- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SEmO, a reasoning segmentation framework using three tokens: SEG, EDGE, and OTHERS. The proposed Progressive Mask Decoder (PMD) combines these tokens to improve segmentation quality. Experiments on ReasonSeg and RefCOCO datasets show improved performance with a lightweight decoder.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses important problems in reasoning segmentation, particularly inaccurate object boundaries and false-positive predictions.
-
The proposed role-specific tokens provide a simple and understandable approach to separating target regions, boundaries, and non-target regions.
-
The method achieves competitive performance on ReasonSeg, with improvements over the reported baseline methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
Comparisons with related methods are limited. Important methods such as PixelLM and M²SA are missing from the segmentation performance comparisons.
-
Reasoning segmentation is evaluated only on ReasonSeg. Additional benchmarks, such as MUSE and MMR, are needed to better evaluate the generalization of the method.
-
The framework does not support multiple targets in a single query. This limits its use in more complex reasoning segmentation tasks.
-
The ablation study does not clearly separate the effects of the new tokens from those of additional supervision. More controlled experiments are needed to support the main contribution.
-
The proposed PMD is not compared with other progressive or multi-scale decoders. This makes it difficult to evaluate the contribution of the decoder design.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide performance comparisons with PixelLM(CVPR2024) and M²SA(ICLR2025), or explain why these methods were excluded?
-
Can the authors evaluate the method on other reasoning segmentation datasets, such as MUSE or MMR?
-
How can the OTHERS token be applied when a query refers to multiple target objects?
-
Can the authors compare the proposed tokens with a single SEG token using the same supervision and separate prediction heads?
-
Can the authors compare PMD with existing multi-scale or progressive decoders under similar settings?