- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates whether an ordinary RGB camera can recover hidden-screen content by observing the diffuse light it casts onto a visible wall. The authors propose OEPRL, which consists of two modules, RCER and OCPL: RCER organizes the mixed wall response into reliability-calibrated global evidence and positioned local tokens; OCPL uses prediction errors between wall evidence and decoder features to perform sequential global and local corrections. The authors evaluate on self-collected Browser, Figure, Game, and Lock datasets, report ranking first in all 12 LPIPS, SSIM, and PSNR comparisons, and validate the contribution of each module and a degree of robustness through ablations, occlusion, noise, illumination, viewpoint, and wall roughness experiments.
Critical strengths
The problem setting is novel, and the paper provides an initial demonstration of recovering hidden-screen content from diffuse wall light. By connecting hidden-screen recovery with an ordinary RGB camera and diffuse wall reflections, the paper expands the boundary of non-line-of-sight imaging and offers a complete system, baselines, and multi-perturbation experiments that can inform future work.
Critical weaknesses
The paper does not sufficiently justify the practical value of the problem; the scarcity of related work does not make the problem important. The authors motivate the work with hidden-screen recovery from diffuse wall reflections, but they do not provide concrete application scenarios, user needs, or threat models. The recovered information is mainly limited to brightness, dominant colors, and regional layout, while texture and fine details are largely lost; PSNR is only 17–19 dB and the visual results are blurry. If the goal is merely to show that an ordinary camera can perform some form of NLOS imaging, it is unclear whether the advantage over existing NLOS methods—such as ultrafast laser, interferometry, or polarization—is sufficient to support an independent research problem. The authors need to answer: who needs this capability, under what conditions is it useful, and what practical tasks can the recovered coarse content support? Otherwise, the problem looks more like an interesting demo than a clearly valuable research direction.
Questions for authors
-
What are the concrete application scenarios or threat models for this capability? Who needs to recover hidden-screen content from wall reflections? Compared with existing NLOS methods such as ultrafast laser, interferometry, or polarization, is the advantage of an ordinary RGB camera sufficient to constitute an independent and important problem?
-
Can the authors provide cross-scene, cross-wall, and cross-device generalization experiments? If all results come from the same experimental environment, how can we be sure the method has not simply memorized that environment?
-
Does RCER’s reliability calibration have quantitative validation? How can we know it selects “reliable evidence” rather than merely “easy-to-reconstruct regions”? Can it be compared with learned uncertainty estimation or physical propagation models?
-
Reconstruction PSNR is only 17–19 dB, mainly recovering low-frequency layout and dominant colors, with texture details largely lost. What practical use does this quality have in real scenarios? Should the authors add task-oriented metrics such as layout matching, color distribution, OCR readability, or semantic consistency?