- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
To analyze errors in results measured by evaluators, this study audits 200,328 Qwen3-8B candidates extracted from five benchmark-derived problem sets. The study uses 595 stratified reference labels, as well as individual follow-up and transfer studies. The findings of this study reveal that standard raters exhibit different "think/no-think" reporting patterns for the same output, and that the proposed mode-conditional false positive (FP)/false negative (FN) channel quantifies the underlying errors. Additionally, source code rules and surface rewriting identify deterministic extraction failures, and paired reference audits measure corrected and newly introduced errors. Error decomposition and inversion boundaries pinpoint the potential causes of the observed gaps.
Critical strengths
-
S1: A very detailed analysis has been conducted.
-
S2: This study is being conducted following a review of a vast amount of related research.
-
S3: Theoretical analyses and extensive experiments using multiple datasets have been conducted.
Critical weaknesses
-
W1: This paper is difficult to read and understand. One reason is the large number of parenthetical notes and references to the appendix. Additionally, the experimental results are simply listed without explaining the significance of numerical values.
-
W2: The problem statement should clearly be defined.
-
W3: It is difficult to understand the meaning of the main text without the knowledge provided in the Appendix.
-
W4: Figure 2 should be shown on page 5 or later.
-
W5: All necessary terms should be defined in the text.
Questions for authors
Starting in Section 4, the number of undefined terms increased. Without an explanation of the equations, I could not follow the discussion. Unless the author clarifies the research questions and organizes the text around them, readers unfamiliar with the field will be unable to understand it. Looking at the section on contributions, it appears that the author achieved significant results. Unfortunately, however, I could not grasp the details.
I would appreciate it if you could provide the following three pieces of information:
- What research questions do you aim to address in this paper?
- What results did you obtain in response to these questions?
- Which methods used in your analysis are novel and effective?
Thank you for the three direct questions and for noting the detailed analysis, related-work coverage, and multi-dataset experiments. I answer them in order.
1. What research questions do we address, and 2. What results did we obtain?
RQ1: Can grading rules reverse a think/no-think comparison on identical outputs? Yes. We held 200,328 Qwen3-8B responses fixed across five benchmark-derived item sets and varied only the grading rules. On MMLU, one extractor reports a think-minus-no-think gap of −15.7 points, while two others report +17.0 and +17.3 on the same outputs. The grading rule therefore changes the reported direction on identical outputs.
RQ2: How can we account for grading errors when comparing the two modes? We estimate false-positive and false-negative rates for each mode using stratified reference labels. An exact decomposition links these errors to the observed gap and gives the error-difference threshold at which the reported comparison reverses. At the per-cell level, 5 of 25 task–grader cells support a positive reference-accuracy gap, covering MATH and TriviaQA. After accounting for all comparisons together, the direction remains undecided. The reference-based intervals therefore make clear which comparisons the evidence supports.
RQ3: Does removing the reasoning segment reduce grading errors rather than merely raise scores? We count both repaired and newly introduced errors on the same records. In a separate MMLU follow-up of 240 Qwen records, 120 are think records and 51 change verdict. Against benchmark gold, all 51 changes are repairs. The estimated error reduction over all 2,560 think outputs has a 95% interval of [31.4, 44.8] points, while no-think verdicts remain unchanged. On GSM8K, removing the reasoning segment leaves every lm-eval flexible verdict unchanged. The measured repair effect is therefore task-specific.
3. Which methods in our analysis are novel and effective?
Our two contributions are:
Manuscript revisions. The revised manuscript is organized around these two contributions. It defines the notation in the main text and explains what the numerical results mean. Figure 2 is on page 18 of the revised PDF, satisfying your request that it appear on page 5 or later.