acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Outer–Inner Layer Separation for Third-Order Mixed-Derivative PINNs with Bilinear Lagging

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Higher-order bilinear PDE residuals pose two coupled challenges for physics-informed neural networks (PINNs). First, high-order derivatives entangle parameters across layers. Second, nonlinear products typically destroy the least-squares structure that makes Layer Separation (LySep) computationally attractive. We introduce an outer–inner LySep framework that addresses both. At each outer step, one bilinear factor is frozen, yielding a linear variable-coefficient PDE. An inner third-order LySep solver then reconstructs mixed derivatives through order three using an auxiliary hierarchy \(a\!\to\!d\!\to\!q\!\to\!r\), while retaining a conditional least-squares output block. We establish exact auxiliary recovery and state-dependent residual consistency, and characterize the quartic obstruction that motivates outer lagging. Experiments span an intrinsically third-order forced KdV-type equation, hard-solenoidal Navier–Stokes, and resistive MHD. On KdV, the direct third-order route yields lower solution and original-PDE residual errors in all five paired seeds than both a matched low-order LySep route and a MIM-style first-order mixed-residual PINN, with median comparator-to-direct ratios of 1.95–2.97 for solution error and 2.47–3.61 for original-PDE residual. On hard-solenoidal Navier–Stokes, all five paired initializations give lower velocity, nonlinear-momentum, and pressure-gradient errors with LySep than with a matched end-to-end PINN. The MHD comparison likewise yields lower field and nonlinear-residual errors for LySep in all five pairs.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Physics-Informed Neural Networks;Outer-Inner Layer Separation;Bilinear Lagging;Third-Order Mixed Derivatives;Scientific Machine Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_wgBhOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The manuscript uses a variant of the Method of Auxiliary Coordinates [Carreira-Perpiñán & Wang, AISTATS 2014] to train PINNs. Here it is called Layer Separation. Previous work has already applied it to PINNs [Liu & Gu, J. Comput. Phys. 543:114414, 2025]. It extends that work to higher-order derivatives (previously only derivatives up to order two were considered) and to nonlinear PDEs via Picard iteration (successive linearization).

As such, the contribution is a standard combination of existing ideas, and quite a foreseeable one. Beyond this, the manuscript has significant weaknesses, the lead me to recommend rejection. The two core weaknesses are weak baselines, and the restricted applicability of the method, I give details below.

Critical strengths

I see no obvious mathematical errors in the computational tools used (like Picard iteration or the layer separation process).

Critical weaknesses

There are two critical weaknesses:

(i) The baselines are weak. I ran a plain Levenberg–Marquardt method on the authors' problems. I prompted Claude Opus 5.5 with reasoning on high to do it for me with the prompt: "Can you take the examples of this paper, use JAX in double precision and a kernel formulation (or parameter space formulation if more appropriate) of Levenberg Marquardt with constant damping and backtracking line search with Armijo and quickly run their experiments and give me the relative L2 error"

Claude used constant damping (10⁻⁵; 10⁻⁷ for Navier–Stokes) and Armijo backtracking, and was applied directly to the nonlinear residual without Picard linearization. The manufactured solutions, collocation points, architecture and hard constraints were the same as in the manuscript. It clearly outperforms the proposed method.

KdV (solution): 6.1·10⁻⁶ vs. 2.9·10⁻⁴ Navier–Stokes (velocity): 8.0·10⁻⁶ vs. 2.3·10⁻⁵ MHD (velocity): 1.2·10⁻⁵ vs. 1.7·10⁻⁴

This is in line with my own experience in training PINNs, and was definitely to be expected. It is by now well-established in the literature [ENGD, DeepMind, Karniadakis] that Gauss-Newton/natural gradient type methods perform exceptionally well for PINNs. Not comparing to this development in the literature is therefore unacceptable and the results above show that even without tuning, the proposed method is far less effective.

(ii) The applicability of the method is severely restricted. It requires a network with exactly two hidden layers, has only been demonstrated for small widths, and is outperformed on simple benchmarks. I do not see promise for the method in the areas where neural PDE solvers are most promising, mainly high-dimensional problems in quantum physics and quantum chemistry.

Minor weakness: The write-up is verbose and hard to follow. It shows clear signs of heavy LLM-use with little human editing.

Literature:

[ENGD] https://proceedings.mlr.press/v202/muller23b/muller23b.pdf

[DeepMind] https://arxiv.org/html/2509.14185v1

[Karniadakis] https://arxiv.org/pdf/2604.05230

Questions for authors

I have none.

Reviewer_jFetOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper extends layer separation (LySep) from second-order linear PDEs to PDEs involving third-order mixed derivatives and bilinear nonlinearities. The method introduces auxiliary states for third-order derivatives and freezes one factor of each bilinear term in the outer iteration. Combined with alternating block updates, this allows the output layer to remain solvable through least squares when the other variables are fixed. The authors evaluate the method on KdV, Navier–Stokes, and resistive magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) problems. Across five paired initializations, the method achieves lower errors than the selected baselines, but at substantially higher computational cost.

Critical strengths

The paper combines derivative auxiliary variables with an outer freezing strategy, providing targeted analysis and design tailored to third-order PDEs. The use of algebraic analysis to motivate and explain the method makes the presentation logically clear.

Experiments on multiple third-order PDE problems convincingly demonstrate that third-order layer separation can improve final accuracy when more computational resources are used.

Critical weaknesses

Limited methodological novelty. The method builds on second-order LySep, inheriting its independent hidden-layer auxiliary states, consistency penalties, and alternating block updates. The third-order derivative hierarchy follows further application of the chain rule, while bilinear nonlinearities are handled through an established outer Picard-type linearization strategy that freezes one factor of each bilinear term. I therefore find the core methodological novelty limited.

Restricted technical scope. The proposed formulation and analysis are restricted to MLPs with two hidden layers, derivatives up to third order, and the specified bilinear PDE operators. For a paper focused on extending an existing technique, the impact of an extension confined to this architectural and operator scope is limited. A unified framework accommodating broader network architectures and nonlinear differential operators would constitute a more substantial contribution.

The theoretical results provide weak guarantees for the actual training procedure and offer limited independent theoretical contributions. Theorem 1 primarily verifies the derivative recursion and the recovery property when the auxiliary states take their exact values. Theorem 2 provides a state-dependent consistency bound, but does not establish uniform control of its constant throughout training. Consequently, a small separated objective alone does not guarantee a small physical residual. Conditional output-layer quadraticity has computational value, but does not imply convergence of the full alternating optimization procedure or the outer iteration. Although the paper acknowledges these limitations, these results are better viewed as structural verification of the method than as substantial independent theoretical contributions.

Inconclusive experimental comparisons and inconsistent statistical reporting. The proposed method and the baselines use different computational budgets, with the proposed method incurring substantially higher costs. The authors should provide more comprehensive comparisons under matched computational budgets. Statistical reporting is also inconsistent across experiments: means and standard deviations are provided for Navier–Stokes in Table 7 and KdV in Table 13, whereas the MHD results include individual-seed values and medians without corresponding mean and standard-deviation summaries. Reporting mean ± SD alongside the existing results in the main tables would facilitate comparison of variability across methods. Furthermore, the Navier–Stokes formulation comparison in Table 2(a) uses only a single seed; this comparison should be repeated across multiple seeds, with the corresponding aggregate statistics reported.

Questions for authors

See weakness

Reviewer_iP3cOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper extends the Layer Separation (LySep) method of Liu and Gu (2025) to PDEs involving third-order mixed derivatives and bilinear nonlinearities. LySep treats layer preactivations and their derivatives as independent auxiliary variables, reconstructs network-output derivatives through explicit chain-rule expressions, and penalizes discrepancies between the auxiliaries and their corresponding network quantities. For a linear PDE, fixing the hidden-layer parameters and auxiliaries leaves a least-squares problem for the output weights.

The proposed method adds third-order derivative auxiliaries and introduces an outer Picard/Oseen iteration that freezes one factor in each bilinear term. Each resulting linear PDE is solved using an inner LySep iteration, preserving the least-squares output update. The theoretical results establish exact recovery when the auxiliaries match their chain-rule values, a state-dependent residual-consistency bound, and conditions under which the output subproblem remains quadratic. The paper also identifies a harmonic-compensation failure mode in mixed streamfunction–Laplacian formulations.

Experiments consider manufactured solutions for a forced KdV-type equation, hard-solenoidal Navier–Stokes, and resistive MHD. The proposed method achieves lower errors than the selected comparators across five paired seeds, although the reported wall-clock cost is roughly an order of magnitude higher. The experiments establish accuracy improvements within the tested configurations, while leaving questions about computational efficiency, scalability, and performance in more demanding physical regimes.

Critical strengths
  1. Detailed construction and transparent reporting. The derivative recursions, mismatch penalties, and adaptive weights are explicitly documented, together with implementation checks for exact recovery and output stationarity. The authors acknowledge the runtime overhead, the limitations of the state-dependent bounds, and the non-monotone behavior of the outer iteration. This transparency helps establish what the method achieves within the reported experimental protocol.

  2. A useful analysis of mixed-formulation failure. The harmonic-compensation analysis explains how errors in an independently represented Laplacian field can be offset by pressure corrections, while an L2 compatibility penalty fails to control the relevant derivatives. This provides an informative diagnosis that may be useful beyond LySep.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological advance and theoretical guarantees are limited. The principal contributions combine a higher-order extension of the LySep derivative construction with standard Picard/Oseen linearization. The distinction from related approaches, particularly SP-RaNN, needs to be established more convincingly. The theory provides exact recovery and state-dependent consistency, but does not establish convergence of the inner alternating scheme or the complete outer–inner procedure. The contraction assumptions are not verified for the experimental problems, and the reported KdV history includes noncontractive steps. Furthermore, the construction focuses on two-hidden-layer networks, with limited evidence about extension to deeper architectures or the growth of auxiliary storage and computational cost.

  2. The experimental evidence does not establish an advantage at comparable computational cost or in challenging regimes. The benchmarks use smooth manufactured solutions over short time horizons, with relatively modest nonlinear contributions. The reported accuracy gains come at approximately 10× the runtime of the end-to-end PINN comparator, without equal-wall-clock comparisons or evaluation against SP-RaNN and stronger PINN training methods. The reduced-order KdV comparator does not reach the outer tolerance in any of the five seeds under the common iteration cap, so incomplete convergence may explain part of the observed gap. The five-seed evaluation offers useful descriptive evidence but limited uncertainty quantification. Finally, the scalar potential residual reported for MHD does not by itself establish control of the vector induction residual.

Overall, I recommend weak rejection. The paper presents a carefully documented extension of LySep and a useful analysis of a mixed-formulation failure mode. However, the methodological advance appears incremental, the theoretical results do not establish convergence of the full algorithm, and the experiments do not demonstrate an accuracy–cost advantage against sufficiently competitive baselines. Compute-matched comparisons, stronger baselines, and evidence in a more demanding physical regime could materially change my assessment.

Questions for authors

Clarifications and evidence that could materially affect my assessment:

  1. Does the accuracy ordering persist under equal wall-clock budgets, for example with a larger end-to-end PINN budget or fewer LySep sweeps? How much of the runtime gap is implementation-dependent, and is a vectorized or GPU implementation available?

  2. Can you compare against SP-RaNN, or explain precisely what prevents a meaningful comparison? Such a comparison would help isolate the benefit of training the hidden layers within the proposed scheme.

  3. For KdV, does the comparison change if the reduced-order LySep route is run to the same outer convergence tolerance? Can you clarify the seed-1 continuation and whether all seeds were rerun under the final protocol?

  4. What prevents extension beyond two hidden layers, and how do auxiliary memory and computation scale with collocation count, width, depth, dimension, and derivative order?

  5. What evidence supports robustness of the outer iteration at larger amplitudes or smaller dispersion? Have you examined Newton linearization, which can also preserve linearity in the new state, or regimes with stronger nonlinear dynamics?

  6. Can you report the vector induction residual for MHD, or give a bound connecting it to the reported scalar potential residual?

  7. Is the mixed-formulation limitation specific to enforcing the streamfunction–Laplacian relation with an L2 penalty, or does it persist when the kinematic relation is enforced through the operator?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.