- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SVP combines planning, step-local ReAct execution, compact state summaries, evidence extraction, and a critic that can request searches or revise remaining steps. It evaluates this framework on HLE-Verified Gold, GPQA-Diamond, and SimpleQA-Verified, with additional backbone and tool-budget analyses.
Critical strengths
- The compact state interface provides a clear, reusable way to coordinate reasoning across steps. Detailed prompts, execution rules, resource statistics, and candid ablations make the system easier to assess and build on.
- The overall gains extend across three backbones. On the smaller models, HLE accuracy improves by 6.88 and 7.34 points, with corresponding EM/F1 gains. Low-budget SVP also beats higher-budget ReAct using fewer tokens, providing evidence beyond the main model's small margins.
Critical weaknesses
- The critic's net benefit remains unclear: removing it raises HLE ACC from 51.20 to 51.95, while slightly lowering F1. Successful replanning examples show that verification can help, but do not establish an average reliability benefit from this central control mechanism.
- Both critic actions retain the current conclusion. Later reasoning could still recover, but explicit correction of a wrong stored conclusion is not demonstrated. Algorithm A.1 also leaves unclear how the critic's findings and new evidence reach the replanner.
- The State Box ablation removes previous-step information, so it does not distinguish the proposed representation from ordinary summary-based execution. This makes the framework's specific contribution hard to identify. The helpful ReAct budget study partly addresses computation, but not this missing comparison.
- Verification and replanning already appear in the cited VeriMAP and in ReAgent. The contribution should be positioned around the compact state interface and its demonstrated system benefits; the current comparisons do not establish an advantage over these closer architectures.
Questions for authors
- Can you show how a wrong stored conclusion is corrected or marked as superseded, and how critic findings enter the replanner?
- In the existing runs, how often do critic interventions fix errors versus introduce them, and can this explain the mixed ablation results?
- How does State Box compare with a simple summary carrying the same previous-step information under a similar total token budget?
- Can you report paired uncertainty estimates and audit cases where substring ACC and semantic correctness disagree?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 2)
2. Critic Interventions and Paired Outcome Analysis (Q2, W1)
Thank you for raising this concern. To examine how Critic-guided control relates to changes in final-answer correctness, we conducted a paired outcome analysis on the 668 HLE-Verified Gold samples. Table 1 shows that 42 samples were answered correctly by SVP but incorrectly by w/o Critic, while 47 exhibited the opposite outcome. The remaining samples were answered either correctly or incorrectly by both configurations, yielding a net difference of five correct answers (342 vs. 347).
R4-Table 1. Paired outcome comparison between SVP and w/o Critic on HLE-Verified Gold.
| Outcome | Number of Questions |
|---|---|
| Both Correct | 300 |
| SVP Correct, w/o Critic Incorrect | 42 |
| SVP Incorrect, w/o Critic Correct | 47 |
| Both Wrong | 279 |
| Total | 668 |
To further characterize the Critic's participation in execution, we found that 420 of the 668 samples (62.9%) received at least one non-CONTINUE recommendation, while 228 samples (34.1%) triggered at least one REPLAN operation. These results indicate that the Critic actively participates in execution-time control rather than merely evaluating final answers.
However, the paired outcome comparison alone does not reveal how replanning relates to these changes. We therefore further inspected the 35 outcome-flipping samples in which at least one REPLAN was triggered, examining the revised remaining plans to assess whether their changes provided identifiable directions toward the final outcomes. We classified these cases into three categories: (A) correct-direction replanning, where the revised plan explicitly redirected a subsequent step toward the ground-truth answer; (B) incorrect-direction replanning, where the revised plan redirected subsequent reasoning toward an incorrect answer while w/o Critic produced the correct answer; and (C) cases where the recorded plan changes make it difficult to reliably determine how replanning affected the final outcome.
R4-Table 2. Plan-level analysis of replanning in outcome-flipping samples.
| Replanning Outcome | SVP Correct, w/o Critic Incorrect (16) | SVP Incorrect, w/o Critic Correct (19) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Correct-direction replanning | 6 | 0 | 6 |
| B. Incorrect-direction replanning | 0 | 5 | 5 |
| C. Difficult to attribute from plan records | 10 | 14 | 24 |
| Total | 16 | 19 | 35 |
The analysis identifies six cases where the revised plans explicitly redirected subsequent reasoning toward the correct answer, and five cases where they led subsequent reasoning in an incorrect direction. For the remaining 24 cases, the recorded plan changes make it difficult to reliably determine how replanning affected the final outcomes. These findings suggest that Critic-triggered replanning can facilitate corrections but may also introduce errors. Importantly, the 42 and 47 outcome flips represent differences between the two system configurations, rather than direct counts of answers corrected or errors introduced by the Critic.
Overall, the small difference in final-answer accuracy does not negate the Critic's role in SVP. Rather than acting as an independent answer corrector, the Critic evaluates the consistency between intermediate reasoning, accumulated evidence, and the remaining plan, identifying unsupported claims or mismatches and providing a control recommendation (CONTINUE, REFINE_SEARCH, or REPLAN). When REPLAN is selected, a separate Planner call revises the remaining subgoals while preserving completed progress. This mechanism contributes to SVP's broader system-level coordination, which integrates cross-step state tracking, step-local execution, and adaptive planning to enable accumulated external evidence to inform subsequent reasoning and task decisions. These findings also highlight the importance of better aligning evidence-based mismatch detection with planner-driven revisions, so that identified inconsistencies can translate more consistently into effective adjustments to the remaining plan.
Revision. We will include the paired outcome analysis, Critic participation statistics, and replanning case analysis in the appendix.
Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 3)
3. State Box vs. Plain-text Summary (Q3, W3)
Thank you for raising this point. To directly examine the contribution of state representation, we added a Plain-text Summary baseline that preserves the same cross-step information as the State Box, including the current plan, completed-step conclusions, and execution metadata, but presents it as continuous natural-language text rather than explicitly structured fields. The summary is generated by a deterministic formatter without additional LLM calls, with all other experimental settings unchanged.
The following example from Step 2 of sample 671da0bbbb27b8f41a423e7c illustrates the difference:
R4-Table 3. Example of the two state representations provided to Step 2.
| Component | Plain-text Summary | Structured State Box |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | First extract the UniProt accession number from the AlphaFold URL (e.g., P61949), then retrieve the associated protein name from a reliable source, and finally output the name. | Plan: Step 1: Extract the UniProt accession number. Step 2: Retrieve the associated protein name. Step 3: Output the protein name. |
| Completed conclusion | Step 1 established that the extracted accession number is P61949, corresponding to Flavodoxin 1. | Completed step conclusions: Step 1: Accession number P61949 corresponds to Flavodoxin 1. |
| Execution metadata | Available tool: Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode). Four of the original five search calls remain. The current instruction is to perform Step 2 reasoning. | Tools: Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode). Search budget: 5 total, 4 remaining. Step prompt: Perform Step 2 reasoning. |
The performance comparison is shown below:
R4-Table 4. Performance comparison of different state representations on HLE-Verified Gold (668 samples).
| Variant | ACC (%) | EM (%) | F1 | Avg. Tokens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SVP-Full | 51.20 | 48.65 | 0.5268 | 83,672 |
| Plain-text Summary | 50.45 | 47.90 | 0.5069 | 83,583 |
| w/o State Box | 49.85 | 47.60 | 0.5136 | 86,400 |
Plain-text Summary improves ACC by 0.60 percentage points over w/o State Box (50.45% vs. 49.85%), indicating the benefit of retaining cross-step information. Compared with Plain-text Summary, SVP-Full achieves a further 0.75-point ACC improvement and a higher F1 (0.5268 vs. 0.5069), with nearly identical average token consumption (83,672 vs. 83,583). These results suggest that explicitly organizing cross-step information into structured fields provides an additional benefit beyond retaining the same information in plain text.
Revision. We will include the Plain-text Summary comparison, representative input examples, and corresponding analysis in the Appendix.
Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 1)
Thank you for your careful assessment and constructive feedback. We address your concerns in five areas: the Critic–Planner interaction and handling of stored conclusions, the empirical effects of Critic interventions, the State Box representation, evaluation reliability, and SVP's relationship to existing approaches.
We hope that these clarifications and additional analyses address your concerns, and would be grateful if you would consider adjusting your rating in light of our responses. We provide detailed responses to each point below:
1. Critic-Triggered Replanning and Handling of Stored Conclusions (Q1, W2)
Thank you for raising this point. In SVP, the Critic evaluates the current execution trajectory and determines whether to continue, refine the search, or trigger replanning. Its structured output includes is_subgoal_satisfied, missing_evidence, unsupported_claims, and a control recommendation (CONTINUE, REFINE_SEARCH, or REPLAN). The Critic itself does not directly modify the plan or stored conclusions.
When REPLAN is selected, a separate Planner call is triggered. The Planner receives the original question and the current main-thread context, including the original plan, previously appended State Box information, and the Executor's reasoning and search results. Notably, the Critic's JSON assessment is recorded separately and is not directly passed to the replanning prompt. The Critic therefore determines whether replanning is triggered, while the Planner independently revises the remaining plan based on the available execution context. It preserves the existing plan up to the current step and adjusts only the subsequent unexecuted steps. Meanwhile, completed-step conclusions are maintained through append-only updates rather than being overwritten.
Case 1: Revising the remaining plan based on execution progress. In sample 6725fe6b26992c47ce3a7ef5 (ground-truth answer: D), Step 3 was designed to evaluate the answer choices, while Step 4 was intended to derive the final answer. After Step 3 had been executed, the original plan still contained the following unexecuted Step 4:
However, the Executor's reasoning in Step 3 had already established that D was correct. The Critic identified the unsupported assessment in the current plan and recommended REPLAN. The Planner subsequently revised Step 4 to:
The previously completed conclusions were retained, and the Step 3 conclusion was appended to the State Box. The final answer was D. This case illustrates how SVP adapts the unexecuted portion of a plan to the actual execution progress rather than rigidly following the initial plan.
Case 2: Appending subsequent conclusions while retaining earlier records. In sample 67ae17cf1509e1d55b4a0eec (ground-truth answer: 43), the State Box had already recorded two problematic intermediate conclusions. Step 3 derived u = -3, contradicting the constraint u > 0, while Step 4 obtained an expression for AE² that did not satisfy the required answer form. The Critic identified the unsupported intermediate derivations and recommended REPLAN. The Planner then revised the remaining steps to re-examine the sign conventions and re-derive the coordinate expressions using the correct point order and vector directions.
Subsequent execution produced the following updated conclusion:
The earlier Step 3 and Step 4 conclusions remained in the State Box, alongside the subsequently appended conclusions. Neither was deleted, overwritten, or explicitly marked as superseded. Nevertheless, the final answer was 43.
These examples illustrate two complementary aspects of SVP: replanning adapts the remaining execution steps to the evolving task context, while append-only state maintenance preserves historical execution records and allows subsequent reasoning results to be recorded. SVP focuses on coordinating step-local execution, persistent cross-step state, and Critic-triggered replanning to achieve system-level integration of external evidence into multi-step reasoning, while explicit mechanisms for identifying and reconciling conflicting historical conclusions could further extend the framework.
Revision. We will clarify the Critic–Planner interaction, the scope of replanning, and the append-only treatment of completed-step conclusions in the revised system description and algorithm presentation.