- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Gatekeeper Arena, an offline benchmark for evaluating multimodal models on policy decisions that require latent longitudinal state beyond the current visual evidence. The benchmark includes fictional residents, Unreal Engine clips, a nine-role policy, and a three-stage lifecycle. Across 13 models, performance is close to chance and strongly deny-biased. FlyWire retains delayed synthetic input while trailing its rewired control on the gate task.
Critical strengths
-
The benchmark clearly separates current perception, longitudinal memory, and generic recurrent capacity.
-
Balanced accuracy, FAR, FRR, and unresolved rates are reported to reveal failure modes.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the paper motivates longitudinal memory, the main model evaluation uses an empty-context setting, while the recurrent track uses synthetic Rademacher inputs and frozen features rather than an end-to-end registration–familiarization–evaluation protocol.
- The task deliberately withholds the state needed for some decisions, so near-chance performance may primarily reflect task underdetermination rather than limitations in multimodal reasoning.
- The benchmark is narrow, with 100 fictional identities, 222 synthetic clips, one Chinese prompt, and one fixed policy, which limits external validity.
- The paper mentions an oracle-state ceiling but does not report empirical results for it, and does not include retrieval-based memory, profile-matching, or human baselines.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors evaluate the proposed registration–familiarization–evaluation lifecycle end to end?
- Why does the paper not report retrieval, profile-matching, human, or the stated oracle-state baselines?
Thanks for the rebuttal. Some of my concerns are addressed in this rebuttal. However, the rebuttal does not clearly report the end-to-end results of the evaluated models on the new track, and the retrieval, profile matching, and human baseline results are still missing. Furthermore, the synthetic scope of this benchmark is relatively narrow, which also limits its external validity. I therefore maintain my current rating.