- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FTSD, a self-distillation method that does not require maintaining an additional persistent teacher model. The same model serves as both student and teacher: the student sees only the original problem and the current response prefix, while the teacher additionally sees a verified solution demonstration and provides token-level supervision.
To prevent the teacher targets from continually changing as the student is updated, the method stores selected historical teacher output probabilities as fixed targets for subsequent training. FTSD also suppresses tokens that the student favors excessively relative to the teacher and increases the weight of the reference-solution cross-entropy loss when the model repeatedly fails to solve a problem. Historical memories are additionally selected and updated based on solution quality and coverage.
The authors evaluate the method on scientific reasoning and tool-use tasks. Under the same wall-clock training budget, FTSD achieves better average performance, reduces the GPU memory overhead associated with persistent model copies, and shows better retention on benchmarks assessing capabilities outside the training task.
Critical strengths
-
Providing stable supervision by storing historical outputs has clear practical value.
FTSD stores sparse historical teacher output distributions as fixed targets, preventing these targets from changing immediately with every parameter update. This provides historical supervision without requiring a persistent copy of the teacher parameters. The paper reports a reduction in peak GPU memory from approximately 70 GB to 56 GB on Olmo3-7B-Instruct. This is a valuable improvement for resource-constrained training.
-
The full method achieves strong results and is evaluated from multiple perspectives.
Across five tasks and two base models, FTSD outperforms the compared methods in average performance within a five-hour budget. The authors report not only performance on the new tasks but also retention of existing capabilities, and compare settings that remove individual losses, use different sources of teacher demonstrations, or employ EMA teachers, parameter snapshots, and standard CE replay. These experiments suggest that the components of the full method have complementary effects and provide a foundation for further analysis.
Critical weaknesses
-
It remains unclear what additional information the same-model teacher provides after seeing a successful solution.
I understand that the current teacher prioritizes another verified successful response and explicitly excludes the response that the student is currently learning from. Therefore, current teacher supervision should not simply be characterized as copying the same answer. However, historical targets are constructed differently: according to Equation (11) and the STORE procedure in the appendix, when storing a successful trajectory, the method can use that trajectory itself as the demonstration and compute teacher distributions along its own prefixes.
In this setting, the teacher may become more confident because the demonstration activates reasoning knowledge already present in the model, or because the continuation already appears in the context, making the solution easier to reproduce. Both mechanisms may benefit training, but they lead to different interpretations of the method. Moreover, verification of a complete solution does not imply that every local judgment made by the teacher along an arbitrary prefix is more reliable; this is particularly relevant to the interpretation of suppressing tokens that the student overvalues.
In addition, reference solutions enter training through multiple pathways, including fallback teacher demonstrations, memory initialization and historical targets, and reliability-adaptive CE. The fact that the method remains effective after removing CE in Table 2 does not rule out the influence of reference information through other pathways. The paper already compares demonstration sources and CE replay, but it does not sufficiently disentangle the gains from demonstration content, reference information, and fixed historical targets.
-
Retention on other tasks is strong, but the results cannot yet be directly attributed to temporal memory.
Figure 5 and Table 3 in the appendix do show that FTSD performs well on several benchmarks of existing capabilities. My concern is not the absence of forgetting evaluations, but why these improvements should be attributed to the temporal loss.
The temporal loss primarily constrains problems and retained trajectories from the current training task; it does not directly replay the tasks used to evaluate existing capabilities. Furthermore, the stored historical targets come from a teacher that has seen additional demonstrations, rather than representing the pretrained model’s behavior on the original inputs. Preserving historical outputs on training problems therefore does not automatically amount to protecting existing capabilities on other tasks.
Removing the temporal loss in Table 2 reduces new-task performance, but this does not establish its independent contribution to retention on other tasks. The full method also includes reference supervision, demonstration selection, and other training constraints. The current results do not sufficiently distinguish whether temporal memory mainly preserves behaviors learned early on the new task or actually reduces damage to general capabilities.
Questions for authors
-
Does the teacher’s effectiveness mainly come from the reasoning process, the final answer, or textual cues in the demonstration?
With other conditions held constant, could you compare demonstrations containing the full solution, only the final answer, and a paraphrased solution that preserves the reasoning content? This would help identify which information is primarily responsible for the teacher’s improvement.
For the historical STORE procedure, I would also appreciate a comparison between using the retained trajectory itself as the demonstration and using another independently generated successful trajectory. When the demonstration is the very trajectory being stored, what evidence shows that the historical distribution provides guidance beyond repeated learning from that solution? For example, can it still provide useful corrections under different wording or erroneous prefixes, rather than merely predicting the next token of the original trajectory more accurately?
-
Could you directly evaluate the contribution of the temporal loss to retaining capabilities outside the training task?
While keeping the other components unchanged, could you also report existing-capability benchmark results for settings without the temporal loss, with standard CE replay, and with fixed historical-distribution replay? These comparisons should control for the training budget and, where possible, compare checkpoints with similar new-task performance.
Such experiments would help answer whether more stable outputs on training problems actually correspond to less forgetting on other tasks. Does temporal memory primarily preserve solutions learned early on the new task, or does it also preserve behaviors useful for other capabilities? If the latter explanation holds, I would appreciate more direct evidence.
-
What additional benefit does temporal memory provide when access to reference-solution information is held constant?
I would like the authors to separately control the three pathways through which reference solutions enter training: fallback teacher demonstrations, memory initialization and the associated historical targets, and adaptive CE. This does not require changing the verifier used to judge correctness; rather, it requires controlling how reference-solution content enters the supervision.
With these pathways held constant, how much additional benefit do fixed historical distributions provide over standard reference supervision, CE replay on the same trajectories, and teacher targets recomputed at each update?
Figure 7 in the appendix already reports usage counts for different demonstration sources and changes in the losses, which is helpful. However, usage frequency or loss magnitude does not directly measure a component’s contribution to final performance. Could you further use controlled experiments that enable the relevant pathways only early or late in training to establish the roles of the three reference-solution pathways during cold start and subsequent training?
4 comments
Author Rebuttal (Part 2/3)
W.2 Attribution of Knowledge Retention to Temporal Consolidation & Q.2 Effect of Temporal Loss on Existing Capabilities
Response
We agree that preserving historical predictions on training problems does not necessarily guarantee retention on unrelated tasks. While preserves previously acquired privileged predictions through fixed historical targets (Eq. 13), FTSD does not explicitly replay examples from the existing-capability benchmarks.
To isolate this contribution, we extend the ablations on Olmo3-7B-Instruct across Biology and Tool Use, comparing function-space caching, w/o , and CE replay of , while keeping the remaining components and training configurations unchanged. We evaluate retention across the same five prior-capability benchmarks in Table 3 at the 5-hour checkpoint and at approximately matched new-task accuracy. For matching, we select checkpoints within 0.5 percentage points of the weakest variant's new-task accuracy, separately for each training task.
Table: Effect of temporal consolidation on PRIOR-capability retention for Olmo3-7B-Instruct (mean accuracy across five benchmarks, %). Matched columns control for new-task accuracy.
| Setting | Biology (5h) | Tool Use (5h) | Biology (Matched) | Tool Use (Matched) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Function-space cache (ours) | 60.9 | 59.5 | 61.0 | 60.2 |
| w/o | 59.0 | 57.7 | 59.4 | 58.6 |
| CE replay of | 59.3 | 58.0 | 59.1 | 58.9 |
| SDPO (on-policy, Table 3) | 59.6 | 58.7 | — | — |
The results provide three observations:
- Temporal contribution: At 5 hours, FTSD improves prior-capability retention over removing by 1.9 points on Biology and 1.8 on Tool Use.
- Beyond trajectory replay: Fixed historical distributions outperform CE trajectory replay by 1.6 and 1.5 points, respectively, suggesting that preserving privileged predictive information provides benefits beyond replaying retained solutions.
- Matched new-task performance: FTSD maintains higher prior-capability retention than both alternatives even at comparable new-task accuracy, with improvements of at least 1.3 points across the two benchmarks.
These results provide direct evidence that temporal consolidation improves retention of capabilities outside the adaptation task, rather than merely improving new-task performance. While the mechanism is consistent with historical supervision constraining policy updates, the experiments do not establish that parameter drift is the sole explanation or guarantee retention across arbitrary domains. We will incorporate these controlled comparisons and clarify this distinction in the final revised manuscript.
Q.3 Reference Supervision Pathways and the Contribution of Temporal Memory
Response
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion to disentangle reference supervision from temporal consolidation and examine their contributions throughout training. FTSD preferentially retains verified self-generated trajectories, while reference information enters through fallback demonstrations, memory initialization, and reliability-adaptive CE. We agree that the usage statistics in Figure 7 do not establish their independent contributions.
We first compare fixed historical distributions against recomputed privileged targets, alongside removing temporal consolidation and CE replay of the same retained trajectories. The fixed and recomputed variants preserve the remaining objectives, reference pathways, memory selection, and replay configurations, isolating the effect of temporal separation.
Table: Effect of historical supervision mechanisms on Olmo3-7B-Instruct (best avg@16 within 5 h, %).
| Setting | Biology (%) | Tool Use (%) | Avg. (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Function-space cache (ours) | 62.3 | 66.6 | 64.5 |
| w/o | 59.9 | 60.3 | 60.1 |
| CE replay of | 58.7 | 58.3 | 58.5 |
| Recomputed privileged targets | 60.2 | 62.4 | 61.3 |
Fixed targets outperform recomputed targets by 3.2 points (64.5% versus 61.3%), demonstrating the benefit of temporal separation beyond reference access and trajectory reuse. Removing temporal consolidation yields 60.1%, while trajectory-level CE replay achieves 58.5%, further supporting the value of historical privileged distributions. Unlike the immediate-refresh ablation (, Table 4, Case 10), which retains periodic staggered refresh, the recomputed variant updates privileged targets at every optimization step.
Author Rebuttal (Part 3/3)
Q.3 Reference Supervision Pathways and the Contribution of Temporal Memory (continued)
We further isolate the three reference pathways while preserving the verifier and remaining training configuration.
Table: Ablation of reference supervision pathways on Olmo3-7B-Instruct (best avg@16 within 5 h, %).
| Setting | Biology (%) | Tool Use (%) | Avg. (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full objective (ours) | 62.3 | 66.6 | 64.5 |
| w/o reference fallback demonstrations | 61.1 | 64.2 | 62.7 |
| w/o reference memory initialization | 61.4 | 65.0 | 63.2 |
| w/o | 59.1 | 64.3 | 61.7 |
Each pathway contributes to final performance, with removing producing the largest reduction (2.8 points), followed by reference fallback (1.8 points) and memory initialization (1.3 points).
To examine their temporal roles, we additionally restrict fallback demonstrations and CE supervision to the early (first 2.5 h) or late (remaining 2.5 h) phase. Reference memory initialization is separately tested through delayed seeding. We report final-checkpoint accuracy to ensure consistent comparisons among phase-specific variants.
Table: Phase-specific activation of reference pathways on Olmo3-7B-Instruct (FINAL-checkpoint avg@16 accuracy at 5 h, %).
| Setting | Biology (%) | Tool Use (%) | Avg. (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full objective (ours) | 61.8 | 65.9 | 63.9 |
| Reference fallback (early only) | 61.2 | 65.2 | 63.2 |
| Reference fallback (late only) | 61.0 | 64.4 | 62.7 |
| Reference memory initialization (delayed) | 61.1 | 64.9 | 63.0 |
| (early only) | 61.0 | 65.8 | 63.4 |
| (late only) | 58.9 | 64.1 | 61.5 |
The phase-specific results show that:
- Early reference supervision is more beneficial: Early-only fallback and CE achieve 63.2% and 63.4%, respectively, compared with 62.7% and 61.5% when restricted to the late phase.
- Memory initialization timing matters: Delaying reference seeding reduces final accuracy from 63.9% to 63.0%, supporting its role in establishing useful historical supervision early in training.
- Temporal consolidation provides a distinct benefit: Fixed historical targets outperform recomputed targets even when reference pathways are held constant, indicating that the gains cannot be attributed solely to reference supervision.
Together, these findings support the complementary roles of early reference grounding and temporally fixed privileged supervision. We will incorporate these controlled comparisons and clarify their relationship to the training dynamics in Figure 7 in the final revised manuscript.
Happy to have further discussion!
A quick Follow-up
Dear, Reviewer,
Just a quick followup if there are any concern with the response.
Hope we addressed all the concern raised by the reviewer and it will help to raise the reviewers score.
We are happy to discuss if reviewer has any further concern.
Thanks
Author Rebuttal (Part 1/3)
Dear Reviewer Vpc4,
We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback and recognition of FTSD's practical value, memory efficiency, and experimental results. The key concerns raised by the reviewer concern privileged supervision, temporal consolidation, and reference grounding. We address these concerns below and will incorporate the corresponding clarifications and experimental findings into the revised manuscript.
W.1 Source of Privileged Information and Historical Target Construction & Q.1 Demonstration Content and STORE ProcedureResponseFTSD uses a single policy under two conditioning contexts: current supervision uses a distinct verified sibling (Eqs. 3–4), while historical STORE may self-condition (Eq. 11). This preserves temporally fixed privileged predictions without guaranteeing every local judgment, so Lneg uses margin-based correction. On Olmo3-7B-Instruct (Biology, Tool Use), we examine:
Table: Demonstration content and historical target ablation on Olmo3-7B-Instruct (best avg@16 within 5 h, %).
The token-level analysis uses a fixed checkpoint and STORE's prompt format on problems with ≥2 verified successes (yA, yB) and ≥1 failed rollout, removing the fallback. The teacher conditioned on yA is scored on prefixes of the unseen yB; an unrelated demonstration controls for added context, and conditioning on yB is the copy reference.
Table: Token-level prediction of an unseen verified solution yB.
Table: Teacher behavior at the first erroneous decision of failed rollouts (wrong option; wrong tool call/argument) (%).
Though near-copy at top-1, self-conditioned targets are not trajectory replay: cached distributions beat CE replay of the same trajectories (Table 2, Case 3: 64.5% vs. 58.5%), so the retained soft mass matters. Thus, privileged predictions provide transferable, solution-level guidance and correct erroneous decisions, not merely encoding the retained solution. We will extend this to perturbed-prefix recovery in the revision.