acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SVP: State-Verified Planning for System-Level External Knowledge Integration in Agentic Reasoning

Abstract

Grounding agentic LLMs in external knowledge can reduce hallucinations and improve reliability in knowledge-intensive and domain-specific reasoning tasks. However, effective integration requires more than providing access to search or tools. In complex multi-step settings, the acquired evidence may challenge assumptions or reshape reasoning, while the unsupported conclusions can propagate when cross-step progress is not explicitly maintained. We propose State-Verified Planning (SVP), a system-level framework that coordinates external knowledge through explicit cross-step state and adaptive control. SVP decomposes a query into a revisable high-level plan, executes each subgoal with a step-local ReAct-style executor, and maintains a compact State Box containing the plan, completed-step conclusions, available tools, and tool budget. After each step, a state maintainer records compact progress and derives a structured step view for assessment, allowing subsequent execution to condition on accumulated outcomes while supporting selective evidence refinement and plan revision when needed. Across three knowledge-intensive reasoning benchmarks, SVP consistently outperforms direct answering, module-level tool-augmented methods, and a system-level agentic baseline. On HLE-Verified Gold, SVP achieves 51.20% accuracy, outperforming the strongest baseline by 2.10 points, and improves further with larger tool budgets. The cross-model evaluation, component analysis, and a case study further demonstrate its robustness and the value of state-mediated external knowledge coordination across step-local reasoning and system-level orchestration.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, agentic reasoning, external knowledge integration, tool-augmented reasoning, inference-time reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_5jmBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SVP combines planning, step-local ReAct execution, compact state summaries, evidence extraction, and a critic that can request searches or revise remaining steps. It evaluates this framework on HLE-Verified Gold, GPQA-Diamond, and SimpleQA-Verified, with additional backbone and tool-budget analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. The compact state interface provides a clear, reusable way to coordinate reasoning across steps. Detailed prompts, execution rules, resource statistics, and candid ablations make the system easier to assess and build on.
  2. The overall gains extend across three backbones. On the smaller models, HLE accuracy improves by 6.88 and 7.34 points, with corresponding EM/F1 gains. Low-budget SVP also beats higher-budget ReAct using fewer tokens, providing evidence beyond the main model's small margins.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The critic's net benefit remains unclear: removing it raises HLE ACC from 51.20 to 51.95, while slightly lowering F1. Successful replanning examples show that verification can help, but do not establish an average reliability benefit from this central control mechanism.
  2. Both critic actions retain the current conclusion. Later reasoning could still recover, but explicit correction of a wrong stored conclusion is not demonstrated. Algorithm A.1 also leaves unclear how the critic's findings and new evidence reach the replanner.
  3. The State Box ablation removes previous-step information, so it does not distinguish the proposed representation from ordinary summary-based execution. This makes the framework's specific contribution hard to identify. The helpful ReAct budget study partly addresses computation, but not this missing comparison.
  4. Verification and replanning already appear in the cited VeriMAP and in ReAgent. The contribution should be positioned around the compact state interface and its demonstrated system benefits; the current comparisons do not establish an advantage over these closer architectures.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you show how a wrong stored conclusion is corrected or marked as superseded, and how critic findings enter the replanner?
  2. In the existing runs, how often do critic interventions fix errors versus introduce them, and can this explain the mixed ablation results?
  3. How does State Box compare with a simple summary carrying the same previous-step information under a similar total token budget?
  4. Can you report paired uncertainty estimates and audit cases where substring ACC and semantic correctness disagree?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 1)

Thank you for your careful assessment and constructive feedback. We address your concerns in five areas: the Critic–Planner interaction and handling of stored conclusions, the empirical effects of Critic interventions, the State Box representation, evaluation reliability, and SVP's relationship to existing approaches.

We hope that these clarifications and additional analyses address your concerns, and would be grateful if you would consider adjusting your rating in light of our responses. We provide detailed responses to each point below:


1. Critic-Triggered Replanning and Handling of Stored Conclusions (Q1, W2)

Thank you for raising this point. In SVP, the Critic evaluates the current execution trajectory and determines whether to continue, refine the search, or trigger replanning. Its structured output includes is_subgoal_satisfied, missing_evidence, unsupported_claims, and a control recommendation (CONTINUE, REFINE_SEARCH, or REPLAN). The Critic itself does not directly modify the plan or stored conclusions.

When REPLAN is selected, a separate Planner call is triggered. The Planner receives the original question and the current main-thread context, including the original plan, previously appended State Box information, and the Executor's reasoning and search results. Notably, the Critic's JSON assessment is recorded separately and is not directly passed to the replanning prompt. The Critic therefore determines whether replanning is triggered, while the Planner independently revises the remaining plan based on the available execution context. It preserves the existing plan up to the current step and adjusts only the subsequent unexecuted steps. Meanwhile, completed-step conclusions are maintained through append-only updates rather than being overwritten.

Case 1: Revising the remaining plan based on execution progress. In sample 6725fe6b26992c47ce3a7ef5 (ground-truth answer: D), Step 3 was designed to evaluate the answer choices, while Step 4 was intended to derive the final answer. After Step 3 had been executed, the original plan still contained the following unexecuted Step 4:

Step 4: Conclude that none of the above are necessarily true, so answer is E.

However, the Executor's reasoning in Step 3 had already established that D was correct. The Critic identified the unsupported assessment in the current plan and recommended REPLAN. The Planner subsequently revised Step 4 to:

Step 4: Based on the bound λ_max ≥ Δ+1, the maximum degree Δ ≤ 4, so max degree < 6. Therefore, answer choice D is true, while A, B, and C are false. Conclude that the correct answer is D.

The previously completed conclusions were retained, and the Step 3 conclusion was appended to the State Box. The final answer was D. This case illustrates how SVP adapts the unexecuted portion of a plan to the actual execution progress rather than rigidly following the initial plan.

Case 2: Appending subsequent conclusions while retaining earlier records. In sample 67ae17cf1509e1d55b4a0eec (ground-truth answer: 43), the State Box had already recorded two problematic intermediate conclusions. Step 3 derived u = -3, contradicting the constraint u > 0, while Step 4 obtained an expression for AE² that did not satisfy the required answer form. The Critic identified the unsupported intermediate derivations and recommended REPLAN. The Planner then revised the remaining steps to re-examine the sign conventions and re-derive the coordinate expressions using the correct point order and vector directions.

Subsequent execution produced the following updated conclusion:

Step 5 conclusion: Using coordinate geometry with symmetry, we derived t = 2/3, u = 8/9, and s = 9 from the given distances and the condition |v| = GH = 5. Direct computation then gave AE = (9√30)/4, so a = 9, b = 30, c = 4, and a + b + c = 43.

The earlier Step 3 and Step 4 conclusions remained in the State Box, alongside the subsequently appended conclusions. Neither was deleted, overwritten, or explicitly marked as superseded. Nevertheless, the final answer was 43.

These examples illustrate two complementary aspects of SVP: replanning adapts the remaining execution steps to the evolving task context, while append-only state maintenance preserves historical execution records and allows subsequent reasoning results to be recorded. SVP focuses on coordinating step-local execution, persistent cross-step state, and Critic-triggered replanning to achieve system-level integration of external evidence into multi-step reasoning, while explicit mechanisms for identifying and reconciling conflicting historical conclusions could further extend the framework.

Revision. We will clarify the Critic–Planner interaction, the scope of replanning, and the append-only treatment of completed-step conclusions in the revised system description and algorithm presentation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 2)

2. Critic Interventions and Paired Outcome Analysis (Q2, W1)

Thank you for raising this concern. To examine how Critic-guided control relates to changes in final-answer correctness, we conducted a paired outcome analysis on the 668 HLE-Verified Gold samples. Table 1 shows that 42 samples were answered correctly by SVP but incorrectly by w/o Critic, while 47 exhibited the opposite outcome. The remaining samples were answered either correctly or incorrectly by both configurations, yielding a net difference of five correct answers (342 vs. 347).

R4-Table 1. Paired outcome comparison between SVP and w/o Critic on HLE-Verified Gold.

OutcomeNumber of Questions
Both Correct300
SVP Correct, w/o Critic Incorrect42
SVP Incorrect, w/o Critic Correct47
Both Wrong279
Total668

To further characterize the Critic's participation in execution, we found that 420 of the 668 samples (62.9%) received at least one non-CONTINUE recommendation, while 228 samples (34.1%) triggered at least one REPLAN operation. These results indicate that the Critic actively participates in execution-time control rather than merely evaluating final answers.

However, the paired outcome comparison alone does not reveal how replanning relates to these changes. We therefore further inspected the 35 outcome-flipping samples in which at least one REPLAN was triggered, examining the revised remaining plans to assess whether their changes provided identifiable directions toward the final outcomes. We classified these cases into three categories: (A) correct-direction replanning, where the revised plan explicitly redirected a subsequent step toward the ground-truth answer; (B) incorrect-direction replanning, where the revised plan redirected subsequent reasoning toward an incorrect answer while w/o Critic produced the correct answer; and (C) cases where the recorded plan changes make it difficult to reliably determine how replanning affected the final outcome.

R4-Table 2. Plan-level analysis of replanning in outcome-flipping samples.

Replanning OutcomeSVP Correct, w/o Critic Incorrect (16)SVP Incorrect, w/o Critic Correct (19)Total
A. Correct-direction replanning606
B. Incorrect-direction replanning055
C. Difficult to attribute from plan records101424
Total161935

The analysis identifies six cases where the revised plans explicitly redirected subsequent reasoning toward the correct answer, and five cases where they led subsequent reasoning in an incorrect direction. For the remaining 24 cases, the recorded plan changes make it difficult to reliably determine how replanning affected the final outcomes. These findings suggest that Critic-triggered replanning can facilitate corrections but may also introduce errors. Importantly, the 42 and 47 outcome flips represent differences between the two system configurations, rather than direct counts of answers corrected or errors introduced by the Critic.

Overall, the small difference in final-answer accuracy does not negate the Critic's role in SVP. Rather than acting as an independent answer corrector, the Critic evaluates the consistency between intermediate reasoning, accumulated evidence, and the remaining plan, identifying unsupported claims or mismatches and providing a control recommendation (CONTINUE, REFINE_SEARCH, or REPLAN). When REPLAN is selected, a separate Planner call revises the remaining subgoals while preserving completed progress. This mechanism contributes to SVP's broader system-level coordination, which integrates cross-step state tracking, step-local execution, and adaptive planning to enable accumulated external evidence to inform subsequent reasoning and task decisions. These findings also highlight the importance of better aligning evidence-based mismatch detection with planner-driven revisions, so that identified inconsistencies can translate more consistently into effective adjustments to the remaining plan.

Revision. We will include the paired outcome analysis, Critic participation statistics, and replanning case analysis in the appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 5jmB (Part 3)

3. State Box vs. Plain-text Summary (Q3, W3)

Thank you for raising this point. To directly examine the contribution of state representation, we added a Plain-text Summary baseline that preserves the same cross-step information as the State Box, including the current plan, completed-step conclusions, and execution metadata, but presents it as continuous natural-language text rather than explicitly structured fields. The summary is generated by a deterministic formatter without additional LLM calls, with all other experimental settings unchanged.

The following example from Step 2 of sample 671da0bbbb27b8f41a423e7c illustrates the difference:

R4-Table 3. Example of the two state representations provided to Step 2.

ComponentPlain-text SummaryStructured State Box
PlanFirst extract the UniProt accession number from the AlphaFold URL (e.g., P61949), then retrieve the associated protein name from a reliable source, and finally output the name.Plan: Step 1: Extract the UniProt accession number. Step 2: Retrieve the associated protein name. Step 3: Output the protein name.
Completed conclusionStep 1 established that the extracted accession number is P61949, corresponding to Flavodoxin 1.Completed step conclusions: Step 1: Accession number P61949 corresponds to Flavodoxin 1.
Execution metadataAvailable tool: Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode). Four of the original five search calls remain. The current instruction is to perform Step 2 reasoning.Tools: Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode). Search budget: 5 total, 4 remaining. Step prompt: Perform Step 2 reasoning.

The performance comparison is shown below:

R4-Table 4. Performance comparison of different state representations on HLE-Verified Gold (668 samples).

VariantACC (%)EM (%)F1Avg. Tokens
SVP-Full51.2048.650.526883,672
Plain-text Summary50.4547.900.506983,583
w/o State Box49.8547.600.513686,400

Plain-text Summary improves ACC by 0.60 percentage points over w/o State Box (50.45% vs. 49.85%), indicating the benefit of retaining cross-step information. Compared with Plain-text Summary, SVP-Full achieves a further 0.75-point ACC improvement and a higher F1 (0.5268 vs. 0.5069), with nearly identical average token consumption (83,672 vs. 83,583). These results suggest that explicitly organizing cross-step information into structured fields provides an additional benefit beyond retaining the same information in plain text.

Revision. We will include the Plain-text Summary comparison, representative input examples, and corresponding analysis in the Appendix.

Reviewer_bgnkOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes State-Verified Planning (SVP), a system-level agentic framework designed to improve external knowledge integration in complex, knowledge-intensive multi-step reasoning tasks. The authors argue that while existing retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and module-level agentic methods (such as ReAct) provide tool access, they suffer from error propagation across reasoning steps because they lack structured cross-step state tracking and adaptive trajectory revision when retrieved evidence challenges prior assumptions.

Critical strengths
  1. System-Level State Management and Prefix-Preserving Replanning: The design of the compact State Box and prefix-preserving plan revision via CONTINUE and REPLAN actions (P(k+1)=P≤t(k)⊕Πrem(q,Ht)P^{(k+1)} = P^{(k)}_{\le t} \oplus \Pi_{rem}(q, H_t)) addresses the vulnerability where agentic loops discard previously gathered evidence upon replanning or accumulate noisy trajectories. By storing compact step conclusions Ct=(c1,…,ct)C_t = (c_1, \dots, c_t), the system limits local context growth while retaining intermediate findings. Table 3 reports a 1.35-point accuracy drop when the State Box is removed. The module-level analysis also reports lower Executor input-token consumption than ReAct (8,702 vs. 17,128), supporting the value of compact local context, although this does not imply lower total system cost.

  2. Demonstrated Effectiveness on Challenging Reasoning Benchmarks and Smaller Backbones: On HLE-Verified Gold, SVP retains the highest ACC among the nine methods in the manually audited main comparison: 50.75%, versus Search-o1 at 48.35%, ReAct at 47.90%, and Agentic Reasoning at 44.91%. On smaller open-source backbones (Table 2), SVP reports substantial gains of +11.67 points on Qwen3.5-9B and +8.99 points on Gemma4-12B-IT over ReAct. These findings support the practical value of the framework for knowledge-intensive reasoning, particularly on the evaluated smaller backbones.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Unestablished Net Benefit of Critic-Guided Control: In Table 3, SVP w/o Critic achieves 51.95% ACC compared with 51.20% for full SVP. Section 4.5 appropriately describes their aggregate performance as comparable, and Appendix E.5 illustrates successful plan corrections. The additional paired outcome comparison in the author response shows 42 questions where full SVP is correct and the critic-free variant is incorrect, against 47 with the opposite outcome. The five-question difference is small and does not establish that the Critic is systematically harmful; equally, this comparison does not demonstrate an aggregate accuracy improvement from adding it. The ablation removes both search refinement and replanning, so their individual contributions are not isolated. Among 35 answer-flip cases involving REPLAN, the response identifies six revisions toward the reference answer, five toward an incorrect answer, and 24 with inconclusive attribution. These analyses demonstrate plausible recovery and derailment mechanisms, but the selected cases do not estimate the effect of replanning across all 228 samples with a REPLAN trigger. The remaining concern is the empirical justification for the additional critic-guided control, rather than an absence of analysis or a claim that the module must be harmful.

  2. Accuracy–Cost Trade-Off and Limited Precision of Some Benchmark Gains: The author response's main-HLE token breakdown gives 83,672 total input and output tokens per question for SVP, versus 27,298 for ReAct and 23,987 for Plan + ReAct—approximately 3.07× and 3.49×, consistent with the rounded figures in manuscript Table 4. However, Section 4.3 and Table 5 also show SVP at B=3B=3 achieving 50.00% ACC with 72.7K tokens, compared with ReAct at B=20B=20 achieving 47.46% with 91.8K tokens. This is useful evidence against attributing all gains solely to higher token consumption; it does not eliminate the default-budget overhead or establish a complete accuracy–cost frontier. Separately, the response's manual audit supports the HLE ranking, while its paired tests find statistically inconclusive GPQA gains over CoT (+0.51 points; 95% CI −4.55 to +5.56; p = 1.00) and SimpleQA ACC gains over ReAct (+0.67 points; 95% CI −4.00 to +5.33; p = 0.888). The SimpleQA comparison with CoT needs reconciliation: manuscript Tables 1 and 4 report CoT ACC/EM of 21.33%/19.67%, whereas the response's statistical table uses 18.00%/16.67%. Consequently, the reported +37.00/+34.00-point gains and associated tests cannot be assumed to describe the manuscript's CoT predictions without clarification. These limitations constrain comparative conclusions, rather than invalidating the method or showing no benefit.

Questions for authors
  1. Contribution of Critic-Guided Search versus Replanning: The paired outcomes and trajectory categories clarify the original ablation discrepancy. Are separate execution-time ablations available for REFINE_SEARCH and REPLAN, with token consumption reported alongside accuracy? If available, these would help distinguish their contributions to the combined Critic result.

  2. Accuracy–Cost Trade-Off: Figure 2(c) and Table 5 provide a useful cross-budget comparison. Is a token-bounded comparison or an analysis of the best accuracy attainable by each method within common token ranges available from the existing runs? This would clarify how broadly the favorable B=3B=3 versus B=20B=20 result extends. A new budget-allocation objective is not required to establish autonomous retrieval.

  3. Scoring and Version Consistency: Why does the response's SimpleQA statistical table use CoT ACC/EM of 18.00%/16.67%, rather than the manuscript's 21.33%/19.67%? Please specify whether these are different runs or configurations and which paired predictions support the reported tests. Were component-ablation outputs also manually audited, and does the small Critic accuracy difference persist under that correction?

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer bgnk (Part 1)

Thank you for your thorough review and thoughtful feedback. We address your concerns in four areas: the Critic ablation and replanning analysis, budget and evaluation robustness, code execution in interactive environments, and adaptive budget allocation and token efficiency.

We sincerely hope these clarifications and additional results address your remaining concerns, and would be grateful if you could reconsider your rating in light of our efforts and dedication. Below, we provide detailed responses to all the comments:


1. Critic Ablation and Replanning Analysis (R1, W1)

Thank you for raising this important concern. The w/o Critic ablation disables both critic-guided search refinement and replanning, while retaining the other SVP components. Therefore, the observed performance difference reflects the contribution of the Critic's overall intervention mechanism, which determines when to continue, request further search, or trigger replanning. We first conduct a paired comparison between SVP and w/o Critic on the same 668 questions.

R3-Table 1. Paired outcome comparison between SVP and w/o Critic on HLE-Verified Gold.

OutcomeNumber of Questions
Both Correct300
SVP Correct, w/o Critic Incorrect42
SVP Incorrect, w/o Critic Correct47
Both Wrong279
Total668

Although w/o Critic achieves a slightly higher ACC (51.95% vs. 51.20%), the paired comparison shows that SVP produces correct answers on 42 questions for which w/o Critic is incorrect, whereas the opposite holds for 47 questions. These results indicate that removing the Critic leads to mixed outcome changes across individual questions, rather than a uniform improvement. However, final-answer comparisons alone do not reveal how critic-guided decisions influence subsequent execution.

Across 3,652 Critic assessments, CONTINUE, REFINE_SEARCH, and REPLAN account for 60.1%, 30.4%, and 9.5%, respectively. At least one REPLAN is triggered in 228/668 samples (34.1%). Importantly, the Critic itself does not modify the plan. Upon a REPLAN recommendation, a separate Planner call revises the remaining steps based on the original question, current context, and accumulated dialogue, while preserving completed steps.

To examine whether replanning helps recover failed trajectories or introduces potentially harmful changes, we further inspect the 35 answer-flip cases involving at least one REPLAN (16 cases where SVP is correct and w/o Critic is incorrect, and 19 cases with the opposite outcome). We examine the actual changes to the remaining plan and classify them according to whether the decisive step is revised toward the reference answer, toward an incorrect answer, or cannot be clearly attributed to the replanning decision.

R3-Table 2. Trajectory-level analysis of the 35 answer-flip cases involving REPLAN.

Plan Revision CategorySVP CorrectSVP IncorrectTotal
Revision toward the reference answer606
Revision toward an incorrect answer055
Inconclusive attribution101424
Total161935

For example, in sample 6725267ae9d3782179d4a5ff, replanning made the previously unspecified summation explicit (48 + 16 + 128 = 192), yielding the correct answer. Conversely, in 67151b015fc8ee8feaa3538c, the revised plan replaced a previously established correct chemical name with an incorrect one, leading to a wrong final answer. In the remaining 24 cases, the logged plan did not show a sufficiently clear change to the decisive step to attribute the final outcome to replanning.

Taken together, the slightly higher ACC of w/o Critic does not, by itself, indicate that the Critic is harmful: removing the Critic disables both evidence-triggered search refinement and replanning, while our trajectory analysis reveals both beneficial and adverse plan revisions following replanning. The Critic evaluates the consistency between intermediate reasoning, accumulated evidence, and the remaining plan; when it identifies a mismatch, it triggers replanning, after which the Planner revises the remaining subgoals while preserving completed progress. More broadly, these findings should be understood in the context of SVP's overall contribution: connecting step-local reasoning with cross-step state tracking and system-level task planning, so that accumulated evidence can inform subsequent reasoning and task adaptation. They also highlight the importance of better aligning evidence-based mismatch detection with planner-driven revisions, so that identified inconsistencies can translate more consistently into effective adjustments to the remaining plan.

Revision. We will clarify the distinction between Critic decisions and Planner-driven plan revisions, and include the paired comparison and representative replanning trajectories in the appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer bgnk (Part 2)

2. Scoring Robustness and Statistical Significance (Q2, W2)

Thank you for raising this concern. We provide additional manual verification and paired statistical analyses to examine the robustness of our evaluation results.

Scoring protocol and manual verification. We follow the scoring protocol adopted in Agentic Reasoning (ACL 2025), where ACC checks whether the normalized reference answer is contained in the normalized extracted prediction, while EM requires exact equality. Since an exact match necessarily satisfies substring containment, potential false positives introduced by substring-based ACC are confined to open-ended predictions with ACC = 1 but EM = 0. We therefore manually reviewed all such predictions across the nine methods in our HLE main comparison, identifying 41 false-positive method–example instances in total. R3-Table 3 reports their distribution and the corresponding ACC before and after manual correction.

R3-Table 3. Manual audit of substring-induced false positives on HLE-Verified Gold (668).

MethodFalse PositivesACC (Original → Audited)
DirectQA (no thinking)629.94 → 29.04
CoT547.75 → 47.01
Plan + CoT446.86 → 46.26
ReAct548.65 → 47.90
Plan + ReAct446.71 → 46.11
CRITIC546.86 → 46.11
Search-o1549.10 → 48.35
Agentic Reasoning445.51 → 44.91
SVP (Ours)351.20 → 50.75
Total41—

After correction, SVP remains the best-performing method on HLE, with 50.75% ACC, followed by Search-o1 at 48.35%. On SimpleQA-Verified-300, manual verification identified two false-positive instances for CoT and one for SVP, while ReAct had none. Correcting these cases does not change their relative ranking. GPQA-Diamond consists entirely of multiple-choice questions, so its evaluation is unaffected by substring matching.

Paired statistical analysis. To examine the reported gains on GPQA-Diamond and SimpleQA-Verified-300, we compare SVP against both CoT and ReAct using the original ACC and EM metrics reported in the paper. R3-Table 4 presents their benchmark performance together with paired differences, 95% bootstrap confidence intervals, and exact McNemar p-values. All differences are calculated as SVP minus the corresponding baseline.

R3-Table 4. Paired performance comparisons and statistical tests on GPQA-Diamond and SimpleQA-Verified-300.

BenchmarkMethodACC (%)EM (%)ACC Δ (95% CI), pEM Δ (95% CI), p
GPQA-DiamondCoT84.8584.85+0.51 [−4.04, +5.05], 1.000+0.51 [−4.04, +5.05], 1.000
GPQA-DiamondReAct83.8483.84+1.52 [−3.03, +6.06], 0.664+1.52 [−3.03, +6.06], 0.664
GPQA-DiamondSVP (Ours)85.3585.35——
SimpleQA-Verified-300CoT21.3319.67+33.67 [+27.67, +39.33], 1.04×10⁻²⁵+31.00 [+25.00, +36.33], 3.45×10⁻²²
SimpleQA-Verified-300ReAct54.3350.00+0.67 [−4.00, +5.33], 0.888+0.67 [−4.33, +5.67], 0.894
SimpleQA-Verified-300SVP (Ours)55.0050.67——

Note: The strongest baseline on each benchmark is italicized, and SVP is highlighted in bold. All differences are in percentage points. GPQA-Diamond has identical ACC and EM because all questions are multiple-choice.

The paired analyses reveal different patterns across the two benchmarks. On GPQA-Diamond, SVP achieves higher point estimates than both CoT and ReAct, but the corresponding margins are indeed small and do not reach statistical significance. On SimpleQA-Verified-300, SVP also shows a small, statistically inconclusive advantage over ReAct. However, its advantage over CoT is substantially larger in both ACC and EM, with confidence intervals entirely above zero and very small p-values. Overall, although SVP's margins over the strongest baselines are modest on some benchmarks, it achieves the highest observed performance across both datasets, while the relative ranking of CoT and ReAct varies across benchmarks. This demonstrates the consistency of SVP's performance across different benchmark settings.

Revision. We will include the manual audit and paired statistical analyses in the appendix to provide further evidence of scoring robustness and benchmark-level performance differences.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer bgnk (Part 3)

3. Tool Configuration and State Maintenance (Q3)

Thank you for these implementation-related questions. We clarify the experimental tool setting and the operation of the State Maintainer below.

Tool configuration for controlled comparison. To ensure a fair comparison, all tool-augmented methods share the same web-search backend and search budget. Agentic Reasoning originally includes an additional code-execution tool, which we disable to avoid giving it access to an extra tool modality unavailable to the other methods. Our evaluation focuses on how different methods integrate web-retrieved external knowledge into multi-step reasoning and coordinate subsequent planning and control, rather than comparing heterogeneous tool configurations.

State maintenance for multi-turn execution. REPL (Read-Eval-Print Loop) refers to an interactive execution environment where successive code executions can build upon previous results and runtime variables. SVP's State Maintainer processes the current-step reasoning trajectory. Specifically, it uses two separate LLM calls. A step summarizer produces a concise 1–3 sentence conclusion for cross-step persistence, prioritizing concrete findings such as numerical results and key entities. A state extractor then derives supported claims and unresolved questions for Critic assessment. Thus, when outcomes from multi-turn code execution are included in the current-step reasoning trajectory, they can be summarized and extracted through the same mechanism as web-retrieval results. The State Box retains these compact conclusions rather than the full execution trace or live runtime state. Our evaluation examines how web-retrieved external knowledge enhances step-local reasoning and informs subsequent system-level task orchestration. It does not evaluate the persistence of live REPL runtime states, such as variables, across steps, which would require explicit runtime-state management beyond the current design.

Revision. We will clarify the controlled tool configuration and the input/output design of the State Maintainer in the appendix.

Reviewer_zPYrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

State-Verified Planning (SVP) combines high-level planning, step-local ReAct execution, state summarization, and critic-guided replanning. A compact State Box carries the plan, completed-step conclusions, and execution metadata, while a separate evidence store supports assessment. Experiments on HLE-Verified Gold, GPQA-Diamond, and a 300-question SimpleQA-Verified subset report gains over reasoning and agentic baselines, with additional budget, cross-model, and component analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework addresses a useful coordination problem. Keeping compact conclusions across steps can reduce context overhead, and revising the remaining plan lets later evidence influence execution. The roles of the State Box, step view, and evidence store are clearly distinguished.
  2. The evaluation covers several relevant settings. SVP leads the reported main-table metrics across three benchmarks. The HLE gains of 6.88 and 7.34 accuracy points on the two additional backbones are encouraging. The budget study also shows that SVP can use additional search capacity productively.
  3. The implementation details are transparent. The appendix provides prompts, an end-to-end algorithm, actual search and token counts, and the scoring procedure. It also discloses the mixed critic-ablation results and the disabled code tool in the Agentic Reasoning baseline.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The critic's overall benefit remains unclear. In Table 3, disabling critic-triggered search and replanning raises HLE ACC from 51.20 to 51.95 and EM from 48.65 to 48.80, while F1 falls slightly. These small differences do not establish that the critic is harmful, but they leave its contribution unresolved. Intervention counts and selected successful examples show that it acts, rather than how often it helps overall.
  2. The State Box ablation changes both representation and information. Removing the State Box also removes the plan, completed-step conclusions, and metadata from the relevant inputs. The resulting drop supports carrying information across steps, but does not isolate the benefit of the proposed structured format over a plain summary containing the same information.
  3. The gains are not fully separated from inference cost. On HLE, SVP uses 83.7K total tokens per question versus 12.0K for Search-o1. The lower-budget SVP result also beats a higher-token ReAct run, which is useful evidence. Still, varying a search limit is not a matched total-compute comparison, so the accuracy–cost trade-off against a baseline given additional reasoning attempts remains uncertain.
  4. Open-ended answer scoring needs validation. Appendix D awards ACC when the reference string occurs in the extracted final answer. This can count a wrong number containing the reference as a substring as correct, while EM can reject equivalent formulations. A common evaluator is helpful, but does not remove possible differences caused by answer format. It is unclear how often these issues affect the reported ranking.
Questions for authors
  1. On the same set of questions, how often does enabling critic-guided control change an incorrect answer to a correct one, and how often does it do the reverse?
  2. How does the State Box compare with a plain summary containing the same plan, conclusions, and metadata under the same context budget?
  3. Does SVP retain its advantage under a matched total token budget when the comparison method can use additional reasoning attempts?
  4. Could you manually audit a sample of open-ended final answers to estimate scoring errors from substring ACC and assess whether they affect the main comparison?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zPYr (Part 1)

Thank you for your helpful comments and suggestions. We address the four points below, focusing on the Critic's contribution, the State Box representation, token cost and computational overhead, and the reliability of open-ended answer scoring.

We sincerely hope these clarifications and additional results address your remaining concerns, and would be grateful if you could reconsider your rating in light of our efforts and dedication. Below, we provide detailed responses to all the comments:


1. Critic's Contribution and Intervention Frequency (Q1, W1)

Thank you for raising this point. Aggregate accuracy alone does not reveal how Critic's interventions affect individual questions. Importantly, w/o Critic is a single-component ablation that disables critic-triggered Refine Search and Replan while retaining the other SVP components, including high-level planning, the State Box, and step-local ReAct execution. We therefore conduct a paired comparison between Full SVP and w/o Critic on the same 668 HLE samples.

R2-Table 1. Paired outcome comparison between Full SVP and w/o Critic on HLE-Verified Gold.

OutcomeNumber of Samples
Both correct300
Full SVP correct, w/o Critic incorrect42
Full SVP incorrect, w/o Critic correct47
Both incorrect279
Total668

The comparison shows 42 favorable and 47 reverse outcome flips, yielding a net difference of five correct answers (342 vs. 347, or 51.20% vs. 51.95% ACC). However, final-answer differences alone do not fully capture the Critic's role during execution. The Critic triggered at least one Replan in 228/668 samples (34.1%). Specifically, the Critic identifies inconsistencies between the evolving reasoning state and the remaining plan and triggers replanning; the Planner then revises the remaining subgoals based on accumulated evidence while preserving completed progress. These results illustrate the Critic's role as a feedback mechanism within SVP's broader architecture, which connects cross-step state and step-local execution with system-level adaptation, rather than as a standalone answer optimizer.

Revision. We will include the paired outcome-flip analysis and Replan statistics in the appendix to provide a more comprehensive assessment of the Critic's contribution.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zPYr (Part 2)

2. State Box vs. Plain-text Summary (Q2, W2)

Thank you for highlighting the importance of examining cross-step information transfer. To investigate this more directly, we added a Plain-text Summary baseline that preserves the same cross-step information as the State Box, including the current plan, completed-step conclusions, and execution metadata, but presents it as continuous natural-language text rather than explicitly organized fields. This provides a controlled comparison in which the information available to subsequent steps remains the same while its representation varies. The summary is produced by a deterministic formatter, without additional LLM-based summarization, and all other experimental settings remain unchanged.

The following example illustrates the two representations provided at Step 2:

R2-Table 2. Comparison of Plain-text Summary and Structured State Box representations.

InformationPlain-text SummaryStructured State Box
PlanThe plan is to first extract the UniProt accession number from the provided AlphaFold URL (e.g., P61949), then use a reliable source (such as UniProt or the AlphaFold entry page) to retrieve the protein name associated with that accession, and finally output the protein name as the answer.Plan: Step 1: Extract the UniProt accession number from the provided AlphaFold URL (e.g., P61949). Step 2: Use a reliable source (such as UniProt or the AlphaFold entry page) to retrieve the protein name associated with that accession. Step 3: Output the protein name as the answer.
Completed step conclusionsThe completed work for Step 1 established that the UniProt accession number extracted is P61949, which corresponds to the protein "Flavodoxin 1".Completed step conclusions: Step 1 conclusion: The UniProt accession number extracted is P61949, which corresponds to the protein "Flavodoxin 1".
ToolsThe available tools are Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode).Tools: Web search (serper+jina, extractor mode).
Search budgetFour of the original five search calls remain.Web search budget: 5 total (remaining: 4).
Current instructionThe current instruction is to perform Step 2 reasoning.Step prompt: Please perform Step 2 reasoning.

The corresponding performance comparison is shown below:

R2-Table 3. Performance comparison of SVP-Full, Plain-text Summary, and w/o State Box on HLE-Verified Gold.

VariantACC (%)EM (%)F1Avg. Tokens
SVP-Full51.2048.650.526883,672
Plain-text Summary50.4547.900.506983,583
w/o State Box49.8547.600.513686,400

Plain-text Summary improves ACC by 0.60 percentage points over w/o State Box (50.45% vs. 49.85%), supporting the benefit of retaining cross-step information. With the same information preserved, SVP-Full achieves a further 0.75-point ACC gain and a higher F1 (0.5268 vs. 0.5069), with nearly identical average token consumption (83,672 vs. 83,583). These results suggest that retaining cross-step information contributes to performance, while explicitly organizing it into structured fields provides a modest additional benefit for subsequent reasoning.

Revision. We will include the Plain-text Summary comparison and representative examples of the two state representations in the Appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zPYr (Part 3)

3. Token Cost Analysis and Computational Overhead (Q3, W3)

Thank you for raising this point. SVP's system-level orchestration involves multiple LLM modules and therefore introduces additional inference costs. To better understand this overhead, we further broke down the token consumption of individual modules based on the main experiments on HLE-Verified Gold (668 samples). The results, reported as average tokens per sample, are summarized below:

R2-Table 4. Module-level token consumption and ACC comparison on HLE-Verified Gold.

MethodPlanningExecutorExtractorCriticMaintainerFinalTotalACC (%)†
ReAct–27,298––––27,29848.65
Plan + ReAct4,57519,413––––23,98746.71
SVP (Ours)10,23225,87618,10710,3179,6929,44883,67251.20

† ACC values are taken from the main results and included for reference.

Notably, SVP's Executor receives the original question and the current State Box rather than the full interaction history. Its average input-token consumption is 8,702, compared with 17,128 for ReAct and 12,178 for Plan + ReAct, reflecting a more compact context for step-local reasoning. The additional overall cost of SVP comes from its system-level modules, including planning, evidence extraction, critic-guided control, and state maintenance. Nevertheless, the multi-module architecture does introduce additional inference overhead. Reducing the token costs of individual modules while preserving the benefits of system-level coordination is an important direction for future work.

Revision. We will provide the module-level token cost breakdown and the associated analysis in the appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zPYr (Part 4)

4. Validation of Open-ended Answer Scoring (Q4, W4)

Thank you for raising this concern. Following the evaluation protocol of Agentic Reasoning (ACL 2025), we use Accuracy (ACC) based on normalized reference-answer string containment, alongside Exact Match (EM) and token-level F1. All methods share the same answer extraction and normalization procedures.

Since an exact match necessarily satisfies substring containment, potential false positives are confined to open-ended predictions with ACC=1 but EM=0. We manually inspected all such predictions across the nine methods in the main HLE comparison and identified 41 false positives. Multiple-choice questions are unaffected because they are evaluated using mapped option labels.

We recalculated ACC by treating these false positives as incorrect while keeping the original evaluation denominator unchanged:

R2-Table 5. False-positive counts and audited ACC across methods on HLE-Verified Gold.

MethodFalse PositivesACC (Original → Audited)
DirectQA (NT)629.94 → 29.04
CoT547.75 → 47.01
Plan + CoT446.86 → 46.26
ReAct548.65 → 47.90
Plan + ReAct446.71 → 46.11
CRITIC546.86 → 46.11
Search-o1549.10 → 48.35
Agentic445.51 → 44.91
SVP (Ours)351.20 → 50.75

The corrections reduce ACC by at most 0.90 percentage points for any method. Importantly, SVP remains the best-performing method among the nine main-table methods, with an audited ACC of 50.75%, compared with 48.35% for the next-best baseline, Search-o1. Thus, these scoring errors do not change the main comparative conclusion.

Revision. We will include the manual audit and corrected evaluation results in the appendix.


We are grateful for the time and care you have devoted to reviewing our work. Your feedback has helped us further clarify the methodological contributions of SVP and strengthen its empirical evaluation.

We hope that the clarifications and additional analyses provided in this response have addressed your concerns, and would sincerely appreciate it if you would consider revising your rating in light of our responses and the additional evidence provided.

Reviewer_fdEmOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The work presents State-Verified Planning (SVP) which is an agentic framework for question answering in knowledge-intensive setting. The framework decomposes a query into sub-goals, runs a local ReAct on each subgoal, and carries compact conclusions forward via State Box. After each step, a maintainer component and a critic decides whether to continue, make extra tool calls, or replan. I have some issues with the framing of the paper which I describe under weaknesses.

Critical strengths

The general issue the paper touches on is important. Agents and their interactions with the external world could introduce contradictory information into the reasoning chain. This problem requires a principled solution. The paper aims to empirically address this issue and some aspects of the design are reasonable attempts (though not novel).

Critical weaknesses

The abstract of the paper (and the introduction does not help with this) lists “challenging assumptions or reshaping reasoning” but does not clarify how this is related to the incorporation of the external knowledge. It then proposes “coordination of external knowledge through cross-step and adaptive control” which is basically coming across as engineering details and lacks a clear link of how the stated problem is addressed by the proposed SVP framework. Assessing the novelty aspect of the work is also quite difficult. The literature review provides a list of previous works under Agent Orchestration but never states what the existing methods lack and where the current submission sits with respect to them. Basically, the framework contains decomposition of a question into sub-goals, handling of context across those sub-goals (i.e. via state box), verification/critic for each step which also guides the execution of tools. If we take these components apart, they already exist in the literature across several papers (i.e., decomposition roots back to papers like Self-Ask 2023, or Plan-and-Solve 2023, Critic itself was coined in the paper back in 2023, etc). The authors should state precisely which capability is missing from these methods and isolate it empirically in the experiment. Also from the literature review, it seems methods like VeriMAP and VMAO have common components (i.e., plan-execute-verify-replan cycle) but these methods are missing in the empirical comparisons.

Table 1 shows several baselines but out of those only Agentic Reasoning could be a reasonable choice, and still there needs to be other more recent baselines (such as VeriMAP, VMAO) that have similar design to SVP included. Comparison with ReAct in Figure 2 is not bringing new insights other than re-echoing the main empirical argument of the paper.

What is interesting is Table 3 but the sample size is so small (668) that the differences we are seeing could be somewhere between 4-10 questions only so it would be useful to show results across different seeds. Considering the results without tools (ACC: 49.7), highlights a difference of roughly 10 questions which undermines the main narrative of the paper around external knowledge requirement. Also the highest result seems to be where the Critic is removed (ACC: 51.95) which somewhat goes against one of the main claims of the paper. It would be insightful to see how many correct flips component like Critic have introduced (i.e., could it be that it fixes some errors but also introduces new errors and they cancel each other in the final result?).

The paper consistently uses the wrong in-text citation format. In-text citations need to be between brackets unless they are narrative citations. There are too many citation formatting issue even on page 1 (i.e., 7 issues).

Questions for authors

Please see my comments under critical weaknesses. Basically, there needs to be more competitive baselines, sensitivity analysis to random seeds (specially since ablation sample set in Table 3 is not that large). Flip analysis could be done to better understand the contribution of each component (i.e., in particular for Critic and Statebox) and quantifying how much they resolve existing failures and how many new failures they introduce.

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer fdEm (Part 1)

Thank you for your careful reading and constructive feedback. We have organized our response into five points: problem motivation and mechanism (Q1), relationship to existing methods (Q2), tool-budget analysis, external knowledge, and empirical robustness (Q3), component contributions (Q4), and citation and formatting (Q5).

We sincerely hope these clarifications and additional results address your remaining concerns, and would be grateful if you could reconsider your rating in light of our efforts and dedication. Below, we provide detailed responses to all the comments:


Q1. Problem Motivation and Mechanistic Contributions of SVP

Thank you for raising this concern. Our central problem is that, in multi-step reasoning, newly derived conclusions or external evidence may challenge earlier assumptions, which can nevertheless persist in the remaining plan and mislead subsequent reasoning. We investigate this challenge in knowledge-intensive question answering, where web search introduces external evidence that may support, refine, or contradict the model's existing conclusions. SVP addresses this issue by connecting step-local reasoning with subsequent task-level adaptation. The state maintainer records each step's conclusion in an evolving State Box for subsequent steps, while the critic assesses the current State Box alongside a structured view of the executor's reasoning trajectory and accumulated evidence. Based on this assessment, the critic decides whether to continue, request further search, or trigger replanning. When needed, the planner revises the remaining subgoals while preserving completed progress, allowing newly acquired evidence to influence subsequent reasoning rather than remain isolated within the current step.

To further illustrate this problem and how SVP addresses it, we present two representative trajectories:

 1. Sample 673a8c2e4e2e35b51a27fafd: Web evidence showed that mucA mutations in hypermutator strains have a narrower spectrum, while the remaining plan still assumed a wider spectrum. The critic flagged the unsupported claim of a "wider variety of mucA mutations" and recommended replanning. The planner then revised the subsequent answer-selection step to reflect the narrower spectrum, yielding the correct option C.

 2. Sample 66febb7d2cb8fd8d04bcce70: Accumulated conclusions placed the martensite start temperature at 150–200°C, whereas the remaining plan still assumed 100–150°C and targeted option B. The critic flagged this outdated estimate and recommended replanning, after which the planner revised the answer-selection step to option F, yielding the correct answer.

These cases are not isolated. Across the 668 HLE-Verified Gold trajectories, 219 (32.8%) had at least one unsupported-claim flag when the critic first recommended replanning, indicating that potential misalignments between ongoing reasoning and accumulated evidence were explicitly identified during execution.

Together, these results and examples show how SVP connects evolving evidence and intermediate conclusions to subsequent plan adaptation, rather than treating external knowledge merely as information used within individual reasoning steps.

Revision. We will further clarify the problem motivation and SVP's mechanistic contributions in the Introduction, and refine the corresponding descriptions and trajectory analyses in the Appendix.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer fdEm (Part 2)

Q2. Relationship to Existing Methods and Differentiation of SVP

Thank you for this helpful suggestion. SVP builds on established components, including task planning, tool-augmented reasoning, and critique and verification mechanisms. However, our contribution is not to introduce these components individually as new techniques, but rather to coordinate them through cross-step state tracking and evidence-conditioned system-level control, enabling accumulated evidence to guide subsequent plan adaptation.

The following table summarizes the functional differences between SVP and representative prior methods.

R1-Table 1. Functional comparison between SVP and representative prior methods.

MethodExplicit Task DecompositionTool UseCritic / VerifierRemaining-plan ReplanningSystem-level OrchestrationMain Focus
Self-Ask (with Search Engine) (Press et al., 2023)✓✓———Follow-up question decomposition with search
Plan-and-Solve (Wang et al., 2023)✓————Plan-first subtask decomposition
ReAct (Yao et al., 2022)—✓———Interleaved reasoning and tool actions
Plan + ReAct✓✓———Fixed initial plan with stepwise tool use
CRITIC (Gou et al., 2024)—✓✓——Tool-interactive critique and answer revision
Search-o1 (Li et al., 2025)—✓———On-demand retrieval and document-level knowledge refinement
Agentic Reasoning (Wu et al., 2025)—✓——✓Tool-agent coordination and structured Mind-Map memory
VeriMAP (Xu et al., 2026)✓✓✓✓✓Dependency-aware subtasks and planner-defined output verification
VMAO (Zhang et al., 2026)✓✓✓✓✓Parallel DAG execution and completeness-driven replanning
SVP (Ours)✓✓✓✓✓Cross-step state tracking and evidence-conditioned plan adaptation

Note: ✓ indicates an explicitly supported core mechanism; — indicates that the method does not specify it as a core mechanism. Explicit task decomposition refers to high-level subtask decomposition; remaining-plan replanning specifically refers to task-plan revision, rather than search-query optimization or answer revision.

Among system-level frameworks, Agentic Reasoning coordinates external tool-using agents with structured Mind-Map memory. VeriMAP organizes tasks into dependency-aware DAGs and employs planner-defined verification functions to assess individual subtask outputs. VMAO adopts a Plan–Execute–Verify–Replan–Synthesize workflow, coordinating specialized agents through parallel DAG execution and completeness-based verification. In contrast, SVP focuses on maintaining an evolving cross-step state that connects intermediate conclusions and accumulated evidence with subsequent reasoning and task planning.

Comparison with VeriMAP (Xu et al., 2026). VeriMAP organizes tasks as a DAG, passes outputs between dependent subtasks through Structured I/O and Named Variables, and uses planner-generated verification functions (VFs) to evaluate individual subtask outputs. The VFs are expressed either as Python code or as natural-language criteria. Its original evaluation covers diverse tasks, including multi-hop RAG question answering (MultiHopRAG), code generation (HumanEval and BigCodeBench-Hard), and mathematical reasoning (GSM8K and Olympiads). For question answering, VeriMAP employs a dedicated search tool based on Sentence Transformers to retrieve information from an article collection. This evaluation setting differs from the open-web retrieval setting we use for HLE, GPQA-Diamond, and SimpleQA-Verified-300. Consequently, its original evaluation results are not directly comparable to ours. To enable a direct comparison under our experimental setting, we adapted VeriMAP's public implementation to use the same reasoning backbone, web-search tools, and other hyperparameters as our main experiments, while retaining its original DAG planning, Structured I/O and Named Variables, verification, retry, and replanning mechanisms.

R1-Table 2. Performance comparison between adapted VeriMAP and SVP under the same experimental setting.

DatasetMethodACC (%)EM (%)F1 (%)
HLE-Verified Gold (668)VeriMAP (adapted)18.2617.2218.70
HLE-Verified Gold (668)SVP (Ours)51.2048.6552.68
GPQA-Diamond (198)VeriMAP (adapted)76.7776.7776.80
GPQA-Diamond (198)SVP (Ours)85.3585.3585.35
SimpleQA-Verified-300 (300)VeriMAP (adapted)31.3329.6740.50
SimpleQA-Verified-300 (300)SVP (Ours)55.0050.6767.73
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer fdEm (Part 3)

SVP consistently outperforms the adapted VeriMAP across all three datasets, achieving ACC improvements of 32.9, 8.6, and 23.7 percentage points, respectively. Beyond the differences in their original evaluation settings, the two frameworks also differ in how intermediate results influence subsequent execution. Although VeriMAP supports semantic verification through natural-language VFs and passes outputs from upstream to downstream subtasks, its runtime replanning is primarily triggered when a subtask still fails verification after exhausting its retry attempts. Consequently, if newly retrieved evidence challenges a previously established conclusion but the corresponding subtask output still satisfies its predefined verification criteria, replanning is not necessarily triggered. In contrast, SVP reassesses the evolving cross-step state together with accumulated evidence after each step. When necessary, the system can acquire additional evidence and subsequently either continue with the current plan or invoke the replanning module to revise the remaining plan. This allows external evidence to support local reasoning within the current step while also informing subsequent reasoning and system-level task planning.

Comparison with VMAO (Zhang et al., 2026). VMAO also adopts a Plan–Execute–Verify–Replan–Synthesize framework, decomposing complex queries into dependency-aware DAGs of sub-questions and executing specialized agents in parallel where dependencies permit. Its LLM-based verifier assesses the completeness of execution results and identifies information gaps, triggering retries or generating additional sub-questions. However, VMAO is primarily evaluated on 25 expert-curated market research queries, using answer completeness and source quality ratings on a 1–5 scale rather than answer-level ACC, EM, and F1 on fixed-reference question-answering benchmarks. Thus, its task formulation and evaluation protocol differ substantially from ours. Furthermore, we could not identify a publicly accessible implementation that would permit faithful reproduction under our experimental setting. Therefore, we do not report a direct numerical comparison with VMAO.

Overall, SVP addresses a central challenge in multi-step reasoning: how to consistently preserve and propagate evidence-supported conclusions across steps, and how to adapt subsequent reasoning and plans when newly acquired evidence challenges prior assumptions. We evaluate SVP on three datasets—HLE-Verified Gold, GPQA-Diamond, and SimpleQA-Verified-300—demonstrating its effectiveness across different knowledge-intensive reasoning tasks. The core contribution of SVP lies in a compact and continuously evolving State Box that maintains the current task plan, concise conclusions from completed steps, and execution-related information such as the current-step prompt, available tools, and remaining tool budget. This continuously updated state representation allows newly acquired external evidence to influence subsequent reasoning and task planning, thereby supporting evidence-based reasoning and adaptive plan revision in multi-step tasks.

Revision. We will further clarify the functional distinctions between SVP and representative prior methods in the revised manuscript, and add the VeriMAP experimental results and corresponding analysis to the Appendix.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.