- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The main motivation of this paper is that large-scale training data are collected in a source-library setting, whereas applications occur in an endogenous setting. BE-CORR formulates endogenous prediction as source-to-endogenous correction, it first obtains a source-library prior, then predicts context-dependent correction terms for the endogenous context, and finally combines them to form the endogenous prediction. BE-CORR is evaluated on endogenous endpoint prediction and matched source-to-endogenous transfer benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation is practical and clear. The chromatin context is critical to endogenous base-editing outcomes and could be emphasized to make accurate endogenous predictions.
-
I find the measured source–endogenous benchmark is also valuable. The reconstruction of matched pairs by concrete editor construct and exact 40-nt context is a good experimental contribution. It allows the evaluation of a setting in which the source outcome is actually observed, rather than inferring transfer quality only from a predicted source profile. Also, BE-CORR includes hazard scaling, local transport, and reliability gating to model overall editing strength, location changes, and source reliability, which provide interpretable endogenous outcomes to some degree.
I also checked the main-text mathematical claims and all of them are coherent and looks sound to me.
Critical weaknesses
Due to the 1-2 critical weakness limit of this block, I moved few weaknesses to the Question section.
-
Limited contribution of problem reformulation: The previous study BE_Endo already systematically investigated the differences between source-library and endogenous editing outcomes and showed the influence of endogenous genomic context on editing outcomes. BE-CORR recasts this widely known problem as source-to-endogenous correction and lists it as one of its main contributions. This reformulation provides limited additional insight beyond adding the source profile as an additional input.
Moreover, Sec. 5 describes the adaptations largely as retaining released encoders or feature and replacing task-specific heads. Some adaptation is understandable because the methods have different native outputs. However, the resulting comparisons establish performance against the specified adaptations; they do not automatically establish superiority over the complete published methods.
-
Unclear Advantages Over Simpler Residual Correction Methods: The central claim of BE-CORR is to incorporate source-library profiles into context-aware prediction to learn source-to-endogenous correction, which is essentially a form of residual correction of source-library predictions. Although BE-CORR includes hazard scaling, local transport, and reliability gating, the current experiments do not prove that adding these modules improves prediction accuracy over simple source-conditioned residual correction.
Questions for authors
-
Table 9 shows that the model without correction context retains approximately 71% of the absolute improvement over direct prediction. This does not mean endogenous context is not important, since the direct branch still receives endogenous features, and the full model performs better.
A convincing study would remove or permute context separately in the correction and direct branches, and report the results on the measured-source benchmark.
-
I also have reservations regarding the hazard representation claim. The expected number of edited bases is the sum of marginal editing probabilities. BE-CORR instead conserves the sum of transformed hazards during transport. These are different quantities.
-
The biological assumption of Hazard transport is questionable: BE-CORR assumes that changes in editing activity at different positions can be represented by mass-conserving hazard transport, which means that reduced editing activity at one position can be redistributed to other positions. However, in reality, editing activity at multiple positions may increase or decrease simultaneously, and such changes do not necessarily follow a mass-conserving transfer mechanism. Additional biological evidence should be provided to support the assumption of mass-conserving transport.
-
Figure 1B is not sufficient to prove the usefulness of the reliability gate: The results show that when the model relies more on source predictions, the average prediction gain is higher. This only shows a correlation between source utilization and model performance; it does not prove that the gate can determine whether the source prediction is more accurate than the direct prediction for an individual sample. For example, some samples may be easier to predict and achieve higher performance regardless of source reliability.
-
Missing FORECasT-BE baseline: FORECasT-BE (Pallaseni et al., 2022) is a relevant method for predicting position-specific base-editing outcomes but is missing from the baseline comparison.
-
Potentially unfair CRISPRon-BE comparison: In Appendix G, auxiliary features such as CRISPRoff energy and Cas9 activity are set to zero, which may weaken the baseline's performance. Why adopt this setting?
-
Unclear source-prior generation protocol: Does the correction model use in-sample or out-of-fold predictions from the source predictor during training? Differences in source-prior quality between training and testing may lead to a distribution mismatch.
Dear Reviewer BSBC,
As the author–reviewer discussion period is nearing its end, we would be grateful if you could take a look at our rebuttal and revised manuscript when your schedule permits.
We would welcome any further questions or feedback and would be happy to continue the discussion. We understand that this is a busy period and sincerely appreciate your time and thoughtful consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors