- The released implementation does not support a fair, consistent comparison underlying the paper's central performance claims. The reported gains therefore cannot be attributed directly to the proposed method.
Appendix A.1 states that checkpoints are selected by maximizing the sum of validation Recall@20, NDCG@20, Recall@40, and NDCG@40. However, the released code applies a different rule to MultiCBR: it updates the checkpoint only when both Recall@20 and NDCG@20 exceed those of the previously selected checkpoint. CFDGN instead uses the four-metric sum.
These rules are not equivalent. The MultiCBR rule can reject a checkpoint with better aggregate performance if one metric decreases slightly, whereas the CFDGN rule can accept it. The released comparison thus changes both the model architecture and the selection procedure, and does not provide a controlled estimate of the benefit of the structural branch.
This issue bears directly on the main conclusion. On NetEase, the absolute improvements are only 0.0016 in Recall@20 and 0.0009 in NDCG@20. Without ruling out the effect of checkpoint selection, the evidence is insufficient to attribute these differences to the proposed mechanisms.
This is not an incidental implementation detail that can be resolved through a brief clarification alone. The authors need to identify the actual protocol used to produce the reported results and provide comparisons under a common selection rule. Until then, the central evidence for the method's claimed advantage remains inadequate.
- The paper does not establish the substantive value of its central innovations. The existing ablations instead show that most of the gain survives the removal of either core mechanism individually.
In Table 3, the full model improves Recall@20 over the backbone by 0.0111. Removing contextual-role routing reduces Recall@20 by only 0.0010, and replacing candidate-conditioned interest selection with uniform weights reduces it by only 0.0006. Thus, most of the overall gain remains after either of the two emphasized mechanisms is removed separately.
These results do not prove that the components are ineffective. They do, however, expose the central attribution gap: the experiments primarily establish that adding a structural scoring branch helps, not that the proposed role inference and interest selection are responsible for its effectiveness.
MeanPoolBundle does not resolve this issue because it replaces only one representation path while retaining the other structural features and matching mechanisms. There is no conventional pooling or attention-based residual branch with the same inputs, comparable parameter capacity, and the same training procedure. Additional capacity, use of historical information, and residual training therefore remain plausible explanations for most of the gain.
This gap also weakens the novelty claim. BRUCE already models items in the context of their bundle, HIDGN explicitly considers how the same item can express different intents across bundles, and MIND uses target-aware attention to select among historical interests. A different salience-contrast computation does not, by itself, establish a capability absent from these methods.
References:
Internal role-switching statistics cannot substitute for functional validation. The router normalizes the difference between item and context salience again, so a small difference can produce a substantial change in role probabilities. Observing a role switch therefore does not establish that the model has identified a useful contextual role, much less that such changes explain the ranking gains.
The paper currently establishes a particular implementation and its aggregate performance, rather than the necessity or advantage of its central modeling idea. Without that evidence, assembling these components does not constitute a convincing technical contribution.
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for the time and effort you devoted to this paper during the discussion period. We have decided to withdraw the paper from OpenReview in order to protect the intellectual property involved. We sincerely appreciate all the valuable suggestions you raised. We wish you all the best.
Best regards,
The Authors