- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper focuses on the real scenario of apple mold core, which has internal defects, destructive labels, small samples, and cost sensitivity. A dedicated evaluation set was constructed, including LF-NMR images, expert text, fixed partitioning, and TAAPM protocol. The paper also conducted a systematic internal comparison and ablation under a unified setting, covering multiple baselines, retrieval sources, rational forms, and training objectives, with clear domain resource value. However, the scope of application of this work is relatively narrow, covering only a single variety, modality, season, and collection conditions, and the impact of general ML is limited; There are only 237 apples in the queue, with only 15-16 diseased samples per fold. As a core indicator, TAAPM still relies on a set of unproven fixed contract parameters and fixed thresholds, lacking sensitivity analysis. Therefore, the current results can only support the cost sensitive utility under this single queue and specific contract settings, and are not sufficient to support the claims of a universal benchmark or deployable method.
Critical strengths
- The paper focuses on the internal defect screening task of apple mold core. This task has several clear and genuine characteristics: defects are located inside the fruit, and there may be no significant changes on the surface; The label needs to be scanned and obtained through destructive inspection; The number of diseased samples is small and the categories are unbalanced; The cost of missed and false detections is asymmetric; Unable to obtain expert text during testing.
- The paper compared multiple types of baselines under a unified evaluation protocol, including zero shot and fine tuned versions of vision only VGG19 and Qwen3-VL 2B/4B/8B GPT-5-Instant、GPT-5-Thinking,And the author's two-stage system. The paper also includes text only BERT, Stage II oracle, and human expert controls, but these controls use additional text input and cannot be directly compared equivalently with the image only model.
Critical weaknesses
- The algorithm components of the paper are mainly a combination of existing methods, including Qwen3-VL, VGG19, BERT, LoRA, contrastive learning, EMA, and gated fusion; The paper did not propose new basic models, network structures, or learning objectives. Its contribution is more suitable for positioning as domain datasets, evaluation protocols, and system baselines, rather than innovation in general ML methods.
- The data only covers Red Fuji apples, mold core binary classification, LF-NMR modality, as well as single season, refrigeration protocol, operator, and collection day. The paper did not validate other apple varieties, other internal defects, other fruits, other scanners, or real production line conditions. Therefore, the external applicability of its conclusion is limited.
- There are only 237 apples in the queue, of which 79 are diseased samples. Each test set consists of 47-48 apples, with only 15-16 diseased samples. The statistical power is limited, and the differences in model ranking and small sample conditions may be unstable.
- The paper also did not provide sensitivity analysis of TAAPM to parameter perturbations, threshold scanning, calibration experiments under different disease rates, or comparison with accuracy/F1 ranking systems.
Questions for authors
Please refer to 'Weaknesses'.
Response to Reviewer BiKM
We sincerely thank you for your careful review and constructive comments on the contribution and evaluation. We apologize for our delayed response.
Contribution (Weakness 1).
Our contribution combines an LF-NMR dataset and benchmark, an evaluation protocol, and a documented reference system with component analysis. It links images, destructive labels, and expert-reviewed text; separates image-input and expert-text evaluations; and compares components under a shared quality gate.
Revision: Abstract and Sections 1–2.
Evaluation cohort and statistics (Weakness 3).
Each reported model metric covers all 237 apples per seed, including 79 diseased apples. The 47–48 apples belong to one fold. Metrics are computed after pooling five folds; mean and SD summarize three seed-level results:
Revision: Section 3/Table 1; Tables 3–5 captions; Supplementary E.1 and opening of F.
Controlled cohort (Weakness 2).
Standardized cultivar, season, batch, storage, operator, and acquisition reduce confounds. This enables controlled method comparison. Conclusions apply to this cohort and setting; external applicability needs separate evaluation.
Revision: Sections 3 and 7; Supplementary F.1.
TAAPM and conventional rankings (Weakness 4).
TAAPM combines shipment quality and procurement efficiency. Missed defects can violate the quality cap; rejecting healthy fruit raises procurement costs. Its operational objective can rank models differently from accuracy or F1. Table 3 reports both. Utility can be negative after the quality gate is passed if procurement costs exceed modeled revenue.
Revision: Sections 5 and 6.1/Table 3; Supplementary E.1–E.3.
Operational parameters (Weakness 4).
All methods use prespecified parameters. The 10% operational prior is the three-year factory average after upstream screening; the 5% shipment cap is the buyer's requirement. This prior differs from 79/237 in the cohort; utility refers to this factory setting.
Revision: Sections 5 and 7; Supplementary E.1–E.3.
Threshold sensitivity (Weakness 4).
We test 0.48, 0.50, and 0.52; the main threshold remains prespecified at 0.50. Four baselines change; other configurations remain unchanged. The full system reports TAAPM 393.733 ± 13.973 throughout this range. The hard gate can amplify small classification changes.
Supplementary Table S4. Threshold sensitivity. Mean ± SD across three seeds; 237 pooled apples per seed.
Revision: Section 5; Supplementary E.3/Table S4.
Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. We welcome further questions and suggestions and look forward to continuing the discussion.