baseline methods are non-generative. Therefore, this comparison is unfair and does not prove that the proposed method is SOTA. I believe the authors should have compared it with methods such as FedBiP (CVPR'25) and Espresso (CVPR'26). Furthermore, there are also statistical FL methods based on synthetic data, and the authors should have included these in their comparison.
- The two contributions proposed in this paper are not novel in the field of FL. They are methods that have existed for some time. Therefore, this paper does not strike me as particularly innovative.
Questions for authors
I believe the paper has the following issues:
- This paper proposes an OSFL method based on synthetic data, whereas the baseline methods are non-generative. Therefore, this comparison is unfair and does not prove that the proposed method is SOTA. I believe the authors should have compared it with methods such as FedBiP (CVPR'25) and Espresso (CVPR'26). Furthermore, there are also statistical FL methods based on synthetic data, and the authors should have included these in their comparison.
- The two contributions proposed in this paper are not novel in the field of FL. They are methods that have existed for some time. Therefore, this paper does not strike me as particularly innovative.