- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Deep Latent Learning (DLL), a training framework that extends conventional autoregressive prediction by introducing layer-wise latent supervision. In addition to predicting the next observable target, DLL encourages the model to predict the latent representations of the next step across multiple network layers. The proposed method introduces a self-purification module to align latent targets with observable targets, together with latent prediction modules that predict these representations from the current hidden state. These auxiliary modules are used only during training and introduce no additional inference-time overhead. The authors evaluate DLL across computer vision, natural language processing, and time-series forecasting tasks and report improvements over conventional training baselines on several benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The paper explores using latent representation prediction as an auxiliary training objective for autoregressive models. The proposed framework is relatively straightforward to integrate into existing architectures without modifying their inference procedures.
-
The experiments cover multiple domains and model architectures. The authors also provide ablation studies and computational overhead measurements to investigate the contributions and costs of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed method appears to be an incremental combination of existing techniques, including latent representation prediction, representation alignment, deep supervision, and stop-gradient-based training. These ideas have been extensively explored in previous representation learning and self-distillation methods. The proposed objective resembles the use of multiple auxiliary prediction heads for next-step prediction. The paper does not convincingly demonstrate that this particular combination provides a fundamentally new learning mechanism or a substantial methodological contribution beyond existing latent prediction and representation alignment approaches.
-
Although the authors report improvements across multiple benchmarks, the performance gains are generally modest. For example, the ImageNet-1K accuracy improves from 83.8% to 83.9% on ViT-Base compared with NEPA. The reported gains do not convincingly establish the superiority or necessity of the proposed training framework, particularly given its limited methodological novelty.
-
The full DLL framework increases training FLOPs per step by approximately 51–52% and peak memory usage by 28–31% compared with the baseline. Despite this additional computational cost, the reported performance improvements remain relatively small across most benchmarks. Given the additional training complexity and computational requirements, the current experimental evidence does not convincingly justify the practical benefits of DLL over simpler training approaches.
Questions for authors
-
What is the fundamental methodological novelty of DLL compared with existing representation alignment, latent prediction, and deep supervision methods? In particular, how does the proposed framework differ from introducing multiple auxiliary next-step prediction heads? Could the authors provide more direct comparisons with these simpler alternatives?
-
Can the authors provide stronger empirical evidence that deep layer-wise latent supervision offers substantial benefits beyond existing training objectives? The current improvements are generally modest, and the ablation studies do not fully establish that the proposed latent supervision mechanism is necessary. Comparisons against alternative auxiliary supervision methods would help clarify the contribution.
-
How does DLL perform under matched training compute budgets? Given the approximately 51–52% increase in training FLOPs per step for the full method, could the authors compare DLL with baselines trained using equivalent total FLOPs or training time? This would help determine whether the reported improvements justify the additional computational cost.
3 comments
I thank the authors for the response. However, my main concerns are still unsolved. The novelty of the proposed method is limited. It largely increases computational cost, while the gains are small. I will maintain my original ratings.
Dear reviewer,
We have addressed all your concerns individually. More specifically, we have explained how layer subsampling hugely reduces computational cost while maintaining most of the gains; we also explained why gains small in magnitude do not imply triviality in the context of the benchmarks. Could you please specify which concerns remain unsolved? Thank you.
Dear reviewer,
Thank you for the valuable comments. We have submitted a revised PDF (changes marked in blue).
(i) Methodological contribution: deep supervision, representation alignment, and latent prediction.
Deep supervision. Deeply-Supervised Nets (Lee, Xie et al., AISTATS 2015) attach auxiliary heads to hidden layers and train them using ground-truth targets, providing direct supervision to intermediate representations and helping mitigate vanishing-gradient issues during training. Subsequent residual connections and normalization schemes offer more direct and elegant ways to address this issue. DLL instead constructs additional predictive targets. Its distinction is explicit:
Representation alignment. For example, CLIP aligns image/text pairs; distillation matches teacher/student outputs or features. DLL instead predicts next-position, depth-specific targets that incorporate xt+1, using only the prefix through t: a causal prediction task, not same-input teacher imitation or cross-modal matching.
Layer-wise latent prediction. NEPA targets input patch embeddings; NITP uses shallow representations. Original I-JEPA/V-JEPA predict target-encoder outputs, and LLM-JEPA uses last-token/last-layer embeddings. To the best of our knowledge, DLL is the first autoregressive training framework to jointly predict observation-grounded next-step latent targets separately at every depth of the same backbone, using its current final-layer state and without maintaining a separate teacher backbone.
Hierarchical modeling. H-JEPA, first posted in October 2026, after our submission, independently supports the motivation for hierarchical latent prediction. It builds separate JEPA levels at coarser temporal strides; DLL reuses one backbone's depth hierarchy at a fixed next-step offset.
(ii) Effectiveness of layer-wise latent supervision.
We additionally evaluated final-layer-only supervision and have added the result in Table 6 and Figure 4:
Full DLL outperforms both single-layer alternatives, supporting the utility of targets from multiple depths in this setting.
(iii) Magnitude and consistency of the improvements.
We agree that the +0.1 percentage-point ImageNet gain on ViT-B is small in magnitude. However, small in magnitude does not imply triviality. Table 1's top-tier ImageNet baselines differ by tenths of a percentage point: 85.2% (BEiT-L/JEPA-L), 85.3% (NEPA-L), 85.6% (MAE-L). DLL reaches 86.0%, reversing the NTP-versus-MIM paradigm ordering in this comparison; its gains over NEPA are +0.1/+0.7 points on ViT-B/L. The larger gain on ViT-L suggests that DLL’s benefits increase with model scale, consistent with the depth and embedding-size ablations in Section 4.6.
According to Table 4, adjacent foundation-model entries on GIFT-Eval leaderboard differ at the third decimal: MASE 0.699/0.698/0.696 for Toto-1B/Chronos-2/Toto-2.5B, and CRPS 0.478/0.476/0.474 for Zeus/Toto-2.5B/t0-beta. Our gains are of the same scale but non-trivial.
(iv) Training overhead and matched-compute evaluation.
Section 5 and Appendix A quantify the trade-off: full DLL adds 51–52% forward FLOPs and 28–31% peak memory. Layer subsampling (r=0.3), motivated by representation similarity between neighboring layers, reduces these overheads to 16% and 13–18%, retaining 90% of the TableBench gain and 81%/92% of the Toto MASE/CRPS reductions.
We have not yet conducted an equal-total-FLOPs or wall-clock comparison. However, Table 14 shows that DLL with 3 layers slightly outperforms the 7-layer baseline (MSE 0.7022 vs. 0.7059), using 43% as many layers. With half as many training slices (2 vs. 4), DLL also achieves comparable MSE (0.7049 vs. 0.7059). Table 1 also shows that DLL outperforms MAE on ViT-L (86.0% vs. 85.6%) with only half the epochs (800 vs. 1600).