acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

POD-RoPE: Rotary Position Encoding over Physical Observation Distributions for Embodied AI

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Embodied perception requires positional representations that capture both physical geometry and the spatial and temporal extent of observations. We introduce POD-RoPE (Physical Observation Distribution RoPE), which represents token observation footprints as distributions over camera centers, viewing directions, and sampling times. Under independent sampling, expected rotations encode relative relationships between distributions; when each distribution collapses to a single address, the construction recovers pointwise RoPE. The same rotation statistics support Q/K matching and coherence-dependent V/O transformations, allowing observation geometry to guide both information selection and content aggregation. Per-token pre-aggregation avoids increasing sequence length or processing pairs of observation nodes. We evaluate POD-RoPE across four robot policy architectures, simulation and real-world manipulation, and complementary reconstruction, depth-estimation, and novel-view-synthesis tasks. On two real-robot tasks, POD-RoPE raises mean success from 32.5% to 52.5%, while controlled reconstruction ablations support the contributions of distribution encoding and V/O transformations. In H20 model-block benchmarks, POD-RoPE achieves median forward-plus-backward speedups of 1.91× over P-RoPE and 5.34× over RayRoPE, with a median latency overhead of 17.4% over Standard RoPE. These results support physical observation distributions as an effective and computationally efficient basis for geometry-aware attention.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
rotary position encoding, physical observation distributions, embodied AI, robot manipulation, multi-view geometry

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_q8toOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes POD-RoPE, a rotary position encoding for embodied AI that models each token's spatial and temporal footprint as a distribution over camera centers, viewing directions, and timestamps.

It computes the expected rotation matrix over quadrature nodes within each token's pixel patch and temporal stride, and applies these statistics to Q/K attention as well as V/O transformations via a coherence-weighted identity branch.

Evaluated across four robot policies (Fast-WAM, pi0, RDT, ACT), two real-robot tasks, and three 3D vision benchmarks, POD-RoPE improves over standard RoPE and runs 1.9x to 5.3x faster than P-RoPE and RayRoPE.

Critical strengths
  1. Practical adaptation and low latency. Working in a shared robot-root frame and pre-aggregating cosine/sine statistics over 2D patch and video VAE footprints avoids per-query-view re-projection and depth prediction. It adds only 17.4% latency over Standard RoPE while running 1.91x and 5.34x faster than P-RoPE and RayRoPE.
  2. Coherence-gated V/O identity branch. Mixing the expected rotation with an identity matrix is a clean fix for feature norm shrinkage when averaging rotations.
  3. Broad empirical evaluation. The paper tests the method across 50 simulated RoboTwin 2.0 tasks, two real-world bimanual manipulation tasks, view/temporal reconstruction, depth estimation, and novel-view synthesis.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Incremental technical novelty over RayRoPE and Mip-NeRF. The paper's core theoretical claims were already introduced in RayRoPE. Similarly, integrating positional encodings over pixel footprints comes from Mip-NeRF, applying RoPE to global (o,d)(o, d) rays was already tested as the "RoPE on rays" baseline in RayRoPE, and V/O rotation comes from GTA/P-RoPE/RayRoPE. POD-RoPE mainly swaps RayRoPE's 1D depth-uncertainty interval for a 2D-patch + time footprint in global coordinates and adds the V/O branch, making the methodological contribution much more incremental than presented.

  2. Speedup comes from trading away SE(3) rotation invariance and depth adaptiveness. P-RoPE and RayRoPE are slower because they project coordinates into each query camera's frame to guarantee full SE(3) invariance. POD-RoPE is faster largely because it encodes (o,d)(o, d) in a fixed global/robot-root frame, which is only translation-invariant, not rotation-invariant.

Questions for authors

Q1. Policy baselines: In Tables 1–3, how does POD-RoPE compare against Pointwise Physical RoPE (single ray per token), so we know the distribution footprint itself helps control?

Q2 RoboTwin reconstruction discrepancy: Why does POD-RoPE beat P-RoPE on RoboTwin in Table 4 (+0.84 dB), but lose to P-RoPE using the same checkpoint in Table 11 (-0.59 dB)?

Q3 V/O ablation: In Table 6, does the proposed V/O operator (1−ρ)I+R(1-\rho)I + R outperform simply normalizing the rotation to unit length (R/ρR/\rho)?

Reviewer_XajUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes POD-RoPE, a geometry-aware positional encoding method for embodied AI. It represents the observation footprint of each token as a distribution over camera centers, viewing directions, and sampling times. Expected rotations are used to encode relative positional relationships in Q/K attention. The method also introduces coherence-dependent V/O transformations to guide content aggregation. The authors evaluate POD-RoPE across four robot policy architectures, real-world manipulation tasks, image reconstruction, depth estimation, and novel-view synthesis. The results show improvements in several settings, while model-block benchmarks demonstrate lower computational costs than P-RoPE and RayRoPE.

Critical strengths
  1. POD-RoPE provides a mathematically motivated extension of rotary positional encoding. By representing token observation footprints as distributions over physical addresses, it incorporates spatial and temporal information that point-based encodings may overlook. The expected-rotation formulation preserves the relative-position identity under independent sampling, while per-token pre-aggregation avoids explicit pairwise processing of observation nodes. This offers a useful approach to geometry-aware attention with manageable computational overhead.
  2. The paper evaluates POD-RoPE across multiple model architectures and tasks, including robot manipulation, image reconstruction, depth estimation, and novel-view synthesis. The component ablations on reconstruction provide evidence for the benefits of distribution encoding and V/O transformations. The efficiency benchmarks also show clear advantages over P-RoPE and RayRoPE. These experiments provide a useful assessment of the method's potential and its performance trade-offs across different settings.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution of POD-RoPE to robot manipulation performance is not sufficiently isolated. All robot policies use the full Q/K+V/O integration, while component ablations are limited to image reconstruction. In addition, the simulated Fast-WAM and RDT integrations introduce extra trainable residual attention modules. Without robot-task ablations and parameter-matched baselines that retain these modules but use Standard RoPE, it remains difficult to attribute the reported gains specifically to the proposed method.
  2. The statistical reliability of the reported robot manipulation improvements remains uncertain. Table 3 reports only 20 trials per task and provides no confidence intervals. The gains in Table 1 are also modest, at 1.24 and 0.86 percentage points under Clean and Randomized conditions, respectively. The manuscript does not report repeated-run results or uncertainty estimates for these comparisons. Further evidence is needed to determine whether the improvements are consistent across training runs and evaluation conditions.
Questions for authors

1.Since the averaged rotation matrix is generally non-orthogonal, POD-RoPE changes the magnitudes of Query and Key features. Could the authors investigate whether the improvement comes from the encoded observation distributions or from the resulting magnitude modulation? A comparison with a phase-only rotation variant would help clarify this issue. 2.Could the authors provide component ablations on robot manipulation tasks to evaluate Q/K-only and Q/K+V/O integrations separately? It would also be useful to examine the contributions of the vision and action branches in Fast-WAM. The current reconstruction ablations do not establish whether these components contribute similarly to closed-loop control. 3.For the simulated Fast-WAM and RDT experiments, could the authors compare POD-RoPE against a parameter-matched baseline that retains the additional residual attention modules but uses Standard RoPE? This comparison is necessary to distinguish the effect of positional encoding from that of the additional network structure. 4.Could the authors provide statistical uncertainty estimates for the robot manipulation results, particularly the real-robot experiments in Table 3? Were the experiments repeated with different training seeds? Such information would help assess whether the reported improvements are consistent across training runs and evaluation conditions. 5.The V/O transformations in Eq. (9) and Eq. (10) introduce dependence on absolute observation addresses. Although this property is acknowledged in Appendix A.3, its practical impact remains unclear. Could the authors evaluate whether changing the coordinate reference frame affects model predictions or performance?

Reviewer_jiNAOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces POD-RoPE (Physical Observation Distribution RoPE), which represents token observation footprints as distributions over camera centers, viewing directions, and sampling times. Under independent sampling, expected rotations encode relative relationships between distributions; when each distribution collapses to a single address, the construction recovers pointwise RoPE. The same rotation statistics support Q/K matching and coherence-dependent V/O transformations, allowing observation geometry to guide both information selection and content aggregation. Per-token pre-aggregation avoids increasing sequence length or processing pairs of observation nodes. This paper evaluates POD-RoPE across four robot policy architectures, simulation and real-world manipulation, and complementary reconstruction, depth-estimation, and novel-view-synthesis tasks. On two real-robot tasks, POD-RoPE raises mean success from 32.5% to 52.5%, while controlled reconstruction ablations support the contributions of distribution encoding and V/O transformations. In H20 model-block benchmarks, POD-RoPE achieves median forward-plus-backward speedups of 1.91× over P-RoPE and 5.34× over RayRoPE, with a median latency overhead of 17.4% over Standard RoPE. These results support physical observation distributions as an effective and computationally efficient basis for geometry-aware attention.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. As shown in Table 1, the proposed method achieves only marginal improvements over Fast-WAM. Considering the potential variability caused by random seeds, stochastic training procedures, and evaluation conditions, the observed performance gains may not be sufficiently significant to establish the clear superiority of the proposed approach. The authors should conduct experiments with multiple random seeds and report the mean and standard deviation of the results. Where appropriate, statistical significance tests should also be provided to determine whether the observed improvements are statistically meaningful. Without such evidence, it remains unclear whether the proposed method offers a consistent and substantial advantage over Fast-WAM.

  2. The baseline methods included in Table 2 were published in 2025, and the manuscript does not provide comparisons with more recent approaches published in 2026. Given the rapid development of this research area, evaluating the proposed method against relatively outdated baselines is insufficient to establish its competitiveness with the current state of the art. The authors should incorporate relevant SOTA methods published in 2026 and conduct comprehensive comparisons under consistent experimental settings. Such evaluations are essential for determining whether the proposed approach provides meaningful improvements over existing methods and for better positioning its contributions within the latest research landscape.

  3. The manuscript does not provide sufficient qualitative visualizations to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method on visual geometry tasks. In particular, visual comparisons are missing for several important tasks, including cross-view reconstruction, temporal extrapolation, depth estimation, and novel-view synthesis. Quantitative metrics alone may not adequately reveal the differences in geometric consistency, structural fidelity, temporal coherence, and visual quality between the proposed method and competing approaches. The authors should provide representative visual results alongside those of strong baseline methods, ideally using the same input conditions and evaluation settings. These comparisons would help readers assess the actual quality of the generated or reconstructed results, identify potential failure cases, and better understand the practical advantages and limitations of the proposed method.

  4. The manuscript does not provide visual demonstrations of the robot's execution results, making it difficult to assess the practical effectiveness and reliability of the proposed approach in robotic applications. For a method intended to support robot execution, quantitative metrics alone are insufficient to fully evaluate whether the generated actions are physically feasible, accurately executed, and robust to variations in the environment. The authors should provide representative video demonstrations or other visual results showing the robot performing relevant tasks, preferably including comparisons with baseline methods. These demonstrations should illustrate the complete execution process and highlight important aspects such as task completion, motion smoothness, precision, and robustness. Failure cases should also be included where appropriate. Without such qualitative evidence, it is difficult to determine whether the reported quantitative performance translates into meaningful improvements in real-world or simulated robotic execution.

Questions for authors
  1. As shown in Table 1, the proposed method achieves only marginal improvements over Fast-WAM. Considering the potential variability caused by random seeds, stochastic training procedures, and evaluation conditions, the observed performance gains may not be sufficiently significant to establish the clear superiority of the proposed approach. The authors should conduct experiments with multiple random seeds and report the mean and standard deviation of the results. Where appropriate, statistical significance tests should also be provided to determine whether the observed improvements are statistically meaningful. Without such evidence, it remains unclear whether the proposed method offers a consistent and substantial advantage over Fast-WAM.

  2. The baseline methods included in Table 2 were published in 2025, and the manuscript does not provide comparisons with more recent approaches published in 2026. Given the rapid development of this research area, evaluating the proposed method against relatively outdated baselines is insufficient to establish its competitiveness with the current state of the art. The authors should incorporate relevant SOTA methods published in 2026 and conduct comprehensive comparisons under consistent experimental settings. Such evaluations are essential for determining whether the proposed approach provides meaningful improvements over existing methods and for better positioning its contributions within the latest research landscape.

  3. The manuscript does not provide sufficient qualitative visualizations to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method on visual geometry tasks. In particular, visual comparisons are missing for several important tasks, including cross-view reconstruction, temporal extrapolation, depth estimation, and novel-view synthesis. Quantitative metrics alone may not adequately reveal the differences in geometric consistency, structural fidelity, temporal coherence, and visual quality between the proposed method and competing approaches. The authors should provide representative visual results alongside those of strong baseline methods, ideally using the same input conditions and evaluation settings. These comparisons would help readers assess the actual quality of the generated or reconstructed results, identify potential failure cases, and better understand the practical advantages and limitations of the proposed method.

  4. The manuscript does not provide visual demonstrations of the robot's execution results, making it difficult to assess the practical effectiveness and reliability of the proposed approach in robotic applications. For a method intended to support robot execution, quantitative metrics alone are insufficient to fully evaluate whether the generated actions are physically feasible, accurately executed, and robust to variations in the environment. The authors should provide representative video demonstrations or other visual results showing the robot performing relevant tasks, preferably including comparisons with baseline methods. These demonstrations should illustrate the complete execution process and highlight important aspects such as task completion, motion smoothness, precision, and robustness. Failure cases should also be included where appropriate. Without such qualitative evidence, it is difficult to determine whether the reported quantitative performance translates into meaningful improvements in real-world or simulated robotic execution.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.