- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Hybrid Generalization-aware Parameter Selection (HGPS), a test-time adaptation strategy for all-in-one image restoration under distribution shifts. The method combines Fisher-based parameter importance with cross-view gradient agreement to identify parameters that are both safe and beneficial to update. Specifically, HGPS preserves high-importance parameters while selecting adaptation parameters based on gradient consistency within a fixed update budget.
Critical strengths
-
Exploring test-time adaptation for all-in-one image restoration is an interesting and meaningful direction, as it enables restoration models to adapt to unseen degradations and improves their generalization to real-world scenarios.
-
The proposed method is flexible and plug-and-play, allowing easy integration into existing Fisher-based test-time adaptation frameworks without modifying their original optimization objectives or adaptation pipelines.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experimental evaluation is not sufficiently comprehensive. The proposed method is only validated on three backbone architectures, and comparisons with several recent state-of-the-art all-in-one image restoration methods, such as MoCE-IR, are missing.
-
The computational complexity analysis is insufficient. The paper does not provide quantitative comparisons of FLOPs, GPU memory consumption, or actual test-time adaptation latency.
-
The real-world experimental validation remains insufficient. More comprehensive evaluations across diverse real-world degradation distributions are needed to further demonstrate the robustness and generalization capability of the proposed method.
-
The proposed cross-view gradient agreement score relies on dividing eight augmented views into two fixed groups, as described in Eq. (4). What is the motivation behind this specific grouping strategy? How sensitive is the parameter selection and restoration performance to different view partitions?
Questions for authors
See the above Weaknesses parts.
We thank the reviewer for the comments. The revised PDF directly addresses W1, W2, and W4 with new experiments; we respectfully discuss W3 below.
Reply to W1 (three backbones; MoCE-IR missing). MoCE-IR (CVPR 2025) is now included as a fourth backbone in both protocols (Tables 1-2). HGPS improves MoCE-IR+DCTTA on all four three-task targets (family average +0.49 dB); the gain is especially pronounced in the five-task setting, where HGPS improves MoCE-IR+DCTTA on all five targets and raises the family average by +1.28 dB - the largest within-family improvement in this setting. We also note that the adopted backbones are themselves recent peer-reviewed all-in-one restoration models: StarIR (IEEE TPAMI 2026), PromptIR (NeurIPS 2023), DFPIR (CVPR 2025), and MoCE-IR (CVPR 2025). The host framework DCTTA (CVPR 2026) itself was evaluated on three backbones for both the three-task and five-task protocols; our 4-backbone x 2-protocol evaluation exceeds that coverage while keeping every within-family factor (pipeline, budget, optimizer, seed) strictly controlled, which is what licenses attributing the gains to the selection criterion alone.
Reply to W2 (computational complexity). New Sec. 4.5 / Table 4 reports a controlled profiling comparison on Kodak24: G is computed once before adaptation (138.5 s for S=24 samples); the per-iteration adaptation cost is unchanged (adaptation-time ratio 1.038); end-to-end time increases by 17.26% (8.04 s/image); peak allocated GPU memory does not increase (20.63 vs 20.70 GiB). Since the extra cost is a one-time selection pass rather than per-iteration inference, wall-clock latency and memory are the deployment-relevant metrics for TTA.
Reply to W3 (real-world validation). We respectfully clarify that our target domains are already predominantly real-world: O-HAZY and DenseHaze (real haze), SDD (real defocus blur), and VILNC-Indoor3 (real low-light) - four real-world degradation distributions spanning both protocols - plus a cross-modality generalization study on real T1-weighted MRI scans (App. E.1, Table A.3). Because our contribution is a parameter-selection criterion rather than a new restoration model, we prioritized strictly controlled comparisons (identical pipeline, budget, and seed within each family) over benchmark breadth. We will further extend real-world evaluations in the camera-ready version.
Reply to W4 (fixed two-group partition). App. C / Table A.1 evaluates 5 alternatives: two balanced random partitions, a group-swap control, a rotation-vs-reflection partition, and a four-group generalization of G (Eq. A.4). Although G rankings can change substantially (Spearman 0.19-0.82), the adapted outputs deviate from the default partition by at most 0.063 dB (Rain12) and 0.198 dB (SDD), and the scoring cost is unchanged (5.4-6.5 s/sample). We also added the design rationale: both default groups mix rotations and reflections, so neither group observes a single symmetry type. We now state explicitly that G should not be interpreted as partition-invariant, and that directional degradations (rain, motion blur) require care since reflections flip the degradation orientation (Sec. 5).
We hope the new experiments and clarifications address your concerns, and we would be grateful for a re-evaluation of the score.