acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Building Trustworthy Scientific Environments for Coding Agents

Abstract

Automated scientific discovery is emerging as a new paradigm where coding agents interact with scientific environments to pursue open-ended research goals. While recent work has improved agent capabilities, the role of environments in shaping scientific exploration remains largely unexplored. In this work, we show that environmental feedback influences how coding agents explore and optimize scientific objectives through controlled studies with four coding agents across four feedback settings. We then introduce SciEnBuilder, an automated framework that transforms paper–repository pairs into trusted scientific environments by connecting scientific claims, executable evidence, and protected evaluation. Using SciEnBuilder, we construct 30 scientific environments for coding agents from a large collection of top-tier papers. Human evaluation confirms their faithfulness to the original scientific goals and the reliability of their evaluation. Compared with raw repositories, these environments improve research efficiency, eliminate observed shortcut behaviors, and enable stronger long-horizon optimization. These results highlight the importance of trustworthy scientific environments for reliable automated scientific discovery.

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
automatic scientiifc discovery, coding agent, environment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.60 over 5 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_j9w2OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SciEnBuilder, a framework that automatically constructs a reliable scientific research environment from pairs of papers and repositories by linking scientific claims, verifiable experimental evidence, and protected evaluation mechanisms. Using this framework, this paper constructed 30 types of scientific research environments for Coding Agents from a large collection of top-tier academic papers. Furthermore, through manual evaluation, this paper confirmed that the constructed environments remain faithful to the scientific objectives of the original papers and that the evaluation mechanisms are reliable. Additionally, this paper demonstrated that utilizing these environments enables improved research efficiency, the elimination of observed shortcut behaviors, and the achievement of more advanced long-term optimization.

Critical strengths
  • S1. Automation of Environment Preparation. In previous studies, environment preparation has mainly been done manually or has not been considered in detail. Therefore, proposing an automated method for this process is a meaningful contribution.

  • S2. Quantitative Demonstration of Efficiency Improvement. The paper quantitatively shows how much efficiency can be improved simply by preparing the environment. This result highlights the importance of environment preparation for future research.

Critical weaknesses
  • W1. The novelty and significance of the contribution are limited: The main contribution of this study is the automatic construction of a scientific research environment from existing papers and repositories; it does not propose new methods for improving the capabilities of the agent itself. Therefore, the novelty relative to existing research and the significance for the development of scientific research agents appear somewhat limited.

  • W2. The scale and diversity of the constructed scientific research environments are limited: Although this study constructs 30 types of scientific research environments, this number is relatively small, and the target research fields are also limited. And out of these environments, only 10 environments have actually been run as experiments.

  • W3. Lack of comparison with other simple baselines: To prevent shortcut behavior, one possible approach is to prohibit improper operations through instruction files such as AGENTS.md or system prompts. Therefore, it would be desirable to compare these simple prompt-based methods as a baseline and verify whether the environment configuration using the proposed method is truly necessary.

  • W4. I am not sure how effective the details of the proposed method actually are. Specifically, I am not sure whether a DAG is necessary, nor am I sure whether the paper and the code need to be examined separately (L305, L307). It might be helpful to have experiments that demonstrate the effectiveness of these approaches.

Questions for authors

For more details, please refer to “Critical Weaknesses.” In particular, I am concerned about the significance of the paper's contribution.

Reviewer_uaihOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how environmental feedback shapes coding agents’ research behavior and introduces SciEnBuilder to construct scientific environments from papers and repositories. The framework fixes the research objective, protects evaluation, and connects scores to execution evidence. Validation includes controlled feedback experiments, expert audits, comparisons with original repositories, and longer optimization runs.

Critical strengths

Strong systems motivation. An optimizing agent places unusual pressure on experimental infrastructure: weaknesses in measurement can become optimization opportunities. Treating evaluation integrity as a first-class design concern addresses an important obstacle to reliable automated research.

Coherent design with practical validation. Separating editable methods from authoritative evaluation, preserving the protocol during repairs, and tracing results to executions form a sensible architecture. The experiments provide useful evidence that the resulting environments improve the reliability and efficiency of experimentation.

Critical weaknesses

The main technical difficulty remains insufficiently exposed. The hardest problem appears to be recovering the intended scientific protocol from potentially incomplete or inconsistent papers and code. The paper explains the resulting contracts and records more clearly than the mechanisms that make this reconstruction reliable. Freezing a specification preserves its identity; establishing its scientific correctness requires separate evidence.

The evaluation does not isolate the value of the additional machinery. Comparing the complete system with raw repositories combines dependency repair, task clarification, evaluator isolation, and structured feedback. This leaves uncertainty about which benefits require the claim graph, frozen contract, and hypothesis/evidence workflow, and which follow from preparing a runnable environment with a protected evaluator

Questions for authors

Where does the main technical difficulty lie? Please show one challenging paper-to-environment conversion, including how a paper–code mismatch is resolved, what is independently verified, and what requires human judgment.

Can you compare against a prepared, runnable repository with an aligned, protected evaluator? Please isolate what the additional contract and evidence mechanisms contribute, particularly which failures they prevent.

How many paper–repository pairs were attempted, and what construction costs, failures, and manual interventions were required? This would help establish how broadly the automation applies.

Reviewer_c9JzOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how feedback affects scientific coding agents. It introduces SciEnBuilder, which builds research environments from papers and code repositories. The system links evaluation to the paper's scientific goal and protects the evaluator from the agent. The evaluation includes expert reviews and agent experiments.

Critical strengths

Reliable evaluation is important for scientific agents. The 30 environments and experiments across several agents provide useful evidence about this problem.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main comparison changes environment setup, evaluator access, and feedback together. It is hard to tell what the proposed feedback design adds over a prepared environment with protected evaluation.
  2. The 24 hour study has eight tasks, with one run per task and no matched baseline. This limits the evidence for reliable long-term gains.
Questions for authors

Can you compare with a prepared environment that also protects the evaluator? This would help clarify the value of the additional feedback design. And do the 24 hour gains hold across repeated runs and against a matched baseline?

Reviewer_dPorOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Here in this paper the authors study how the feedback provided by scientific environments influences the behavior of autonomous coding agents. The authors first compare four feedback settings to understand reward hacking, objective misalignment, and unstable exploration. They then introduce SciEnBuilder, which automatically transforms scientific papers and repositories into environments with protected evaluators, reproducible experiments, and structured feedback!

The authors construct 30 scientific environments and evaluate several coding agents, reporting improvements in valid research iterations from 45.86% to 80.95%, along with a reduction in observed shortcut behaviors. They also evaluate 24-hour autonomous research runs across eight tasks, demonstrating sustained optimization over longer horizons! cool paper.

Critical strengths

1. I really like the focus on environments rather than just improving agents :)

We spend so much time thinking about better reasoning, memory, and search for scientific agents, but the feedback they receive is just as important. I particularly liked the experiments showing how agents can optimize misleading signals or exploit exposed evaluators. This feels especially relevant as we move toward increasingly autonomous AI research.

2. The scale and practical implementation are impressive.

Building 30 environments from real scientific papers and repositories is a meaningful engineering contribution. I also appreciate the human evaluations and longer 24-hour research experiments. The improvements in valid research iterations and reduction in observed shortcut behaviors suggest that better environments can make autonomous research more productive and reliable.

Critical weaknesses

1. What exactly makes the scientific feedback trustworthy?

One thing I kept thinking about while reading this paper is the distinction between protecting an evaluator and actually verifying that it measures the right scientific objective :) SciEnBuilder isolates the evaluator, tracks execution artifacts, and freezes experimental contracts, which I really like. But if the original scientific claim is translated incorrectly into an evaluation contract, the agent could still optimize the wrong objective while passing every subsequent check.

I think this is an important boundary, especially given the paper's emphasis on trustworthy scientific discovery. The authors perform human audits, but I would have liked a clearer discussion of what is guaranteed mechanically and what still depends on expert interpretation.

2. I am curious which part of SciEnBuilder actually drives the improvements.

The framework combines several ideas: protected evaluation, automated setup, structured feedback, frozen contracts, and hypothesis tracking. However, the main comparison is against raw repositories, where agents also spend substantial time configuring environments and debugging dependencies.

So I wonder how much of the improvement comes from better scientific feedback versus simply providing an environment that is easier to run. A component ablation would make the contribution much clearer.

3. The long-horizon results are promising, but the causal evidence is limited.

I enjoyed the 24-hour experiments, especially the examples where agents gradually improve their solutions through repeated feedback. However, these experiments use one agent configuration and do not include matched long-horizon comparisons against alternative environment designs.

I would also distinguish improving an existing benchmark score from making a genuinely new scientific discovery. The former is valuable, but I think the paper occasionally motivates the results more broadly than the experiments establish.

Questions for authors
  1. Scientific fidelity: How do the authors ensure that the automatically constructed evaluation contract actually captures the intended scientific claim? Could formal specifications or independent verification help check this correspondence?

  2. Component ablations: How much of the improvement comes from protecting the evaluator versus providing better feedback or simply making the environment easier to run? I think separating these would be really interesting :)

  3. Long-horizon evaluation: Could the authors compare the 24-hour experiments against otherwise identical environments without SciEnBuilder's structured feedback? This would help establish how much the feedback design contributes to sustained progress.

  4. Reward hacking and generalization: The paper reports reducing observed shortcut behaviors from 206 to 0. Have the authors tested whether stronger agents can discover new ways to exploit the protected evaluator, particularly through repeated queries or diagnostic feedback?

Reviewer_dkGGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how feedback affects coding agents and introduces SciEnBuilder, which converts paper–repository pairs into environments with frozen scientific targets, artifact-grounded scoring, and protected evaluators. Validation includes a 144-run feedback study, expert audits of 30 environments, 240 runs comparing constructed environments with original repositories, and eight 24-hour demonstrations.

Critical strengths
  1. The claim–protocol–artifact linkage and protected evaluation address an important practical bottleneck. Expert audits and the substantial increase in valid iterations (45.86% to 80.95%, Table 2) make the infrastructure contribution useful.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Causal attribution remains unclear: Section 5 compares the full system with original repositories, combining setup, target clarification, isolation, and structured feedback. Without a prepared-repository baseline or component ablations, the gains cannot be attributed specifically to feedback design; the eight long-horizon runs also lack matched controls.
  2. The behavioral evidence is not fully comparable across conditions. Appendix B.1 multiplies VSTR by objective agreement only in C1, while counting exposed-evaluator/reference use in C0 as shortcuts. These choices partly encode the expected disadvantage into the metrics and weaken cross-condition conclusions.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you report a baseline with matched dependencies, task specification, and protected scalar evaluation, then isolate the added effect of structured feedback? A matched long-horizon comparison would clarify the central attribution.
  2. Can you report the same occupancy metric W across C0–C3, objective agreement separately, and shortcut counts distinguishing legitimate evaluation calls from actual label exploitation? Would the conclusions remain under this uniform audit?

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Thank you for the substantial additional work. The new experiments and analyses would benefit from clearer integration into the manuscript, with a more focused presentation of the main claims, supporting evidence, and remaining limitations. My concern about the reproducibility of the long-horizon results remains, and I therefore maintain my current rating.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.