- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SPImpute, a structure-preserving imputation method tailored for “frozen” time-series foundation models, which must forecast from incomplete historical inputs without adapting the predictor. The method combines a convex quadratic reconstruction that preserves observed points while aligning lag-p increments to a reference trajectory with a same-phase candidate that corrects donor levels for one-sided, long gaps using a robust median slope. A masked historical validation scheme selects among fixed quadratic weightings and the same-phase candidate without using labels or querying the predictor, and extensive experiments across 19 real datasets and synthetic studies show consistent downstream-forecasting gains, competitive runtime, and insightful attribution controls.
Critical strengths
- The same-phase donor correction with a robust, median lag-p slope is a simple yet thoughtful mechanism to compensate for drift in one-sided, long gaps; the trend-equivariance property for eligible coordinates is well-articulated.
- The selection protocol is carefully designed: historical block masking, per-mask re-estimation of reference and slope, and strict switching criteria ensure conservative adoption of the same-phase candidate while keeping the predictor frozen.
- Imputation that preserves structure useful to downstream frozen forecasters is an important and timely problem; SPImpute is methodologically lightweight, interpretable, and deployable, and demonstrates consistent improvements over widely used baselines.
Critical weaknesses
- The masked-validation scoring uses MAE for quadratic candidates but RMSE for the same-phase candidate, which could bias selection; the rationale and sensitivity are not fully justified.
- The same-phase correction relies on at least eight observed lag-p pairs; sensitivity to this threshold and behavior under sparse/volatile observations are not analyzed.
- The period is supplied by the datasets; there is no study of misspecified or unknown p, which is a common practical scenario. How sensitive is SPImpute to period misspecification? Please report a robustness study where p is perturbed or when multiple plausible periods exist, and discuss how validation behaves under wrong p
- Have you considered or experimented with simple auto-period estimation (e.g. STL-derived seasonal length) and then running SPImpute? Even preliminary results would strengthen applicability when p is unknown.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses
4 comments
Response to Reviewer 7TTY (Part 2 of 2)
3. Sensitivity to an incorrectly specified period
The effect of period misspecification depends on how the period is changed.
We tested , , , and on the same incomplete histories, keeping all other settings unchanged. The following forecast MSE changes use the supplied period as the reference:
| Input period | Sundial | TimesFM-2.5 | Chronos-2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.41% increase | 3.62% increase | 0.46% decrease | |
| 2.35% increase | 1.15% increase | 1.85% decrease | |
| 11.79% increase | 16.13% increase | 2.26% increase | |
| 0.83% increase | 1.10% decrease | 0.92% decrease |
The absolute change in mean error was at most 3.62% for a one-step period shift and 1.10% for a doubled period. Halving the period caused larger increases: 11.79%, 16.13%, and 2.26% under Sundial, TimesFM-2.5, and Chronos-2, respectively.
For a signal repeating every steps, positions separated by still share a phase, whereas positions separated by may lie in different parts of the waveform. For example, a position that should use another peak as its reference may instead use a trough. Doubled and halved periods therefore need separate evaluation.
Compared directly with SPImpute without periodic guidance, using reduced mean MSE by 5.81%, 8.86%, and 6.90%, respectively. The other three perturbations also retained average gains over the version without periodic guidance. Period errors reduced some forecasting gains, while periodic guidance continued to help.
With in the main panel, the selected candidate's validation score worsened in 525 of 903 histories, and same-phase selections decreased from 141 to 99. Historical validation thus reduces the use of same-phase candidates with less favorable scores and reselects the imputation under the supplied period.
These comparisons show smaller average effects for slight period shifts and doubled periods, and a larger effect for halved periods. Reliable period information yields lower mean forecasting error, while approximate periods can retain gains over using no period.
4. Estimating the period from observed history
SPImpute can first estimate a period from observed history and then perform imputation. With historical period estimation, all three predictors achieved lower mean forecasting error than with periodic guidance removed entirely.
The original paper takes as an input and uses the dataset-supplied period to compare imputation strategies under the same period information. When the period is unknown, we can identify a repetition length in the observed history and pass it to the same SPImpute algorithm, leaving the subsequent imputation procedure unchanged.
Our added estimator first removes a linear trend from the observed history, then examines repetition using pairs with both endpoints observed. A correlation peak satisfying fixed criteria supplies the period; if none is found, SPImpute runs without periodic guidance. The estimator receives only the observed history, with no dataset name, sampling frequency, original period, or future values.
We compared supplied periods, automatically estimated periods, and no period:
| Comparison | Sundial | TimesFM-2.5 | Chronos-2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated vs. supplied period | 10.75% increase | 9.40% increase | 2.79% increase |
| Estimated vs. no period | 7.26% decrease | 13.11% decrease | 6.44% decrease |
When reliable period information is available, using it directly avoids estimation and gives lower mean error. When it is unavailable, historical estimation reduces mean MSE relative to using no period by 7.26%, 13.11%, and 6.44%. It therefore provides a usable imputation approach for inputs without period metadata.
For traffic, the supplied period is 24 hours, but automatic estimation selected the 168-hour weekly period in 42 of 45 histories in each mask panel. Daily and weekly variation can coexist in the same history, and the period used for imputation affects subsequent forecasts. Supplied periods and historical estimation support use with known and unknown periods, respectively.
We have revised the manuscript in response to your comments; the revised text is marked in blue, with purple margin labels identifying changes addressing your questions.
Thank you to the authors for the thorough rebuttal and for incorporating the new experimental results and discussions into the revised manuscript.
As most of my previous concerns have been resolved with empirical evidence, I am raising my rating from 2 to 3.
Thank you for your feedback
Thank you for reviewing our response and revised manuscript, and for your positive feedback on the additional experiments. Your suggestions on candidate scoring, period misspecification, and automatic period estimation helped us strengthen the experimental evaluation and explain the rationale and practical use of our method more clearly. These comments have helped us improve the paper. We appreciate the time and care you have devoted to reviewing our work.
Response to Reviewer 7TTY (Part 1 of 2)
Thank you for recognizing the one-sided drift correction and historical validation design. We added comparisons of scoring rules, observation counts, and period settings. We explain the design choices and results below.
1. Candidate scoring
We use RMSE, which is more sensitive to large errors, to evaluate the same-phase candidate and impose a stricter condition for replacing the default quadratic reconstruction. If selected, this candidate replaces the quadratic repair at every missing position. RMSE allows large deviations at even a few positions to affect this decision. The same-phase candidate must also outperform every quadratic candidate and satisfy the 3% switching threshold. Replacement therefore requires sufficient evidence from historical validation.
We compared the original mixed scoring with two alternatives: MAE for all candidates and RMSE for all candidates. The candidates, validation blocks, and switching threshold remained unchanged. The experiment used 19 series from 10 sources under BM30. Each predictor evaluated 903 histories; Sundial and TimesFM-2.5 shared masks, while Chronos-2 used independent masks. Forecast MSE changes relative to mixed scoring are:
In the main mask panel, same-phase selections increased from 141 with mixed scoring to 185 with uniform MAE and 182 with uniform RMSE. The corresponding counts in the independent mask panel were 142, 172, and 173. Mixed scoring thus selects the same-phase candidate more conservatively.
Under both uniform rules, the absolute change in mean MSE was below 0.62%, and the direction varied across predictors. We retain mixed scoring to control candidate switching; the comparisons show that this choice has a small effect on mean forecasting performance.
2. The minimum of eight observed pairs
Eight is the minimum number of observed pairs required to enable drift estimation, preventing correction based on very few observed changes. The slope is computed from all valid pairs. Both endpoints must be observed and exactly one period apart. Once the minimum is met, the algorithm computes the rate of change for each pair and takes their median.
We recounted the pairs in 1,806 actual histories and their 5,418 internal masked-validation tasks:
Even the smallest validation task retained 673 pairs. Changing the threshold from 8 to 4, 16, or 32 therefore uses exactly the same pairs to estimate the slope in every task, leaving candidate selection and imputation unchanged. All these estimates are supported by hundreds of observed pairs.
When fewer pairs are available than the threshold requires, the algorithm sets the slope to zero and continues with the uncorrected same-phase candidate and quadratic reconstruction. Taking the median reduces the influence of individual extreme pairwise changes. Each historical validation task also re-estimates the slope and checks the error after correction. The threshold controls whether correction is enabled when observations are scarce.