Closely related work is omitted, and the novelty of the main contributions is limited.
The related-work section and reference list omit SchNovel / RAG-Novelty, AI Can Learn Scientific Taste, OpenNovelty, and NovBench. These are directly relevant to the paper's claimed contributions. Examining those contributions separately shows substantial overlap with existing work. Dates below refer to each work's first arXiv submission (v1).
Multidisciplinary benchmarking: SchNovel / RAG-Novelty (September 2024) already evaluates scholarly novelty using 15,000 paper pairs across six fields. SciTaste-Bench uses a different subject mix and scoring target, but multidisciplinary evaluation itself is an established setting.
Citation-based evaluation of scientific taste: AI Can Learn Scientific Taste (March 2026) already constructs SciJudgeBench using field- and time-matched citation-based paper pairs. Using community citation signals to evaluate scientific judgment is therefore not a new contribution of this submission. Its distinctive scoring element is the particular seven-dimensional composite, whose validity requires separate evidence.
Tool-assisted paper assessment: SchNovel includes retrieval-augmented novelty assessment, while OpenNovelty (January 2026) retrieves prior work and performs contribution-level full-text comparisons to produce evidence-grounded novelty reports. DimAgent-v3 adapts tool-assisted assessment to nine predefined bibliometric queries followed by an LLM scoring step. This provides a specific implementation, but the paper does not clearly demonstrate a new retrieval, reasoning, or learning mechanism beyond existing tool-assisted assessment workflows.
Benchmarking novelty judgments against reference evaluations: NovBench (April 2026) already evaluates novelty-review generation using 1,684 paper–review pairs with reference evaluations extracted from expert reviews. Systematically testing LLM novelty judgments and their relationship to human assessments is also an established research direction.
I regard the proposed approach as a limited integration of established methods. The paper does not substantiate a stronger benchmark contribution through validated reference labels or sufficiently distinctive empirical findings; the construction problems in the next weakness further undermine that contribution.
The benchmark does not sufficiently validate either its evaluation population or its reference labels.
The 300-paper evaluation set is too limited to substantiate the breadth of the conclusions without further validation. Each discipline contributes only 50 papers while covering seven or eight sub-disciplines, leaving roughly six or seven papers per sub-discipline on average if all are covered, before accounting for year and journal tier. The 5,700 backup papers are not included in the main model comparisons. The paper does not report uncertainty intervals or demonstrate that model rankings and discipline-level differences persist across independently sampled evaluation sets. The concern is the stability and coverage of the reported conclusions, rather than a universal minimum dataset size.
The selection procedure also leaves important representativeness questions unresolved. Non-physics candidates are collected in descending citation order and sampled across composite-score quartiles (§3.3), while the selected set emphasizes 2000–2020 papers and balances journal tiers (§4). These choices define a particular evaluation population, whose relationship to the broader literature is not quantified. The paper does not establish how citation-ranked collection and subsequent selection affect coverage of less-cited or recent work. Physics and the other fields also use different database backends, so observed discipline gaps may reflect sample composition and evidence availability as well as model capability. Stratified sampling can improve coverage, but the reported strata alone do not establish that the comparisons are representative or robust.
The quantum-physics-derived weights define the answers against which all models are judged. Section 3.4 converts feature contributions from predicting citation and journal impact on 998 quantum-physics papers into dimension weights, then applies them to all six disciplines. This requires two distinct justifications: why predictive importance for these bibliometric outcomes should determine importance in scientific-value assessment, and why the resulting relative importance should hold in medicine, chemistry, finance, and the other fields. Predictive performance within quantum physics establishes neither. A common weight vector supplies a common calculation; it does not establish that the resulting scores have the same scientific meaning across disciplines.
Section 8 acknowledges that transferability is an assumption, but does not quantify its effect on the benchmark. Although multidisciplinary data have been collected, there is no comparison with balanced multidisciplinary calibration, field-specific weights, or equal weights, and no analysis of how these alternatives change reference paper rankings, model rankings, or agreement with independent experts. Appendix C mentions expert inspection of final paper scores in the journal-score construction, but does not report the number of experts, the inspection procedure, or quantitative agreement. The reported inspection is therefore insufficient to establish the validity of the full seven-dimensional target; independent expert annotations remain future work. For a benchmark contribution, these checks are needed to establish the reference labels themselves. Their absence leaves open whether model rankings reflect scientific judgment or agreement with a scoring rule calibrated on quantum physics.
The temporal definition further weakens the interpretation of the labels. The dataset spans 1996–2023, but Appendix C's citation formula uses cumulative counts without specifying year-conditioned reference cohorts or a common observation window. The observation horizon for disruptiveness and the historical cutoff for semantic comparisons are also unclear. These choices determine whether the benchmark evaluates realized influence or potential at publication. Publication-year and field effects have already been investigated in related research evaluation work, including Thelwall and Kurt (November 2024), but this study is not discussed.
Finally, the tools retrieve quantities used to construct the reference scores, including citation and author counts. Better agreement may therefore reflect improved access to the scoring rule's inputs. Without simple bibliometric baselines and independent validation, the tool gains do not establish an improvement in scientific judgment.
Internal inconsistencies also affect reproducibility and interpretation. Section 3.4 derives weights by averaging feature contributions across five regressors, whereas Appendix B and Table 5 describe a derivation from two random-forest analyses. Section 7.2 also calls DeepSeek's pure_qa Scheme-2 score of 30.2 its best result, although Table 2 reports higher scores for dimagent_v3 (34.5) and dimagent_v3_native (33.7). The authors should reconcile these descriptions with the actual implementation and results.
Appendix F also states that reasoning_effort and temperature were disabled for GPT's tool calls. The effect of this configuration change needs to be examined before attributing its poor tool-mode performance to an intrinsic model difference.
These issues indicate shortcomings in the manuscript's consistency checks. The weight derivation and experimental configuration affect reproducibility and interpretation, so they cannot be treated merely as language-editing problems. However, the PDF alone does not establish the full extent of AI involvement or the thoroughness of human verification.
The PDF provides no access link for the dataset or code. The abstract (p. 1) says that the data and code will be made available on Hugging Face, while Appendix I (p. 15) describes the materials as published. However, the PDF provides no dataset link, code repository, or anonymous download address. For a paper whose main contribution is a benchmark, this prevents reviewers from checking the complete paper collection and reference scores or reproducing the weight derivation and model evaluations. If these materials are supplied separately through the submission system, their location should be specified.
Thank you for the detailed response and additional analyses. The weight-sensitivity experiments and bootstrap confidence intervals are useful additions and address some of my concerns regarding ranking stability.
However, my main concerns remain unresolved. Stable model rankings under different weights do not establish the validity or cross-disciplinary transferability of the reference scores. More importantly, the lack of independent expert validation makes it difficult to determine whether the benchmark measures scientific research taste rather than agreement with a bibliometric scoring rule.
The citation-only baseline and dimension-level analysis further highlight this distinction. While I appreciate the authors' willingness to acknowledge these limitations and narrow their claims, I do not believe the current evidence sufficiently supports the benchmark's central claims. I therefore maintain my original assessment.