- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents GeoX-2, a feed-forward model for efficient driving-scene geometry estimation. It combines a hybrid encoder, decoder-pair pruning, and geometry distillation from a prior-conditioned teacher to an RGB-only student. The model achieves competitive geometry accuracy and 1003.1 FPS on KITTI.
Critical strengths
- The paper tackles an important practical problem: improving geometry inference efficiency.
- GeoX-2 achieves a good balance between accuracy, speed, and memory usage.
- The ablations are useful, particularly the distillation experiment, which reduces Waymo depth Abs Rel from 0.193 to 0.110.
Critical weaknesses
- The gain from pruning is unclear. In Table 5, most of the speedup comes from replacing the encoder. Without accuracy results for intermediate models, it is difficult to judge how much pruning actually contributes.
- PIS is tested under limited settings. Table 4 only evaluates one pruning budget on Waymo. It is unclear whether the method works equally well when more or fewer decoder pairs are retained.
- The role of geometric priors in distillation is not established. The paper shows that teacher supervision helps, but does not compare a prior-conditioned teacher with an RGB-only teacher. This leaves the main source of improvement unclear.
- The camera-pose results may be influenced by familiar camera rigs. Since the evaluation datasets also appear in the training list, the model may benefit from known camera configurations. A mean-relative-calibration baseline would help address this concern.
- More qualitative results are needed. The paper lacks direct visual comparisons with baselines and ground truth, making it hard to assess local geometric errors and the claimed reduction in checkerboard artifacts. Some figures are also difficult to read due to small labels and unclear connections.
Questions for authors
GeoX-2 is a promising system, especially in terms of efficiency. However, the paper does not clearly establish the individual contributions of pruning and distillation. The limited PIS evaluation, potential bias in camera-pose estimation, and lack of qualitative comparisons also leave important questions unanswered. Thus, a weak rejection is proposed.