- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how the non-target target, e.g., image background, training data contributes to the memorization of target images in class-conditioned flow matching models. The authors show that by replacing same-class background images with distinct ones can significantly reduce the target extraction rate. In addition, this paper presents a paired-trajectory framework to track two branches, target-on and target-off to isolate target-induced parameter displacements and the background gradient response. The experiments show that reciprocally transferring background gradient responses between repeated and distinct regimes can affect target retention and copying rate.
Critical strengths
- The proposed paired-trajectory framework and the intervention is interesting and can show causal relation better.
Critical weaknesses
- The main empirical observation of the paper about repeated content drives memorization is fairly intuitive and expected. When replacing the images with repeated ones, I would expect the data diversity gets lower which makes it easier to memorize or extract the target.
- The paper uses several terms and notations without properly defined and explained, e.g., paired trajectory framework, reciprocal response transfer, the selection of target and background sets, the formulation of the losses for background data and target set, etc.
Questions for authors
- How the target set and background set are separated and constructed in the experiments?