- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
n/a
Critical strengths
n/a
Critical weaknesses
-
The title on OpenReview is inconsistent with the title in the PDF
-
The primary area listed on the OpenReview homepage is “learning theory,” but the main result is a diagnostic correlation analysis. Section 3, “FILTRATIONS AND OUTPUT LEARNABILITY,” does not appear to fall under learning theory. In my view, the paper does not fit the stated area and is therefore out of scope.
-
Finally, and most importantly, I believe that a substantial portion of the paper was generated by a large language model rather than written by the authors. The authors also acknowledge this in the AI USE STATEMENT. This appears to conflict with the iclr conference requirements.
Questions for authors
n/a
2 comments
Thank you for the authors' response.
First, consistency in the manuscript's title upon submission is a fundamental requirement that every author must carefully check and verify beforehand; mismatched titles run counter to a rigorous academic attitude. Second, Chapter 1 fails to adequately present the research motivation; Chapter 3 appears to be a mere accumulation of formulas without analyzing their internal connections, and lacks necessary discussion regarding generative recommendation, making it very obscure to read. Furthermore, relying extensively on large language models to write the paper without researchers carefully considering and overseeing its content is not encouraged by a rigorous research community. The declaration in the AI use statement cannot serve as a blanket exemption from responsibility. This is why the scores for Presentation, Informativeness, and Soundness are all very low.
Therefore, I will maintain my original rating.
Dear Reviewer,
We would like to address the three points raised in your review.
On AI use, we do not see a basis for the claim that our disclosed assistance conflicts with ICLR’s requirements. The conference’s AI policy permits assistance with writing and theoretical work, subject to disclosure and author responsibility. Our manuscript includes an AI-use statement, and we take responsibility for its claims, results, and implementation. Could you identify the specific policy provision that you believe has been violated?
The policy is here: https://iclr.cc/Conferences/2027/AIPolicyForAuthors
On scope, Section 3 studies how an item-to-code mapping changes the approximation error of a capacity-restricted predictor. Theorem 2, on page 5, establishes lower and upper bounds on the best attainable excess log-loss under explicit assumptions. The formal statements and proofs are in Appendix C.3. These results motivate GWT, whose relationship with trained prediction error is then investigated experimentally. This theoretical analysis is why we selected learning theory as the primary area.
You are correct about the title mismatch. This is a mistake on our side, and we will correct it.
We would also appreciate clarification of the specific technical concerns underlying your soundness rating. The review does not identify an error in a mathematical statement, proof, or experiment. Identifying those concerns would allow us to address them directly.