- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses breast tumor segmentation when only the pre-contrast volume of a DCE-MRI exam is available at test time. The full sequence is used only during training. The proposed HDRSNet has three parts. A recurrent conditional diffusion model (RHD) generates each post-contrast phase from the previous one; it is trained with a scheduled blend of real and generated conditioning (dynamic blending) and with a loss weighted by a soft gate computed from the enhancement magnitude and the tumor mask (local decoupling). Intermediate features of the denoising network, rather than the generated images, are injected into a 3D U-Net that takes the pre-contrast volume, through cross-attention at every scale (MTC). On DUKE (291 cases) and I-SPY2 (970 cases), the method is reported to reach 84.9 and 78.5 DSC from the pre-contrast volume alone, above the best full-sequence baseline (TSESNet, 83.7 and 76.5) and above three generate-then-segment pipelines.
Critical strengths
- The setting is clinically meaningful. Using the contrast-enhanced phases only as training-time supervision, and segmenting from a non-contrast scan at test time, would remove the need for contrast injection if it worked reliably.
- Taking intermediate features of a phase-synthesis diffusion model instead of its synthesized images is a reasonable idea, and it avoids passing image-level artifacts to the segmenter.
- The experimental section is broad: two main datasets, nine baselines, ablations of the blending schedule, loss weights, fusion levels and sampling steps, cross-center and CT experiments, and a limitations section.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central result is hard to accept as presented. At inference the model sees only V0, so every hemodynamic feature is a function of V0 and random noise, yet HDRSNet is reported to beat all models that use the real post-contrast phases and to more than double the DSC of nnUNet and MedSegDiff given the same V0 input (78.5 versus 33.0 and 25.8 on I-SPY2, Table 12). Even the ablation whose generated phases reach an SSIM of only 0.30 scores 54.1 DSC (Table 3). The controls that could explain this are missing: the plain 3D U-Net on V0 trained with the same recipe, and HDRSNet with real phases at inference as an upper bound. A label leak also cannot be ruled out. The gate in Eq. (4) is built with the ground-truth mask Y and, by Eq. (7), multiplies the features passed to the segmentation network. The text says the gate at inference is computed "in the same form" from the predicted residual, Algorithm 1 applies no gate at inference, and Appendix B.2 gives two further definitions (Eq. 16 without Y, Eq. 19 with a different use of Y). The values of κ, τ and λ are not given.
-
Table 5 reports p-values between 1e-7 and 1e-15 "from five runs", but the means and standard deviations in the same table do not support them. A two-sample t-test on those numbers gives p = 0.03 for DSC and 0.13 for HD against TSESNet on I-SPY2, and 0.27, 0.72 and 0.12 for the three metrics on DUKE. For I-SPY2, all nine reported p-values have the same leading digits as the recomputed ones, but exponents that are 2 to 10 orders of magnitude smaller. Standard deviations for the same configuration also differ between tables (on DUKE, 84.93 ± 1.67 and 6.87 ± 2.17 in Table 1 versus 84.93 ± 1.2 and 6.87 ± 1.5 in Table 11). With the reported variances, the advantage over TSESNet on DUKE is within run-to-run noise.
-
In Table 2 the synthetic sequences appear to be fed to the TSESNet that was trained on real sequences ("the same TSESNet"), so these pipelines are tested under a domain shift that HDRSNet does not face. The direct test of the first contribution is missing, namely feeding HDRSNet's own generated phases to a segmenter and comparing this with using its features. On cost, the 216 G FLOPs in Table 1 cannot plausibly include the 125 denoising passes needed per window (five phases, 25 DDIM steps), and 2.2 s per case is hard to reconcile with sliding-window inference.
Questions for authors
- What exactly is the gate at inference? Is the mask Y used in any form at test time, and what are the values of κ, τ and λ? What is the result when the feature gate of Eq. (7) is removed during both training and inference?
- Could the authors report the segmentation backbone alone on V0 with the same training recipe, and HDRSNet with features extracted from the real phases at inference?
- How were the p-values and confidence intervals in Table 5 computed (which test, on which samples, with what n)? Why do the standard deviations of the same configuration differ between Table 1 and Table 11?
- In Table 2, was TSESNet retrained on the synthetic sequences? What is the result when HDRSNet's own generated phases are fed to TSESNet? How are FLOPs and time per case counted (number of windows, phases and DDIM steps)?