- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
UniSeek provides a simple and straightforward unified framework for four referring expression localization tasks. By reusing the native visual features of Qwen3-VL and incorporating lightweight modules, it achieves strong performance across multiple benchmarks.
Critical strengths
Unified Framework: UniSeek provides a simple and coherent framework that unifies REC, RES, GREC, and GRES, supporting both bounding-box and mask predictions with varying target counts.
Strong Experimental Performance: The method achieves strong results across multiple benchmarks, particularly in REC and GREC, demonstrating its effectiveness in referring expression localization.
Critical weaknesses
Limited Methodological Novelty and Missing Key Ablation Studies for the Core Architectural Designs.
Questions for authors
Rating and Rebuttal Considerations
Regarding my rating, I initially intended to give this paper a Borderline score and then either maintain or increase my rating depending on the authors' rebuttal. If the authors satisfactorily address my concerns, I would be willing to increase my score from 2 to 3.
Weaknesses
1. Limited Methodological Novelty.
The core designs of this paper overlap substantially with existing research. For example, CoHD and HieA2G have already explored explicit target counting, while GSVA and PixelLM utilize the hidden states of special MLLM tokens for downstream segmentation. Moreover, DETR and SAM provide well-established foundations for task-specific geometric decoding. Similarly, PixelLM and Qwen3-VL-Seg have investigated native visual feature reuse and lightweight spatial feature enhancement.
Therefore, the main novelty of this work appears to lie in the integration of these existing techniques, particularly the unified interface that constrains instance-slot generation based on predicted target counts. While such an integration has practical value, it remains unclear what distinct and indispensable technical advantages the proposed design offers over existing approaches.
2. Missing Key Ablation Studies for the Core Architectural Designs.
Considering that Count-Guided Instance Slots constitute one of the main methodological contributions, I believe the current ablation studies are insufficient to fully demonstrate the necessity of this mechanism. In particular, I have the following questions:
(a) Why is it necessary to predict the target count before generating instance slots? I suggest comparing Count-Guided Slots with conventional fixed-size Instance Queries under otherwise comparable settings.
(b) Does explicit counting actually improve the localization of complete target sets? Table 6 primarily reports N-acc and T-acc. I suggest additionally reporting Exact Counting Accuracy and GREC Strict Set-Matching Accuracy for the same ablation configurations.
(c) Do the performance improvements mainly come from the auxiliary Counting Loss or from Constrained Decoding? I suggest disentangling these two components by always retaining the Count Token while independently enabling or disabling the auxiliary Counting Loss and the count-based constraints during decoding.
I understand that conducting all these experiments may be challenging within the rebuttal period. If the authors have already performed such experiments, reporting the results would be helpful. Otherwise, I would particularly appreciate the comparison in (a). The evaluation proposed in (b) should be relatively straightforward if the corresponding trained checkpoints are available, as it mainly requires additional inference and evaluation.
3. Missing Comparisons with Important Recent Baselines.
The REC experiments do not include WeDetect-Ref-4B, published at CVPR 2026, which achieves higher performance than UniSeek-8B on certain RefCOCO/RefCOCOg splits.
Similarly, the GRES experiments omit several relevant methods, including DeRIS-L, CoHD, and SSDE.
I recommend including these methods in the experimental comparisons to provide a more comprehensive assessment of UniSeek's competitiveness against recent approaches.
4. Insufficient Analysis of Computational Efficiency.
The paper emphasizes its Lightweight Add-ons and reports that the newly introduced modules contain approximately 28M parameters. However, the overall framework still relies on a multi-billion-parameter MLLM backbone and generates instance slots autoregressively.
Therefore, a small number of additional parameters does not necessarily imply efficient end-to-end inference.
I suggest reporting actual inference latency, FLOPs, throughput (e.g., FPS), and peak GPU memory consumption, particularly the inference cost under different numbers of target instances.
Additional Suggestions
The following comments are relatively minor and would not substantially affect my overall rating.
1. Figure 1 could be improved in terms of presentation and clarity.
The current layout appears somewhat simplistic, with considerable unused whitespace. I suggest making better use of the available rectangular space to improve the visual organization. In addition, Figure 1 lacks some important annotations and explanations, which makes the architecture less intuitive to follow.
2. Consider streamlining the main performance tables.
I would suggest reducing the number of non-MLLM-based methods in the main comparison tables. Including a few representative state-of-the-art approaches, or prioritizing more recent methods (e.g., those published in or after 2025), may make the comparisons more focused and easier to interpret. Other baselines could be moved to the appendix.
3. Key ablation results should be presented in the main paper.
Ablation studies that directly establish the necessity and effectiveness of the core architectural contributions should be included in the main text rather than being placed only in the appendix.
4. The abstract could better motivate the proposed method.
The abstract would benefit from a clearer explanation of the key limitations of existing approaches. Ideally, it should first identify the main challenges that previous methods have not adequately addressed, then explain how UniSeek specifically tackles these challenges and what improvements or new capabilities it provides. This would make the motivation and contributions more compelling.