acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

From Memory Access to Evidence Satisfaction: Diagnosing and Resolving Demand–Evidence Misalignment

Abstract

Long-term memory systems are typically optimized to preserve and retrieve records relevant to a later query. Yet relevance is an item-level property, whereas answering is a set-level requirement: the retrieved evidence must jointly establish the facts, relations, temporal conditions, and state constraints required by the question. We characterize this challenge as demand–evidence misalignment and introduce MemPath, an interventional diagnostic framework that traces the transformation from historical information to answer-supporting evidence across the memory lifecycle. Across representative systems, MemPath reveals that improving individual memory stages does not necessarily ensure sufficient evidence for answering, as failures can arise from insufficient access, incomplete demand coverage, or ineffective evidence utilization. Guided by this diagnosis, we propose BiDE-Mem, a demand-guided evidence construction framework that represents questions as typed demands, retrieves and organizes supporting evidence, and aligns the constructed evidence with these demands before answer generation. BiDE-Mem improves accuracy by 6.23 points on LoCoMo and achieves 91.80% overall accuracy on LongMemEval, with particularly strong results on multi-hop and multi-session reasoning. Ablations and evidence-level analyses attribute these gains to improved demand coverage and evidence organization rather than evidence quantity alone. Our results highlight that effective long-term memory requires not only accessing relevant information, but also constructing evidence that satisfies the requirements of the current question. We release our code at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/BIDE-8507.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Long-Term Memory, Agents, Memory Diagnosis, Demand–Evidence Alignment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_khFcOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the mismatch between "demands" and "evidence" within long-term memory systems, distinguishing between "retrieval relevance" and "evidential sufficiency." It introduces a diagnostic framework called MemPath, which examines the accessibility of source information, the completeness of demands, and the success of answer retrieval under the condition of "ideal evidence intervention"—a scenario assuming the acquisition of perfect evidence. Building on this analysis, the BiDE-Mem framework incorporates "Typed Question Demands" to guide memory access and evidence construction, ensuring the alignment of demands and evidence prior to generation. Experimental results on the LoCoMo and LongMemEval datasets demonstrate the superior performance of this approach; furthermore, the study validates its effectiveness through component ablation experiments and analysis at the evidence level.

Critical strengths

MemPath goes beyond focusing solely on end-to-end accuracy; it also examines evidence accessibility, requirement coverage, and answer recovery via interventions, thereby offering valuable insights into the issue of memory failure.

On the LoCoMo task, BiDE-Mem achieves a significant boost in accuracy by sharing an answer-generation model, while simultaneously requiring fewer input tokens for the reader compared to several strong baseline models.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Regarding Figure 2. Figure 2a shows that, within a diagnostic subset of 250 questions, ReadAgent achieved a "demand-complete" status for 41.2% of the questions (i.e., 103 questions). However, Figure 2b identifies 164 cases as "covered but wrong." If both subfigures utilize the same subset and the same criteria for "completeness," the latter figure should not exceed the total number of "demand-complete" questions. The authors are requested to clarify the sample sets, denominators, and definitions used for both subfigures, and to correct the data in the figures if necessary.

  2. Regarding the transparency of the human review process. Appendix B.2 mentions the creation of a "human-reviewed demand annotation set," consisting of 250 LoCoMo questions and 425 "question demands." The authors should specify the number and qualifications of the annotators/reviewers, the detailed guidelines provided for annotation and review, the mechanisms for resolving disagreements, and—if applicable—the inter-annotator agreement metrics. Furthermore, please clarify whether the human review was limited to this diagnostic subset or if it encompassed all 2,517 demands.

Questions for authors

A minor point regarding source-based demand coverage. Table 10 defines "supporting sources" as source IDs; Appendix B.3 defines AiA_i as the set of annotated supporting sources for a given demand did_i, using Ai⊆SA_i \subseteq S as the criterion for "fully supported." Consequently, AiA_i represents source identifiers rather than the actual content of the evidence. When constructing SS, did the authors merely verify the presence of the source IDs, or did they also confirm that the information required to satisfy the demand was indeed preserved within the evaluation context? This distinction is critical, especially in the context of "compressed memories"—retaining a source ID does not necessarily imply that the required evidentiary content has been preserved.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Diagnostic Consistency, Human Review, and Evidence Coverage

We thank the reviewer for identifying the Figure 2 inconsistency and raising questions about annotation and source coverage. We have corrected the figure and clarified the statistics, human review, and evidence checks.

1. Figure 2: Error Correction and Statistical Definitions

The reviewer is correct about the inconsistency. In the original Figure 2b, the value 164 for ReadAgent was its total number of initially incorrect answers on the 250-question subset, but was placed under Covered but wrong. It did not represent 164 demand-complete incorrect cases. Figure 2a's value, 103/250 (41.20%), was the question-level demand-complete count and remains valid. The corrected Figure 2 replaces the error-routing panel with (a) question-level source-grounded demand completeness and (b) oracle evidence-intervention recovery.

The 250 questions / 425 demands across six systems yield 1,500 system–question cases, including 915 initially incorrect. The aggregate intervention records include 869 valid cases per setting. Evidence-only replaces the original context with reviewed supporting evidence; Combined integrates that evidence with the existing context. Both keep the Reader and answer-generation procedure unchanged. Evidence-only recovers 404/869 (46.49%) and Combined recovers 476/869 (54.78%).

Source-grounded completeness is measured over questions per system, while intervention recovery uses initially incorrect system–question cases. The aggregate records do not establish identical case membership across the two interventions or item-level exclusion reasons for the remaining 46 errors. We report these rates descriptively, not as a matched-pair significance comparison. The revised Section 2.2 and Appendix B.3 specify the definitions and denominators.

2. Demand Annotation and Human Review

We used an LLM-assisted annotation followed by human cross-review. The LLM drafted atomic Question Demands from the question, reference answer, and supporting sources. Two PhD researchers with relevant expertise participated in checking (i) whether the demands covered all necessary answer requirements, (ii) whether decomposition was atomic and the Fact, Relation, Temporal, State, Constraint types were applied consistently, and (iii) whether each demand was grounded in its annotated supporting sources without unsupported inferences.

The two inventories serve different purposes: 250 questions / 425 reviewed demands form the human-reviewed MemPath subset for cross-system diagnosis; 1,540 questions / 2,517 annotated demands form the full-scale offline BiDE-Mem coverage analysis. The latter is not claimed to have received independent dual human review. The retained records lack independent initial label sets, per-reviewer workloads, and complete disagreement-resolution records; hence, no inter-annotator agreement statistic is inferred (Appendix B.2).

Gold demands, reference answers, and annotated sources are offline evaluation inputs, not supplied to online QueryFrame, retrieval, evidence assembly, or answering.

3. Source-grounded Coverage in Compressed Memories

We agree that retaining a source ID does not prove that the required content survives compression. For demand did_i, AiA_i denotes its annotated supporting-source set, and Si(EQ)S_i(E_Q) denotes the sources whose demand-relevant information is retained in the observed evidence context. Our all-support criterion remains Ai⊆Si(EQ)A_i \subseteq S_i(E_Q); this definition is shared across memory representations.

For uncompressed, source-preserving records, source IDs are matched to the accessible original content. For compressed summaries or structured memories, we additionally inspect the retained representation through demand-indexed semantic mapping: it must preserve relevant entities, relation direction, temporal scope, polarity/state changes, or constraints as required by did_i.

For example, a summary retaining a source ID but dropping a required date does not count as support for that Temporal demand, even if it preserves information supporting a different demand. Thus, semantic preservation determines whether a source counts as retained for that demand; it does not replace or relax the source-grounded all-support rule.

Source-grounded completeness measures annotated supporting-information availability, not guaranteed answer correctness. It is distinct from the Reader's ability to use that evidence; the oracle interventions provide complementary evidence about answer recovery. These clarifications appear in Section 2.2 and Appendix B.3.

We appreciate the reviewer's careful reading, which helped us correct Figure 2 and make the annotation and evidence-coverage protocols more transparent.

Thank you for the detailed response and corrections. However, I am not convinced that my main concerns have been resolved, so I will maintain my original score.

Reviewer_p3KyOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the demand–evidence misalignment problem in personalized memory systems, where required information may be inaccessible, incompletely covered, or ineffective utilized for answering. The authors propose MemPath to trace the memory pathway and diagnose these failure modes, and then introduce BiDE-Mem to align structured question demands with supporting evidence. BiDE-Mem achieves strong performance on two benchmarks, while ablation and evidence-level analyses further support the identified misalignment and the effectiveness of the proposed approach.

Critical strengths

S1. The paper introduces MemPath as a unified pathway for monitoring the lifecycle of heterogeneous memory systems, enabling a systematic analysis of different failure modes, including source inaccessibility, incomplete demand coverage, and ineffective evidence utilization. This provides a useful perspective for diagnosing demand–evidence misalignment beyond end-to-end answer accuracy. S2. The proposed BiDE-Mem provides a coherent solution to the identified misalignment problem by structuring both question demands and memory representations, enabling demand-guided retrieval and evidence construction, followed by demand–evidence verification before answer generation. The corresponding design addresses the different failure modes identified by MemPath and achieves strong performance on both evaluated benchmarks.

Critical weaknesses

W1. BiDE-Mem introduces a complex pipeline with multi-channel retrieval, LLM-based reranking, evidence reorganization, and verification, but the reported token statistics do not capture these intermediate costs. Without latency/cost analysis or equal-budget comparisons, it is unclear whether the performance gains come from the proposed method or the additional computational budget. W2. Removing the retrieval and reranking components leads to the largest performance drop, but this component combines multi-channel retrieval with a Qwen-based reranker. The current ablation therefore cannot disentangle their individual contributions, especially since MemPath shows that most systems can already retrieve a substantial amount of relevant information.

Questions for authors

Q1. The robustness of the proposed pipeline under errors in intermediate stages is unclear. Since QueryFrame directly determines the question demands used for retrieval and evidence construction, how does the method handle incorrectly formatted or incomplete demands? Similarly, how robust is the final answer when the evidence–demand alignment is incorrectly judged? Q2. The current ablation study does not fully disentangle the contributions of individual components. In particular, could the authors clarify the respective contributions of evidence reorganization and evidence serialization in the post-retrieval processing stage, as well as those of multi-channel retrieval and reranking? Q3. The implementation of demand-conditioned retrieval is not sufficiently clear. Given a specific Question Demand, how does BiDE-Mem determine which retrieval channel(s) to activate? Is the channel selection explicitly defined according to the demand type/QueryFrame, or determined automatically by the model? Q4. BiDE-Mem involves multiple retrieval channels, reranking, LLM-based processing, evidence construction, and verification. Could the authors provide an end-to-end analysis of inference cost, such as latency, number of model calls, and token consumption, to better assess the practical efficiency of the proposed framework?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Robustness, Component Contributions, and Computational Efficiency

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We provide finer-grained ablations, implementation clarifications, and stage-level cost accounting.

Q1. Robustness to errors in QueryFrame and evidence alignment

QueryFrame validation checks required JSON fields, query types, nonempty retrieval fields, and temporal fields when applicable. Malformed outputs trigger bounded correction attempts; terminal failures are recorded. Such checks prevent malformed requests from proceeding, but a well-formed QueryFrame can still omit an answer requirement.

Evidence assembly preserves original text, provenance, timestamps, and session/turn order to ground Reader outputs. The formal ZQZ_Q defines four support states (satisfied, partial, conflicting, unmet). In Full's evaluated compact path, evidence links, grouping, and Reader guidance convey support information, without a separate four-state verifier; the ALIGN/VERIFY pilot is not part of Full.

Importantly, provenance lets the Reader inspect the underlying evidence rather than rely on an unsupported support label, but this is not a measured guarantee against semantic errors. We do not claim quantified robustness to schema-valid semantic mistakes or incorrect support assessments (Appendices C.4 and D.2).

Q2. Disentangling retrieval, reranking, and post-retrieval processing

All comparisons use the LoCoMo GPT-5.4-mini / Top20 protocol (1,540 questions). Retrieval and reranking results are:

Table 1. Retrieval × Reranking (Accuracy, %)

RetrievalNo rerankerWith reranker
Single dense channel75.5884.48
Multiple channels84.8191.49

Reranking gains are +8.90/+6.68 points with single/multiple channels; multichannel gains are +9.23/+7.01 points without/with reranking.

The paired single-channel run has 181 incorrect-to-correct versus 44 correct-to-incorrect transitions (net +137/1,540). Reranking changes Top20 membership. The original 68.83% joint-removal result uses a different fallback and should not be interpreted as the single-channel/no-reranking cell. The multichannel comparisons are setting-level contrasts; the single-channel reranking effect additionally has paired outcomes.

For post-retrieval processing, dialogue_blocks preserves event, temporal, and provenance structure; reading_guide provides Reader-facing interpretation guidance.

Table 2. Reader-input Field Comparisons (Accuracy, %)

ConfigurationAccuracy
Full (submitted reference)91.49
Matched assembly control86.49
Without dialogue_blocks85.26
Without reading_guide85.97
Without both fields84.55

Joint removal gives 84.55% versus the 86.49% matched archived control (30 fewer correct; −1.95 points). The submitted Full (91.49%) is a reference, not the matched control.

Thus, these field interventions support the role of evidence organization and Reader guidance beyond access alone, but do not isolate the entire serialization pipeline or a separate verifier (Section 4.3; Appendix E.3).

Q3. How demands determine retrieval channels

QueryFrame encodes entities, owner/answer roles, relation/event cues, temporal constraints, and retrieval operations. These fields condition Clause, Occurrence, Structural, Multivector, SPLADE, and Typed-L2.

Typed-L2 matches structured assertions; Occurrence expands linked entity/event records. Candidate matches are projected back to raw source IDs; ranked lists undergo reciprocal-rank fusion and deduplication before reranking and Top-K selection. This retains access to original evidence even when a structured assertion provides the initial match.

Thus, demands shape query construction and evidence matching, not fixed demand-type-to-channel switches or an extra generative routing call (Section 3.3; Appendix C.3).

Q4. What the cost numbers include

For the measured Qwen3.8-27B LoCoMo compact path, distinct from the GPT ablations, the normal path uses two generative calls/question (QueryFrame + Reader).

Mean usage is 2,740.65 input / 349.27 output tokens/question: QueryFrame 447.16/290.15, Reader 2,293.48/59.12 (input/output; totals before rounding).

Five measured retrieval stages take 0.59 s/question batch-amortized; local Qwen3-8B reranking takes 4.35 s/question; Reader requests average 5.24 s. The local reranker incurs compute, not an additional generative call. Offline construction, judging, and retries are separately accounted for; calls hidden inside system services require their own traces.

These stages have different measurement coverage, so we neither sum them as measured E2E latency nor claim a matched seven-system E2E cost ranking (Section 4.5; Appendix F).

We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions, which helped clarify the method and its measured costs.

The rebuttal has addressed some of my previous concerns, particularly regarding component contributions and computational costs. However, two issues remain insufficiently clarified. First, it is unclear whether all six retrieval channels are executed for every question, with QueryFrame conditioning the retrieval process within each channel, or whether only a subset of channels is dynamically activated based on the encoded demands. These two settings imply different retrieval mechanisms and computational costs, but the current response does not specify which is implemented. Second, although the authors describe evidence organization, provenance, and Reader guidance, they do not explain how the system explicitly determines whether the constructed evidence satisfies each individual demand. Given that the actual Full configuration does not employ an independent four-state verifier, it remains unclear how demand–evidence alignment is assessed in practice, rather than merely providing potentially relevant evidence to the Reader.

We thank the reviewer for the follow-up questions. We agree that our previous response did not sufficiently distinguish retrieval-channel execution from demand-based conditioning, or evidence association from explicit demand-satisfaction assessment. We clarify both aspects below.

1. Retrieval-Channel Execution and QueryFrame Conditioning

All six retrieval families are executed for each question in the implemented six-family Qwen LoCoMo retrieval path. BiDE-Mem does not dynamically activate a subset of channels according to demand types.

QueryFrame is generated once and provides structured fields, including target entities, owner/answer roles, relation and event cues, temporal constraints, and lexical expansions. Each retrieval family uses the relevant fields according to its own retrieval mechanism. For example, Typed-L2 uses entity, relation, event, and temporal cues to match structured assertions, while Occurrence expands records through entity/event and provenance relationships.

The six families are Clause, Occurrence, Structural, Multivector, SPLADE, and Typed-L2. Their ranked results are aggregated within each family and combined using reciprocal-rank fusion (RRF), followed by source-ID deduplication, reranking, and Top-K selection. Each retrieval lane contributes at most 128 ranked records. A channel may return no matching candidates for a particular question, but it is not dynamically skipped based on a demand-type routing decision. This is therefore fixed six-family execution with QueryFrame-conditioned retrieval within each family, rather than demand-dependent channel activation.

2. Practical Demand–Evidence Alignment in the Full Configuration

We thank the reviewer for pointing out that our previous explanation did not sufficiently clarify how demand–evidence alignment is realized in practice.

During the development of BiDE-Mem, we explored an explicit multi-step ALIGN/VERIFY implementation. It examines individual Question Demands, associates each demand with its supporting evidence, and checks for missing conditions and conflicting information before answer generation. This provides an explicit mechanism for inspecting demand-level evidence support, but introduces additional model calls, intermediate processing, and inference latency.

In refining the system, we explored a more efficient alternative: incorporating demand-oriented checking principles into evidence organization and Reader instructions. Instead of invoking a separate generative verification process, the final Full configuration uses reading_guide to direct the Reader's attention to the question requirements and their corresponding evidence. The organized context preserves relevant provenance, entity/event relationships, temporal information, and state changes, helping the Reader assess the available support when formulating its answer.

This compact implementation was adopted as a practical balance between demand-aware evidence utilization and inference cost. It retains demand-related guidance within the final Reader generation, but does not produce the same explicit per-demand verification records as the iterative ALIGN/VERIFY implementation.

We appreciate the reviewer's follow-up questions, which have helped us clarify the actual retrieval execution and the distinction between formal alignment semantics and their implementation in the evaluated Full configuration.

Reviewer_FJGDOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper separates item-level retrieval relevance from set-level evidence sufficiency. It introduces MemPath, which diagnoses six memory systems on LoCoMo through source accessibility, demand completeness and oracle-evidence interventions. It then proposes BiDE-Mem, which represents each question as typed demands, retrieves and organizes evidence per demand, and aligns the evidence back to the demands before answering. BiDE-Mem reaches 91.49% on LoCoMo, against 85.26% for the strongest baseline under a shared reader, and 91.80% on LongMemEval.

Critical strengths
  1. A useful diagnostic perspective. The interventional analysis shows that access and sufficiency are distinct bottlenecks. For example, ReadAgent has 99.87% prompt coverage but only 74.48% accuracy (Table 1).
  2. Strong, efficient LoCoMo results under a shared GPT-5.4-mini reader. Multi-hop accuracy rises from 75.89 to 87.59, and the Top10 variant uses about 1.3K tokens. The ablation without post-retrieval processing keeps the same recall but loses 6.9 points, which directly supports the access vs. evidence-construction distinction.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evaluation process lacks consistent control to some extent. The benchmark data for LongMemEval is derived from various "readers" and "judges," and its advantage over Mnemis is marginal, appearing only in the context of a single question (91.80 vs. 91.60). Furthermore, in the LoCoMo evaluation, the model used as the "judge" is identical to the model used as the "reader."
  2. The methodology lacks clear, detailed specifications. It remains ambiguous how "demands" are mapped to the six retrieval channels, nor is it specified how "alignment states" are generated. Due to the absence of a "query-decomposition" baseline built upon the same retrieval architecture, it is difficult to isolate the performance gains attributable to "typed demands" from the contributions of the powerful retriever and reranker employed by the system.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you rerun Mem0 and Mnemis on LongMemEval with your reader and judge, and add a judge from a different model family on LoCoMo?
  2. How does BiDE-Mem compare with the same retrieval stack plus standard query decomposition? Please also specify the demand-to-channel mapping and how Z_Q is produced.
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Evaluation Comparability, Typed Demands, and Implementation

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the value of MemPath and BiDE-Mem and for the constructive questions. We have added a unified generative-LLM evaluation, independent cross-model judging, demand-related ablations, and implementation details.

1. Evaluation Comparability and Independent Judges

In the original LoCoMo evaluation, BiDE-Mem achieves 91.49% using the shared GPT-5.4-mini Reader, versus 85.26% for Mnemis (+6.23 percentage points). The original LongMemEval score (91.80%) was compared with published baselines using different configurations; we now report a separate seven-system evaluation.

In the supplementary experiments, Qwen3.8-27B is used for all generative LLM operations executed by each system, including memory processing, query/agent operations, and answering where applicable. We assess 1,540 LoCoMo and 500 LongMemEval-S questions. For each saved answer, we use Qwen3.8-27B and GPT-5.4-mini as two Judges, following the benchmark judging protocols.

Table 1. Supplementary accuracy (%; one Reader output scored by each Judge)

Dataset / JudgeBiDE-MemMnemisEverMemOSMem0MIRIXReadAgentMemoryBank
LoCoMo / Qwen86.4384.4282.9265.5270.9171.8246.30
LoCoMo / GPT-5.4-mini89.9487.5386.4372.7375.8475.9749.09
LongMemEval-S / Qwen84.6078.4077.4069.4050.8046.2039.60
LongMemEval-S / GPT-5.4-mini88.4084.4080.0070.4057.8051.0040.80

BiDE-Mem attains the highest overall accuracy on both benchmarks under both Judges. Against Mnemis, its gains are 2.01/2.40 points on LoCoMo and 6.20/4.00 points on LongMemEval-S (Qwen/GPT Judges). On LoCoMo multi-hop questions, gains are 6.03/7.45 points; on LongMemEval-S temporal questions, 15.04/12.78 points. Improvements vary by category.

We standardize executed generative LLM operations, not the memory architectures, retrieval components, or budgets. Mnemis on LongMemEval-S uses author-released memory contexts rather than rebuilding them. The revised Sections 4.1–4.2 and Appendices A and E document these settings and the selected results.

2. Typed Demands versus Standard Query Decomposition

BiDE-Mem represents answer requirements—including entities, roles, relations, temporal/state conditions, and constraints—through QueryFrame rather than relying solely on retrieval subquestions. Under the unified LoCoMo GPT-5.4-mini / Top20 ablation protocol, we obtain:

ConfigurationAccuracy
Full BiDE-Mem91.49%
Standard Query Decomposition87.60%
Without demand-conditioned retrieval86.69%
Without explicit demands78.70%

Standard Query Decomposition uses the same retrieval stack and reaches 87.60%, a 3.89-point difference from Full. Removing demand-conditioned retrieval or explicit demands yields 86.69% and 78.70%, respectively. These configuration-level comparisons support explicit answer-requirement modeling beyond query decomposition. Appendix E.3 specifies the changed input fields and archived controls.

3. Demand-conditioned Retrieval and ZQZ_Q

QueryFrame encodes target entities, owner/answer roles, relation and event cues, temporal constraints, and retrieval operations. These fields condition six complementary families: Clause, Occurrence, Structural, Multivector, SPLADE, and Typed-L2. For example, Typed-L2 matches structured assertions using entity/relation/temporal cues, while Occurrence expands entity/event-linked records. Results are fused, deduplicated, reranked, and selected under Top-K. There is no fixed one-to-one demand-type/channel routing rule.

The formal mapping ZQZ_Q describes demand–evidence associations and consistency, using satisfied, partial, conflicting, and unmet as semantic states. In the evaluated compact path, provenance, evidence grouping, and Reader guidance convey demand-relevant support; no independent four-state object or generative ALIGN/VERIFY call is required. The separate ALIGN/VERIFY pilot is not included in Full. The normal compact online path uses one QueryFrame generation and one Reader generation; retrieval and reranking have separate non-generative costs (Sections 3.2–3.4; Appendices C, D, F).

We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions, which have helped us clarify both the evaluation protocol and the implemented demand–evidence mechanism.

Comments on the paper

6 comments

Hi everyone,

I came across this paper while looking for research on long-term memory, and the title caught my attention. I am interested in the gap between retrieving relevant memories and obtaining enough evidence to answer a question. I was hoping for a deeper analysis, but came away somewhat disappointed.

I found the concept of “bidirectional alignment” underspecified. The paper does not make clear how support from multiple pieces of evidence is aggregated, how the resulting information is passed to the Reader, or how it affects the answer. Fortunately, the authors provide code. Looking through it, I found that the retrieval pipeline essentially turns the whole question into a structured query, retrieves candidates through multiple channels, merges and reranks them, and takes the top K. Query-guided retrieval, evidence organization, and gap detection have already been explored in work such as EviMem and GraphMemix. In this pipeline, much of the terminology and notation in the paper seems to add a layer of packaging to a familiar workflow. This left me puzzled. At what point do the “per-demand” and “bidirectional” aspects emphasized throughout the paper actually change the system’s behavior?

More strikingly, the main experiment notes (BIDE/docs/MAIN_EXPERIMENT_IMPLEMENTATION.md) say that the current Full configuration lacks a stable per-demand closure mechanism and that ZQZ_Q is not an independently validated demand satisfaction state. In the released answering pipeline, the Reader first generates an answer from the question and evidence. A checker then examines that answer, and the system retrieves more evidence and answers again if needed. The first Reader call does not receive the ZQZ_Q described in the paper. If I understand correctly, as far as the main experiment can be traced through the public materials, the per-demand verification and explicit alignment states emphasized in the paper have yet to be established as stable, independently validated mechanisms. This surprised me, because they seem central to the method.

The same document reports 88.70% accuracy for a single Reader pass in the Full Top20 setting. The result reaches the paper’s 91.49% only after subsequent corrections, selection, and adjudication. I could not find a detailed account of these steps in the paper, so it is hard to tell where the 2.79 percentage points came from or whether Full and the ablated variants in Table 4 were evaluated under the same rules. There are other serious issues in the code as well. For example, it passes has_answer to the memory model, exposing which dialogue turns contain evidence needed for the current question while the model is still constructing its memory. If the reported LongMemEval result used this path, it would be difficult to compare that score directly with those of systems that did not receive the same annotations.

Beyond these concrete issues, I have to say that phrases like “user confirmation” and the notes on what can and cannot be claimed read like handoff notes from an AI coding agent. I have no objection to using AI to assist with research. What concerns me is that the notes clearly spell out the limits of what the implementation and experiments support, while the paper describes the core mechanism and its empirical gains in substantially stronger terms. This makes the paper’s conclusions about the effectiveness of that mechanism hard for me to accept. I suspect the authors may have relied too heavily on AI to drive the implementation and shape the paper’s narrative, with too little checking before submission that the paper’s claims, the code’s behavior, and what the experiments actually measured all lined up.

The topic is why I was willing to spend time reading the paper closely. However, after going through the paper and released code, though, I struggle to see what it adds to prior work. Overall, it seems to repackage familiar techniques for decomposition, retrieval, reranking, and evidence organization, and may also credit the method itself for gains from additional corrections, selection, and review. Where does long-term memory fail, and why? Is the evidence missing from the original memory, missed during retrieval, or available to the Reader but poorly used? When does ordinary question decomposition fall short enough to require explicit demand modeling? These more fundamental questions remain largely unanswered.

I spent quite a bit of time, and a few tokens, reading this paper closely. The questions that came up along the way prompted me to write this comment. I hope these observations help readers assess the paper’s claims and give the authors a basis for clarifying their method and improving the evaluation. I sincerely hope this paper can deepen our understanding of why retrieved memories often fall short of providing enoughevidence to answer a question.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Research Motivation and Core Contributions

We sincerely thank the commenter for carefully examining our paper, code, and experimental documentation. We particularly appreciate the interest in the central question motivating our work: why retrieving relevant long-term memories does not necessarily provide sufficient evidence for answering a question.

We recognize that several aspects of our methodology, result provenance, and released implementation could have been explained more clearly. We would like to provide additional clarification on four points.

1. Research Motivation and Core Contributions

First, we would like to clarify that our work does not aim to introduce query decomposition, retrieval, reranking, or evidence organization as individually new components.

Our central research question concerns the gap between memory accessibility and evidence sufficiency in long-term memory systems.

Retrieving information related to a question does not necessarily mean that the retrieved information satisfies all the conditions required for answering. A question may depend on multiple facts, entity relationships, temporal conditions, state transitions, or constraints distributed across different historical records.

For example, answering what someone finally decided after changing their plans may require information about the original plan, the change event, the subsequent decision, and their temporal relationships. Retrieving one or several relevant records does not necessarily establish the complete answer.

Furthermore, even when the necessary information reaches the Reader, the model may still fail to combine or utilize it correctly.

We therefore distinguish three related but different aspects of memory utilization: memory accessibility, evidence sufficiency, and answer correctness.

To investigate this problem, we first introduce MemPath, which analyzes memory failures from three complementary perspectives.

Lifecycle accessibility examines whether required historical information is retained, retrieved, and made available to the Reader.

Demand-level evidence coverage examines whether the available information satisfies the specific facts, relations, temporal conditions, states, and constraints required by a question.

Oracle interventions investigate whether changing the available evidence can recover previously incorrect answers.

These analyses show that failures can arise from different stages of memory utilization. Some information may be inaccessible; other information may be retrieved but insufficient; and even sufficiently informative evidence may not be used correctly.

Building on these findings, BiDE-Mem investigates a demand-oriented approach to memory processing.

Rather than treating relevance as the sole objective, we use answer requirements as a shared reference for memory preparation, evidence acquisition, organization, and utilization.

Our contribution is therefore not a collection of new retrieval components, but a different way of guiding and coordinating memory processing: moving from retrieving question-relevant records toward constructing evidence that jointly satisfies answer requirements.

This diagnosis-to-method perspective connects MemPath and BiDE-Mem.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Demand-aware Processing, Bidirectional Alignment, and Z_Q

2. Demand-aware Processing, Bidirectional Alignment, and Z_Q

We would also like to clarify that demand-aware processing is not simply equivalent to decomposing a question into multiple retrieval subqueries.

Our approach considers answer requirements across both offline memory preparation and online question answering.

Offline memory preparation. Since future questions are unknown when memory is constructed, we consider potential information requirements when determining what historical information should be preserved and organized.

For example, a future question may depend not only on an individual's final decision but also on the previous plan, the time of a change, or the reason for that change. Preserving relations, event sequences, temporal dependencies, state transitions, and provenance makes historical memory more useful for different future questions.

This does not assume access to future benchmark questions or their answers. Rather, the objective is to preserve reusable information that may be needed to satisfy different classes of answer requirements.

Online question-specific processing. When a question Q arrives, its concrete requirements are represented by D(Q).

These requirements guide the acquisition and organization of evidence according to the information actually needed for answering.

For example, questions about someone's original plan, final decision, or reason for changing that decision may concern the same historical records but require different evidence and relationships.

Thus, demand-aware processing is intended to connect memory preparation and question-specific evidence utilization through a shared perspective on answer requirements.

Bidirectional alignment describes two complementary directions.

The forward direction, Demand → Evidence, uses answer requirements to guide what information should be preserved, accessed, and organized.

The reverse direction, Evidence → Demand, characterizes which requirements are actually supported by the obtained evidence, including whether several records must be combined and whether some requirements remain incomplete or inconsistent.

This distinction matters because relevant evidence is not necessarily sufficient evidence.

A demand may require several complementary records, while a single record may contribute to multiple demands. The completeness of the resulting evidence therefore depends not only on individual records but also on their relationships.

The role of Z_Q.

In our formulation, Z_Q represents the demand–evidence support mapping between the question-specific requirements D(Q) and the constructed evidence E_Q.

It describes three related aspects.

First, it identifies which evidence supports each requirement.

Second, it characterizes how multiple records jointly contribute to satisfying a requirement, including necessary temporal, relational, or state dependencies.

Third, it describes the extent of support, which may be satisfied, partial, conflicting, or unmet.

For instance, a record describing a final decision may support the factual component of a question, but it may not establish whether that decision occurred after a particular change. Additional evidence about the change event and temporal order may be necessary.

Z_Q is not an additional source of factual information or a substitute for answer generation. Its purpose is to characterize the support relationships between the available evidence and the conditions required by the question.

Our emphasis on bidirectional alignment is therefore not intended to add terminology to ordinary retrieval. It reflects the objective of using answer requirements to guide evidence construction and examining the resulting evidence in terms of the requirements it supports.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.