Lack of clarity on practical applications: The paper would benefit from a more detailed discussion of how the proposed framework can be applied in practice. In particular, the authors should provide concrete examples of scenarios where identifying task-relevant factors separately offers advantages over conventional predictive representations.
Insufficient distinction from prior work: The motivating framework and learning paradigm substantially overlap with prior work, particularly C-disentanglement (https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17325), although the theoretical results appear distinct. C-disentanglement already addresses latent non-identifiability, introduces observed labels as inductive information, and develops a conditional VAE-based framework for disentangled representation learning. The authors should clarify how TCI differs from this framework and, more importantly, what new mathematical or algorithmic capabilities it provides. Specifically, what would happen if the confounding label (C) in C-disentanglement were replaced with TCI's environment variable (U) and task response (Y)? What identifiability guarantees or capabilities would TCI provide beyond those already formulated within weakly supervised conditional disentanglement? A more rigorous comparison is necessary to establish the novelty of the proposed framework.
Limited experimental evaluation: The experimental design is insufficient to demonstrate the practical value and effectiveness of the proposed framework.
-
Lack of realistic benchmarks and downstream applications: The paper does not evaluate the method on real-world datasets, image benchmarks, or natural downstream tasks. Consequently, it is difficult to assess whether the theoretical advantages translate into meaningful practical improvements or identify scenarios where the proposed method would be useful.
-
Outdated and incomplete baseline comparisons: The experimental evaluation primarily compares against relatively old baseline methods, without including more recent identifiable representation learning or disentanglement approaches from 2025–2026. Although the related work section cites several more recent studies, these methods are not included in the experimental comparisons. The authors should explain these omissions and provide comparisons with more competitive baselines to better establish the advantages of the proposed approach.