acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Large Language Models Learn to Persuade Multiple Receivers through Social Context

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) enable open-ended persuasion, yet existing LLM-based approaches largely focus on isolated, short-horizon interactions, overlooking how target selection and social influence jointly shape collective outcomes. To address this gap, we formulate LLM-based multi-receiver persuasion as a natural-language sequential decision problem, in which an LLM persuader decides whom to address and what to say to heterogeneous receivers connected by a social graph. We instantiate this setting in three domains: academic rebuttal, political decision-making, and charitable campaigns. Our key insight is that evolving social context is central to both persuasion evaluation and policy learning. For evaluation, we find that incorporating social context generally improves correlation and reduces prediction error with human judgments across all three domains and accordingly develop Persuade-RM, which outperforms the task-specific Rebuttal-RM in academic rebuttal. For policy learning, we propose Graph-Contextual Group Policy Optimization (GCGPO), a critic-free algorithm that groups socially comparable steps and combines step-level advantages with episode-level relative advantages. Across all three domains, GCGPO achieves strong quality and stance scores while avoiding the degradation observed in several baselines. We further develop a coupled actor-reward generation mechanism that reduces training time per iteration by 44.7% on average while maintaining comparable evaluation performance. Together, these results establish social context as a key ingredient for effective evaluation and policy learning in LLM-based multi-receiver persuasion.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
AI4SS, Reinforcement Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_EqdFOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tackles the problem of LLM-based persuasion in a multi-receiver setting. Specifically, it proposes a Reinforcement Learning-based framework where the LLM can select multiple receivers, further integrating social context by means of a graph.

The framework is applied over three different domains, spanning political campaigns, academic rebuttal, and charity context. Method effectiveness is validated in terms of some features (e.g., clarity, success, persuasiveness) against a set of baselines.

Critical strengths

The underlying idea which forms the basis of this paper is intriguing. Effectively inducing LLM persuasion over multiple heterogeneous peers by further integrating social context is valuable and highly impactful.

Critical weaknesses

The writing quality of the paper is unfortunately poor, heavily affecting comprehension.

Overall, the text is full of overly generic and non-technically sound statements, with several concepts never properly defined (e.g., success signal ηt\eta_t, the "actor") or described in a shallow manner ("the environment validates the output", "the key is the corresponding context of the target receiver").

More crucially, it is not clear to this reviewer why the discrepancy in terms of stance Δsi\Delta s_i should represent a good proxy in terms of persuasion. The paper claims that higher values of the stance score indicate greater persuasiveness, but why? Stance is merely a representation of the node inclination towards a given topic. If Δsi\Delta s_i is maximized, this basically implies that the stance at converge will be higher than the original one, without taking account any target final value, or the semantics underlying the score.

Additionally, there is an important mismatch between the provided Figure and the main content. In the figures, to the best of my understanding, the graph G is actually labeled with labels representing the node inclination towards the given topic (e.g., supportive/opposing). However, the text never mentions such labels and how they are estimated.

Next, the findings reported in the experimental section are weak. The paper claims that integrating social context "improves" Pearson correlation and lowers MSE, but (i) most of the reported correlations are either low or even absent (approaching 0), and (ii) it is not showed that the reduction in terms of MSE is statistically significant. Finally, it is never clarified how the "quality" features used to validate the method are defined nor quantified. Similar statistical concern holds for the results reported in Table 1, whose values are often similar and reported intervals tend to overlap.

Questions for authors
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer EqdF

Thank you for your review. We clarify the definitions and evidence below.


W1: Definitions and figures.

Reviewer EqdF (summary): The actor, validity signal, and graph labels need clarification.

The actor is πθ\pi_\theta; ηt\eta_t denotes format and receiver validity in the transition/reward definitions. The evaluation appendix defines Success aggregation. Figure legends identify node stances and the selected target; directed edges denote observation links. Colors visualize stance values rather than a separate classification task.


W2: Stance and quality.

Reviewer EqdF (summary): Why use stance change, and how is quality quantified?

Stance denotes acceptance rating, policy support, or donation willingness. Thus, Δsi=sifinal−siinitial\Delta s_i = s_i^{\mathrm{final}} - s_i^{\mathrm{initial}} measures movement toward the domain objective. Quality separately averages Attitude, Clarity, Constructiveness, and Persuasiveness equally, using the appendix's rubrics and 0–10 scales; unexecuted steps receive zero.


W3: Statistical interpretation.

Reviewer EqdF (summary): Are the reported improvements statistically supported?

The matched ablation holds the model, examples, and other prompt inputs fixed. Social context raises Pearson correlation by 0.08/0.06/0.18 and lowers MSE by 0.02/0.04/0.41 on Paper/Political/Charity. These are observed improvements in all three domains; statistical significance of each difference has not been established.


Thank you again for your feedback.

Reviewer_iFkyOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies multi-receiver persuasion with LLMs. Since previous work primarily focuses on short interactions and limited planning, the paper proposes a formulation of multi-receiver with LLMs as a sequential decision-making problem in the natural language space. The authors study various examples of multi-receiver persuasion in the real world, including academic rebuttal, political decision-making, and charitable campaigns. Through their experiments in both training and evaluation, they claim that incorporating social context improves correlation with human judgements, and the proposed algorithm, Graph-Contextual Group Policy Optimization, can achieve strong quality while avoiding degradation.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper studies an interesting question related to LLM-driven persuasion. Allowing multiple receivers is an important extension of persuasion models in game theory, and I think it can also provide useful insights into LLM behavior in related scenarios.
  2. The scope of the paper is fairly comprehensive. It covers the theoretical formulation, dataset collection, algorithmic design, and empirical analysis, which together make a valid contribution toward multi-receiver persuasion with LLMs.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Although the paper mentions related work in multi-receiver Bayesian persuasion, it does not establish a meaningful connection with this literature in game theory. Instead of directly modeling the difference in multi-receivers assumed in previous literature, the paper uses graphs to capture such relationships, which only captures the information visibility, not strategic interdependence.
  2. The authors use a MDP formulation for persuasion tasks. However, the implemented experiments (or realistic scenarios) does not follow the Markovian assumption, which significantly weakens the theoretical formulation. The authors mention in the introduction that the formulation introduces fundamental challenges, including adaptive receiver selection, socially dependent persuasion, and long-horizon credit assignment. However, I think there is a significant mismatch between the proposed algorithm, GCGPO, and the motivated challenges that the authors aim to address.
  3. The authors propose to use Persuade-RM as an evaluator for most of the experiments without sufficient validation, which significantly make the empirical findings less reliable, especially given that multiple scores, including attitude, clarity, constructiveness, and persuasiveness, all come from the same models.
Questions for authors
  1. What is novel regarding the empirical findings regarding "social context as a key ingredient for effective evaluation and policy learning"?
  2. Do you have any evaluation results to justify the use of Persuade-RM?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer iFky

Thank you for your detailed review. We clarify the formulation, contributions, and validation below.


W1: Scope and novelty.

Reviewer iFky (summary): What connects this work to Bayesian persuasion, and what is new?

We share multi-receiver Bayesian persuasion's collective sender objective, without claiming an equilibrium signaling solution. Observation links determine which peer stances affect subsequent updates, creating sequential dependence. Our contributions are joint receiver selection and message generation, social-context-aware evaluation, and graph-contextual credit assignment for sequential language interventions.


W2: MDP and algorithmic motivation.

Reviewer iFky (summary): Is the Markov assumption valid, and how does GCGPO address the challenges?

The simulator state includes the graph, profiles, current stances, conversation history, and completed/remaining receivers. Social dependence therefore does not itself violate the Markov assumption; real-world partial observability remains a limitation. GCGPO uses completed/remaining-receiver keys for selection, target/neighborhood keys for persuasion, and return-to-go plus episode advantages for downstream credit assignment.


W3: Persuade-RM validation.

Reviewer iFky (summary): What evidence supports Persuade-RM and social-context-aware evaluation?

The evaluator-validation appendix reports human-annotation comparisons, evaluator baselines, and the following social-context ablation:

DomainPearson without → with context ↑MSE without → with context ↓
Paper0.12 → 0.201.02 → 1.00
Political0.07 → 0.130.97 → 0.93
Charity0.24 → 0.421.44 → 1.03

Final evaluation uses a separate, frozen Persuade-RM. Its scores are distinct from training-time self-assessment, although dimensions scored by one judge are not independent human validations.


Thank you again for your feedback.


Reviewer_4b7FOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work formulates LLM-based multi-receiver persuasion as a problem in which LLM generates targeted natural language messages to specific receivers in a social network. It tests the framework in three representative domains of academic rebuttal, political campaigns, and charitable campaigns. To tackle this challenge, the paper introduces Graph-Contextual Group Policy Optimization (GCGPO), which combines episode-level and graph-contextual step advantages. Experiments show that GCGPO outperforms several policy-learning baselines.

Critical strengths
  • This work studies an interesting task of socially influenced persuasion by introducing a novel formulation of LLM-based multi-receiver persuasion.
  • This work presents three target domains that adequately involve social influence and receiver persuasion.
Critical weaknesses
  • Even though the paper shows LLM-simulated data can be calibrated toward human-annotated data to a degree, it is unclear if the improved results in the simulated experiments translate to improved persuasion without adequate human evaluation.
  • The paper introduces both the simulator and the evaluator, and GCGPO seems to be highly tailored to this setup. The extent to which GCGPO would generalize beyond this proposed simulator-evaluator environment is unclear, without additional evidence demonstrating its applicability and benefits.
  • Clarity can be improved. For instance, Persuade-RM is mentioned several times before it is defined, making it difficult to follow.
Questions for authors
  • Are there any evidence that the improvement in results based on simulated evaluation correspond to improvement in human persuasion quality?
  • How robust are the results to the network structure, e.g. sparse, dense, existence of hubs?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4b7F

W1: Human validity and generalization.

Reviewer 4b7F (summary): Do the gains translate to human persuasion and generalize beyond the simulator?

Human annotations assess the plausibility of held-out stance predictions, not whether the trained policy changes real participants' opinions. Our results support performance within the evaluated environments; real-world persuasion and generalization beyond our simulator and evaluator remain unverified.


W2: Network robustness.

Reviewer 4b7F (summary): Is performance robust to network density and hubs?

We evaluate complete reviewer-observation graphs, layered political graphs, and BA-style charity graphs. These settings do not isolate topology effects; robustness to controlled changes in density or hubs remains unverified.


W3: Clarity.

Reviewer 4b7F (summary): Persuade-RM appears before its definition.

We have moved its description to a dedicated “Social-Context-Aware Evaluator” subsection in Method, before the coupled actor-reward discussion, to distinguish evaluation from training-time self-assessment.


Thank you again for your feedback.


From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.