- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies open-text underwater detection, where a natural-language description may refer to multiple objects through appearance, relations, and environmental context. It introduces AquaGround, a benchmark containing approximately 224K images, 894K instances, 2,363 categories, and 7.52M image–query records. The annotations provide four progressively enriched query levels and structured environmental attributes. The proposed AquaDetect uses six guidance scores to select aggregation centers, progressively merge visual tokens, and recover spatially organized features for detection. Experiments report 58.94 AP, exceeding OTA-Det-M by 5.22 points, together with improvements in visual grounding and component ablations.
Critical strengths
-
AquaGround is a potentially valuable benchmark for open-text underwater detection. It combines object annotations, multi-level descriptions, environmental attributes, and one-to-many query–instance associations at a substantial scale.
-
The proposed semantic-guided token aggregation and spatial recovery form a coherent design for language-conditioned detection. The reported improvements over OTA-Det-M and the component ablations provide encouraging evidence of its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
-
The inference setting is insufficiently clear. Appendix C.1 states that AquaDetect uses dataset-provided auxiliary descriptions and structured conditions during inference. It is unclear how these object-linked annotations are selected without knowing the target instances, and whether all baselines receive equivalent information. This makes it difficult to attribute the gains to the proposed method.
-
The reliability of the final query–instance associations needs stronger validation. Descriptions and matching sets are largely constructed automatically, but the reported expert checks do not separately quantify incorrect matches and missing valid targets. These errors could directly affect both training and evaluation.
-
The independence of the data splits is not established. The duplicate-removal procedure targets near-identical images but does not exclude related scenes or adjacent video frames across splits. Consequently, generalization to independent underwater scenes remains uncertain.
-
Some figures, particularly Figure 2, have an AI-generated appearance and differ noticeably from the other figures in color palette, line thickness, and typography. Although their origin cannot be determined from appearance alone, the inconsistent styling reduces visual coherence. Please improve their clarity and standardize the presentation across all figures.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify the exact inference inputs using a concrete example. How are object-linked auxiliary descriptions and environmental conditions selected without using ground-truth boxes or query–instance associations?
-
Do all baselines receive the same auxiliary information, including structured conditions? Please provide an image-plus-query comparison between AquaDetect and the strongest baseline to separate architectural gains from the benefit of additional inputs.
-
Has the final query–instance mapping been independently checked by humans? What are the rates of incorrect matches and missing valid targets, particularly for relational and multi-instance queries?
-
Are images from the same video, dive, or acquisition sequence kept within one split? If sequence information is available, can the authors report performance on a sequence-disjoint subset?