- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates how backward truncation changes the target geometry of local supervision. The authors derive matching rules showing that retained state derivatives can require directional corrections rather than simple loss rescaling. Controlled interventions, prospective supervision construction, and experiments using recordings from a 1125-km optical link examine the mechanism and its consequences.
Critical strengths
-
The central insight is meaningful. The theoretical matching rules explain why changing retained derivatives can alter the required supervision direction. The controlled interventions preserve the same forward computation while changing only the retained derivative paths, directly supporting this mechanism.
-
The controlled interventions are carefully designed. The optical receiver experiments provide additional evidence: Complex Quotient supervision improves Q-factor across all 20 workpoints and 40 paired comparisons when dispersion, nonlinear, and residual compensation are trainable under Detached closure.
Critical weaknesses
-
Local matching does not consistently predict training outcomes. The authors report finite-step reversals, while receiver gains are small and configuration-dependent. The closure interaction varies across configurations (26 positive, 28 negative), so the effect of retained derivatives on the Complex Quotient advantage is not uniform.
-
The connection between theory and practical supervision remains incomplete. Exact matching relies on known operators under specific assumptions, while the receiver experiments use fixed structured supervision candidates rather than deriving the matching metric.
Questions for authors
-
Under what conditions can Complex Quotient supervision approximate the theoretically matched metric? Can the matching analysis predict when its advantage over Point becomes larger or smaller under Detached versus AF-Full?
-
Can the authors summarize the absolute Q-factor and computational cost of AF-Full with Point, Detached with Point, and Detached with Complex Quotient under matched training conditions?
Reminder: halfway through discussion period
This is a friendly reminder to the reviewers that we are halfway through the discussion period. The authors have posted responses to the reviews, so please acknowledge the rebuttal, and discuss their response and remaining questions.
Best, AC