acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Measuring the Marginal Utility of Skills at the Execution State

Abstract

Skill libraries package procedural knowledge for agents, but retrieval ranks relevance rather than testing execution. We define the marginal utility of a fixed package-plus-announcement protocol at execution state as its change in expected verified reward. At each checkpoint we replay one realised prefix, apply a protocol arm, independently continue it, and compare verifier rewards. Across 22 screened realised states from eleven SkillsBench tasks under one model and agent (516 runs), the health-gated own-package contrast was +0.147. Conditional on these fixed states, a runs-only 95% interval was [+0.082, +0.213] and within-state randomization gave ; an 11-cluster interval crossed zero [-0.020, +0.315] (), making cross-task mean inference method-sensitive. Utility did not separate checkpoint rules, but uptake differed by +39.9 points between first-write-rule and three-fifths checkpoints; two no-write fallbacks and one reversed pair limit that label. Only two tasks had a foreign top-1. The contribution is a signed, state-conditioned protocol and auditable finite-sample map, not a router.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, tool-using agents, procedural skills, skill routing, agent evaluation, counterfactual evaluation, execution-time intervention, benchmarks

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_p4zUOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the research problem of how to measure the marginal utility of LLM agent skills. The marginal utility of a skill is defined as a fixed package plus announcement protocol as it changes the expected verifier reward. At each checkpoint the paper replays one realised prefix, apply a protocol arm, independently continue it, and compare verifier rewards. Across 22 screened realised states from eleven SkillsBench tasks under one model and agent, the experiments show the calculated marginal utility score.

Critical strengths
  1. The marginal utility of a specific LLM agent skill seems interesting.
  2. The research reports comprehensive related works.
  3. The paper reports comprehensive experimental details.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The method used to measure such marginal utility is rather simple and follows the standard definition of marginal utility. It is unknown if this kind of simple empiricial study consistitues significant research progress that meets the publication standard at premier machine learning conferences. It may be more suitable for a workshop paper, rather than a conference paper.
  2. While the research topic is interesting, what this paper essentially does is to apply marginial utility measurements to LLM agent skills. The experiments simply report the calculated scores, without significant or insightful observations that can be helpful for LLM agent skill community.
  3. The experimental settings are not diverse enough using only one model and one benchmark.
  4. Uncertainty and flucation across different experiment runs and settings are not sufficiently regulated or measured. This brings concerns on the rebliability of the calculation method.
  5. The reliablity of the verifier is not sufficiently validated. Since the score is dependent on the quality of the verifier, this also brings concerns on the rebliability of the calculation method.
Questions for authors
  1. The paper essentially applies standard marginal utility measurements to LLM agent skills. Could the authors clarify what constitutes the significant research progress beyond this application?
  2. Given that the method follows the standard definition of marginal utility and the study is relatively simple empirically, could the authors explain why they believe this work meets the publication standard of a premier machine learning conference, rather than being more suitable for a workshop paper?
  3. The experiments use only one model and one benchmark. Could the authors explain whether this limited setting is sufficient to support the paper's claims?
  4. The paper does not sufficiently regulate or measure uncertainty and fluctuation across different experiment runs and settings. How do the authors address the resulting concerns about the reliability of the calculation method? Could they provide variance estimates or confidence intervals across multiple runs?
  5. How do the authors validate the verifier's reliability? How sensitive are the marginal utility scores to verifier errors or biases?
  6. How could the authors assure that the proposed calculation method produces reliable and reproducible results? What additional experiments or analyses could be provided to verify its reliability?
Reviewer_RckaOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

“Measuring the Marginal Utility of Skills at the Execution State” defines a skill’s utility as the change in expected verifier reward caused by making its package available under a fixed announcement protocol. The experiment records a baseline trajectory, reconstructs selected checkpoints in fresh sandboxes, and independently continues several intervention arms: no injection, the task’s own packages, unrelated packages, and BM25’s top-ranked package.

Critical strengths

The estimand is explicit and operationally meaningful. Comparing a package intervention against no injection permits benefits and harms to be measured on the same reward scale. The paper correctly defines the treatment as the entire package-plus-announcement protocol, rather than claiming to isolate procedural content.

The fork design controls the realized execution prefix. Arms within a state share a byte-checked prefix, model, environment, and clocks. Independent continuations estimate sampling variation after that checkpoint without pretending to measure variation over alternative baseline trajectories. This distinction is important and clearly communicated.

The paper documents operational failures and exclusions. Verifier execution is checked directly, unhealthy runs remain in the manifest, and the sole timeout receives explicit sensitivity analysis.

Critical weaknesses

The methodological contribution is limited relative to the unresolved empirical questions.

Adaptive screening restricts inference, and the screening rationale is partly incorrect. Tasks entered after earlier rounds were analyzed; the binary-task admission rule was added later; one task received additional repetitions after its initial results were examined; and the final screening decision file was reconstructed rather than archived. These choices can support an exploratory finite-state map, but do not support ordinary task-population inference or automatically justify nominal fixed-sample intervals after sequential extension. A prospectively locked confirmation set would be valuable.

Replay fidelity and execution reproducibility need stronger validation. Missing temperature, top-p, output-token limits, immutable image identifiers, and historical agent artifacts further limit execution reproducibility. The manifest may reproduce numerical aggregation while still being insufficient to reproduce the underlying intervention experiment.

Questions for authors

Does the pooled own-package result remain convincing under leave-one-task-out analysis and on a prospectively selected confirmation set?

Can repeated baseline trajectories establish reward-based state dependence?

Reviewer_r3MWOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
1
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper estimated the marginal utility of skills (reusable procedural instructions for agents) for 11 SkillsBench tasks, and reported exploratory results. However, the paper did not seem to present clear conclusions or findings from these results.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. The writing is hard to follow.

  2. The motivation and contributions are unclear. The paper measures the marginal utility skills for 11 out of 87 SkillsBench tasks, but motivation for doing so over other protocols, such as in SkillRouter or the original SkillsBench paper, seems unclear.

In the related work (Page 2, Line 101/102), the paper writes:

"SkillRouter is the closest prior work and we do not claim its position: it retrieves and reranks over roughly 80K skills and evaluates end to end on 75 SkillsBench-derived tasks, ..."

Then this paper mentions its own position on P3 L131/132:

"Position. What we claim is the conjunction: skill utility measured rather than predicted, at the execution state where the skill would be consumed rather than at the query, for procedural knowledge whose failure mode is a misleading process rather than a wrong fact. "

  1. The paper mentions its other contribution being a map that "supplies labels for future routing", but also mentions that it is "not a router," which seems confusing. The purpose and significance of this map seem unclear.

  2. Sections 3 and 4 provide methodology details and experiment protocol, respectively, but do not provide clear rationale behind them. For example, on Page 7, L342/343:

"The screen forks one recording per task, so it is a coarse instrument: a task can pass or fail it on the luck of one rollout, and a task that fails it is not shown to be uninformative, only not shown to be informative."

  1. Section 5 reports the output statistics, but do not provide meaningful discussions or clear conclusions. For example, on Page 8, L407/408:

"At six to nine repeats per cell an interval that straddles zero is what a real effect of a few tenths of a point looks like as much as it is what no effect looks like; the sign pattern across cells, not any single cell, is what this experiment can support."

Questions for authors

None

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.