- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses client-wise performance unfairness in federated person re-identification (ReID) under domain heterogeneity. The authors argue that conventional aggregation methods may suppress useful hard-domain information or amplify unreliable updates, leading to performance disparities. To address this, they propose FedHRA, which integrates reliability-aware client scoring, consensus-guided update projection and recovery, and adaptive aggregation. Experiments on four ReID datasets with ResNet50 and ViT backbones report notable improvements in average retrieval performance and worst-client accuracy.
Critical strengths
-
Meaningful Problem and Reasonable Motivation. The paper addresses an important client-wise fairness issue in federated ReID, with a reasonable and well-motivated problem formulation.
-
Promising Experimental Results. The experiments cover multiple ReID datasets and two backbone architectures (ResNet50 and ViT), demonstrating notable improvements in retrieval performance, particularly for underperforming clients.
Critical weaknesses
- The central motivation and mechanism of FedHRA remain insufficiently validated. The paper claims that the dilution of reliable hard-domain updates and unreliable fairness compensation are key causes of client-wise performance disparity. However, no direct empirical evidence is provided to establish these causes. More importantly, although FedHRA claims to selectively recover reliable identity-discriminative information from hard-client updates, its recovery mechanism simply scales the entire residual using a client-level reliability score, without distinguishing useful identity cues from noisy components. The current ablations only demonstrate performance improvements and do not establish that the proposed reliability score identifies meaningful updates or that the recovered residuals contain useful hard-domain information rather than noise. Therefore, I think the experimental evidence does not adequately substantiate the paper's central motivation and claimed mechanism.
- Inconsistent results and insufficient experimental details. Figure 1 and Table 1 report inconsistent results for FedFVand FedHRA Moreover, Figure 1 labels a baseline as FedAvg, although its reported values match FedPav in Table 1. Additionally, many essential implementation details are missing, including the optimizer, learning rate, batch size, local training epochs, key hyperparameter settings.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors provide more direct experimental evidence to validate the central claims and proposed mechanisms?
-
Could the authors clarify the discrepancies between Figure 1 and Table 1? Are they due to different experimental settings or a misunderstanding on my part?