- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents RNACLIP, a framework for RNA-ligand virtual screening. In order to solve the problem of data scarcity, the authors used protein-ligand data to enrich the datasets. The model utilized shared intellifold embedders as pretrained encoders. The authors used ablation studies to prove that additional data helped performance. However, the baseline methods evaluated in experiments are limited, more confidence scores (Ipae, Ipsae et.al) from Alphafold3 / Boltz2 / Protenix2 should be included.
Critical strengths
- RNACLIP outperforms other evaluated baseline methods by a large margine
- This paper proves that using additional protein-ligand could further improve RNA-ligand screening performance
Critical weaknesses
- Notations and equations are hard to follow, especially the definition of m_i
- Popular interface screening scores from folding models like IPAE, IPSAE are missing from the comparison.
- The model is evaluated on self-curated eval sets. It also makes sense to compare with other baseline methods on some common benchmark sets.
Questions for authors
- It is quite confusing that pair-shuffled perform nearly as good as the reference. How is the model doing a great job without being confused by wrong ligand-protein pairs.
- How are other methods’ training data different from your model? Any chance they are just undertrained?
- Why is it still necessary to include protein-ligand datasets as additional training source since the pretrained encoder already sees them?
- Does training on RNA-ligand also help improve protein-ligand screening?