- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SFCI-Mamba, a compact U-shaped encoder-decoder for dermoscopic skin lesion segmentation. Its spatial-frequency collaborative block contains a spatial branch based on two-dimensional selective scanning and a frequency branch that applies a Fourier transform, separately maps amplitude and phase using two independent Mamba modules, reconstructs a complex spectrum, and returns it to the spatial domain. The proposed dual-context interaction module allows branch-specific queries to retrieve information from a shared spatial-frequency context before concatenation and SE-based fusion. The model is evaluated on ISIC2017 and ISIC2018, together with cross-dataset evaluation on PH2 using the ISIC2018-trained checkpoint without fine-tuning. Against eight retrained baselines, it reports Dice scores of 0.9121, 0.9001, and 0.9228, respectively, with 2.538M parameters and 0.354 GFLOPs. The ablation studies examine DCI, SE, frequency-domain modeling, and separate versus joint amplitude-phase modeling.
Critical strengths
- The paper specifies the dataset sizes, common training protocol, metric definitions, micro-averaging convention, thresholding rule, and handling of empty masks for HD95 and ASSD. It reports overlap, pixel-level, and boundary metrics and includes qualitative examples, failure cases, and an appropriately scoped limitations section. These choices make the empirical claims relatively easy to understand and audit.
- Under the reported common protocol, SFCI-Mamba obtains the best IoU and Dice among the evaluated methods on both ISIC test sets and on PH2, while remaining smaller than most conventional and state-space baselines. The component studies are also directionally consistent: the complete model outperforms the tested spatial replacements, and joint amplitude-phase modeling gives the best overlap among the evaluated spectral variants.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty mainly comes from combining existing components and appears relatively incremental. Spatial-frequency dual-branch modeling, Fourier amplitude-phase decomposition, visual Mamba, SE, and cross-branch attention have all been explored in related work. The main new designs are the use of independent Mamba mappings for amplitude and phase and the use of branch-specific queries over a concatenated shared context. However, the former largely replaces an existing mapping operation with state-space modules, while the latter remains structurally close to multi-head cross-attention. The paper does not provide sufficient theoretical analysis, spectral-behavior analysis, or strictly parameter-matched experiments to demonstrate that these designs introduce capabilities unavailable to existing methods. The current contribution therefore appears closer to an effective incremental architecture than a substantial methodological advance.
- The experiments do not establish whether the relatively small improvements are robust, and they do not fully separate the proposed mechanism from additional capacity and computation. All tables report single point estimates without multiple random seeds, confidence intervals, or statistical tests. The Dice improvements over the strongest listed baseline are 0.0038 on ISIC2017, 0.0067 on ISIC2018, and 0.0027 on PH2, while the improvement of joint amplitude-phase modeling over phase-only modeling is only 0.0015. Moreover, DCI+SE uses 2.538M parameters and 0.354 GFLOPs, compared with 2.002M parameters and 0.247 GFLOPs for no-DCI+SE. Part of the improvement may therefore result from increased model capacity or computation rather than the interaction mechanism itself.
Questions for authors
- Beyond combining existing modules and changing their mappings, what new modeling capability does SFCI-Mamba provide relative to prior spatial-frequency Mamba, amplitude-phase modeling, and bidirectional cross-attention approaches? Can the authors provide spectral-response or feature-behavior analyses and parameter- and FLOP-matched no-DCI, bidirectional cross-attention, and other relevant controls to show that the gains cannot be obtained from a standard dual-branch architecture or increased capacity?
- Can the authors report results over multiple random seeds, including means and standard deviations or confidence intervals, for the full model, the strongest baseline, and the key ablations in Tables 5-7? A paired bootstrap analysis over test images would also be informative. Please additionally specify the channel schedule, Mamba state and expansion hyperparameters, DCI pooling and upsampling procedure, normalization and rotation settings, exact split identifiers, and code-release plan.