- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a tabular diffusion model that represents rows as graphs, where nodes are column attributes and (soft) edges are learned, and uses a graph neural network-based denoiser to learn the reverse diffusion process. The denoiser network and the graph edge weights are jointly trained via a regularized TabDiff-style [1] denoising loss. The paper also proposes a (optional) way to initialize the graph edge weights using an external LLM and the available schema information.
Critical strengths
The proposed methodology is a clean and useful application of graph models to tabular data generation, explicitly capturing inter-column dependencies.
Critical weaknesses
- The advantage of the proposed method is not clear from the reported experiments, which do not match the initial motivation. Specifically, when looking at the main metrics for inter-column dependency evaluation (Trend and alpha-Precision), GDiffTable performs very similarly to the most similar diffusion baseline, TabDiff (Table 2): 97.92 vs. 97.86 on Trend and 97.99 vs. 97.76 on alpha-Precision. Missing statistical significance tests make the evaluation harder to assess.
- Additional experiments are needed to assess the benefits of the proposed graph component. One suggestion is to test whether the proposed method can produce high-quality synthetic data using fewer denoising steps than diffusion baselines. An alternative could be to evaluate the method on more complex datasets, where the baselines could fail.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors elaborate on [Their reverse process, however, must recover coherent feature relationships from states in which the evidence for those relationships has itself been corrupted.] (L39-41)? How is this different than marginal distributions or diffusion models in other domains?
- How is Equation (1) derived?
- What is the "common early-stopping criterion" (L450-451)?
- Some hyperparameter details are missing. E.g., how many GNN layers are used? What is the total number of parameters?
References
[1] Shi, Juntong, et al. "Tabdiff: a mixed-type diffusion model for tabular data generation." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2025. 2025.