- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper is very rough overall, clearly an auto-research work with no visualization, and poor figures.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
Omission of highly relevant prior work and insufficient justification for novelty. FlexiVideo (CVPR 2026) has already addressed the visual confusion caused by fixed two-frame encoding by proposing continuous adaptive segmentation and dynamic temporal patch embedding prior to visual encoding, while also offering a training-free version. The current paper fails to cite or compare against this work. Although EATP differs in its fixed-group dynamic programming and specific projection rules, the authors need to clearly articulate the substantive contributions arising from these differences and conduct a comparison against the closest method using matched backbones and computational budgets.
-
Ambiguity regarding the evaluation set version, raising issues with the comparability of external results. Section 4.1 describes the evaluation set as the original QVHighlights test split; however, the results cited in Table 2 for models like GPT-4o and Gemini actually originate from the re-annotated QVHighlights-TimeLens dataset, which features different query and temporal annotations compared to the original. The authors do not specify which version of the data was used for their local Qwen3.5-9B and EATP models. If the original dataset was used, the external results are not directly comparable; if the TimeLens version was used, the experimental protocol and table labels require correction.
-
Significant internal inconsistency in core results. For the EATP configuration described as having a 2 FPS / 768-frame budget, Table 2 reports mIoU, R@[email protected], and R@[email protected] values of 66.35 / 70.00 / 62.00, whereas Table 3 reports 65.26 / 67.00 / 60.00 (with Figure 2 also adopting the latter mIoU figure). Consequently, the reported mIoU gain shifts from +2.16 to +1.07, and the R@[email protected] gain shifts from +3.14 to +0.14. The paper offers no explanation for these discrepancies in configuration or evaluation; thus, the primary performance gains claimed in the abstract and main tables cannot currently be verified. 4. The ablation study on maximum group length fails to meet the stated control conditions. The lower section of Table 4 claims to fix the candidate stream while varying only , yet it includes a native baseline where . Under the main experimental setup, a 4 FPS candidate stream comprises approximately 4G frames; however, G groups with a maximum length of 2 can only accommodate 2G frames, making it impossible to cover the full set of candidates. Consequently, that specific row inevitably alters either the number of candidate frames or the output budget, disqualifying it as a controlled experiment isolating the effect of maximum group length. The authors should explicitly state the actual number of candidate frames and output tokens for each row.
-
Missing alignment rules between variable-length grouping and real-world time hinder reproducibility and result interpretation. While the paper notes that candidate frames possess real-world timestamps, it fails to define the representative time and duration for each variable-length group, or how these map to the model's temporal inputs and positional encodings. Given that different groups cover varying real-world durations, this information is critical for understanding the temporal grounding and chaptering mechanisms. The current description is insufficient to reproduce the temporal alignment process or to determine whether changes in temporal information processing influenced the gains in localization performance.
Questions for authors
N/A
Weakness 1 — prior work and novelty. Thank you for identifying FlexiVideo as a close predecessor. Section 2.2 now cites it, including its training-free variant. FlexiVideo forms segments using a visual-change threshold and transforms a shared temporal kernel, whereas EATP uses dynamic programming to assign all observed candidates to exactly the native number of groups under explicit group-size bounds and averages pretrained two-frame responses within each group. These distinctions define our contribution; they do not establish superior accuracy or wider applicability. A same-backbone, matched-budget comparison with FlexiVideo is still needed before claiming a performance advantage over it. Our reported gains are relative to the native and fixed-group controls.
Weakness 2 — which QVHighlights annotations were evaluated. Table 2 identifies our benchmark as QVHighlights-TimeLens. Its local Qwen3.5-9B baseline and EATP use the same TimeLens annotations and evaluation queries, allowing a direct comparison of the effect of EATP. We present the published TimeLens scores as benchmark references; differences in models and training mean they cannot isolate the effect of EATP. We will specify the exact TimeLens annotation version and the query and video counts for each local result, so readers can verify the evaluation set used.
Weakness 3 — results and the Kmax=2 control. Thank you for noting the differing scores. Table 2 and the Kmax=16 row of Table 4 use the selected setting and report 66.35/70.00/62.00 on QVHighlights. The EATP row at the 2-FPS downstream budget in Table 3 and the Kmax=8 row of Table 4 use a different group-length setting and report 65.31/67.00/60.00. Both EATP settings use nominal 4-FPS candidates and retain the native output-unit budget. Figure 2 now shows 66.35 for the Kmax=16 setting; we will label it in the figure. The native baseline reports 64.19/66.86/53.96. The Table 4 native-reference case has G output groups. With Kmax=2, at most 2G candidate frames fit, so this row cannot simultaneously use the approximately 4G candidates of the 4-FPS run. The comparable DP sweep begins at Kmax=4 and uses nominal 4-FPS candidates at the same G; when C=4G, its four-frame groups match Uniform K=4. We will report the actual candidate and output-group counts for each row and reconcile the VidChapters GRACE values of 61.10 (main) and 60.96 (ablation) before submission.
Weakness 4 — group timestamps and positional encoding. Section 3.4 now defines the observed interval of each group using the first and last candidate-frame timestamps and prepends that interval as text to the corresponding visual block. Each group produces one visual temporal unit, with the grid length fixed at G, so a group covering more seconds does not take more visual positions. We will clarify that the reported results retain the model's original visual positional encoding: a group's real duration is stated in its timestamp text, but does not rescale its visual positions. We tried changing the positional encoding for variable-length groups, but performance decreased in our preliminary experiments, so we kept the original encoding. We will explore other ways to represent real time in future work. The revised discussion also notes that the timestamp text may contribute to the localization gains, which therefore cannot be attributed solely to group-boundary placement.