- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper formulates multi-view color correction as a geometry-guided global optimization problem, where RGB-D observations are projected into a shared voxel space to establish cross-view correspondences, and per-view bilateral grids are optimized using a multi-objective color consensus to improve color consistency while preserving image fidelity.
Critical strengths
The problem is practical and relevant to multi-view imaging and 3D reconstruction.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The comparison is not sufficiently comprehensive. Recent 3D reconstruction and Gaussian Splatting works have already explored appearance, exposure, and ISP inconsistencies across views, e.g., WildGaussians: 3D Gaussian Splatting in the Wild, Bilateral Guided Radiance Field Processing, and Unifying Appearance Codes and Bilateral Grids for Driving Scene Gaussian Splatting. Some of these methods are also closely related to the proposed bilateral-grid formulation. The paper should include stronger comparisons with representative methods from this line of work, or clearly explain why they are not applicable. Otherwise, the specific advantage of the proposed voxel-consensus formulation remains unclear.
(2) The method heavily depends on accurate depth and camera poses, but this dependency is insufficiently analyzed.The paper acknowledges that errors in depth or pose can lead to incorrect observation mixing and degraded correction quality. I think the paper should further discuss whether color inconsistency itself affects depth/pose estimation in practical pipelines, and provide robustness experiments under controlled depth and pose perturbations.
(3) The presentation would benefit from a clearer overview figure.
(4) The qualitative results do not clearly demonstrate the claimed gain in multi-view consistency. The current visualization mainly shows corrected images, but does not sufficiently illustrate whether the same physical regions become more consistent across different viewpoints. Since cross-view consistency is the central claim, the paper should visualize multiple overlapping views of the same scene, preferably with corresponding regions highlighted or with difference maps before and after correction.
Questions for authors
No