- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper defines a relatively new problem to modify the face image so that it can be recognised only by an authorised face recognition model. The protected face is then evaluated against other unauthorised face recognition models where the performance drops. The protected images have a lot of changes (examples in Fig 3) that is also difficult to recognise for human.
Critical strengths
- The paper proposes a new method for protecting face images to be recognisable by an authorised face recognition model.
- Experiments are conducted with different model architectures and on different datasets.
Critical weaknesses
- The main issue is with the definition of the task (which is new). The protected images have a lot of changes (examples in Fig 3) that is also difficult to recognise for human. This causes a lot of limitations in application. It is more interesting if the image remains recognisable for human.
- The paper lacks baseline. If we assume that it is not important that the protected face can be recognised by human a gradient assent based approach on the identity embedding/class will be easily provide protection.
- If the image cannot be recognised by human why should users send their protected image, instead they can send an encrypted image.
Questions for authors
- Given that we are assuming that there is an authorised face recognition model, can we use a secret key to protect the image?
- Assuming whitebox/blackbox access to the authorised face recognition model, can an adversary reconstruct the face image (to be recognised by other models) from protected image?