acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SCOPE: Memory Conflict as a Question-Time Relation

Abstract

Conversational memory accumulates statements that revise, qualify, or contradict earlier ones. Which statement matters depends on a question that may not yet have been asked. Resolving conflicts when memory is written can discard a distinction a later question needs. We ask what memory should decide before that question arrives. Keeping the dialogue preserves these distinctions, but a bounded reader still needs to find and select the evidence relevant to each question. We introduce SCOPE (Slot-indexed Conversational Organization for Provenance-linked Evidence), which groups extracted statements by subject and attribute while retaining links to their original dialogue. At query time, these groups guide access to source turns for an answering model to interpret. On MemConflict, a benchmark of questions over conflicting conversations, SCOPE answers more accurately overall and on questions about change over time than lexical retrieval with the same evidence selection and answering steps. It also exceeds the evaluated memory systems in overall accuracy; both results hold under a second LLM judge. These findings support separating memory organization from question-dependent interpretation of competing evidence.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Conversational memory, Memory conflict, LLM agents, Evidence selection, Question answering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_emvpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(−1)
Confidence
1
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper propose a simple yet effective method for memory conflct issues. To be specific, the authors introduce slot-indexed conversational organization for provenance-linked evidence, i.e., SCOPE, which groups extracted statements by subject and attribute while retaining links to their original dialogue. At query time, these groups guide access to source turns for an answering model to interpret. SCOPE also outperforms othe baselines on MemConflict and MemoryAgentBench.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper is well strcutured.
  2. Simple yet effective method with good performance and analysis.
Critical weaknesses

The cost-quality trade-off and robustness analysis is not discussed.

Questions for authors

Refer to weakness section

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer emvp

Thank you for the review. We have added the cost–quality and robustness analysis you asked for.

Cost–quality (query input per question, Appendix H.2):

ConfigurationPooled AAQuery input
SCOPE52.5054,191
Same pipeline, lexical access (no-slot)47.9213,721
Full history53.61205,714

Against the no-slot pipeline, SCOPE gains +5.83 [0.21, 11.67] dynamic points on the 360-question sample at 3.95× the input, and +8.03 [5.31, 10.61] on all 3,750 questions. Reading the full history uses 3.8× SCOPE's input with no detectable gain (+1.11 [−3.06, 5.42]). With the catalog bounded to 64k bytes, SCOPE reaches 60.42% at 22.6k tokens, within +1.25 [−2.08, 4.72] of a lexical pool that uses more than twice the input (Appendix H.3). Mem0 and MemOS make more LLM calls than SCOPE and score 18.7 and 17.6 points lower pooled (Appendix H).

Robustness :

CheckResult
Second backbone (gpt-6-luna), all 3,750 questions (F.12)SCOPE − no-slot +11.79 [10.31, 13.24] pooled, +15.60 [13.89, 17.32] dynamic
Grouped − occurrence-level access (F.11)+4.58 [0.83, 8.54] dynamic; +3.75 [0.63, 6.88] second backbone
Shuffled − chronological ingestion (F.14)+0.42 [−2.08, 2.92] pooled; +1.94 [−0.69, 4.58] second backbone
Latest-only index − SCOPE (G.3), all 804 static + conditional−10.83 [−14.17, −7.92] static, −8.11 [−10.89, −5.31] conditional

The access gain holds on a second backbone, grouping helps on both backbones, ingestion order has no detectable effect, and removing superseded statements at write time costs static and conditional accuracy.

Setup. All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF. Unless stated otherwise, new experiments use the 360 questions of Sections 5.2–5.3, and numbers in brackets are 95% confidence intervals from a paired persona bootstrap. New runs use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash under a provider system identifier that changed after submission, so we compare them only with each other. The second backbone is OpenAI gpt-6-luna.

Reviewer_HWwqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates conflict handling in long-term conversational memory. The authors argue that conflicts between memories and their applicability often depend on the specific query, and that prematurely overwriting or deleting old memories may discard information needed for future question answering. To address this issue, the paper proposes SCOPE, which organizes facts extracted from conversations into subject–attribute Slots while preserving different values and their original sources. At query time, the system first identifies relevant Slots, retrieves the corresponding original conversations, and then uses an LLM to select evidence and generate answers. Experimental results show that SCOPE outperforms the compared memory systems on MemConflict, with particularly noticeable improvements on dynamic memory questions.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a practically important problem. Separating memory organization from query-dependent conflict resolution is a reasonable design choice.
  2. The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive. In addition to comparisons with existing memory systems, the authors conduct a No-slot ablation study and validate the results using a second evaluation model, which strengthens the credibility of the findings.
  3. The paper examines the effects of different evidence retention strategies and reports empty retrieval cases and performance drops on certain tasks, providing a more complete picture of the method's behavior.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main idea behind SCOPE is to preserve historical statements with their source information and decide which evidence to use at query time. However, prior work such as StateFuse has also explored preserving conflicting information and deferring conflict resolution. SCOPE mainly organizes memories using subject–attribute Slots and combines this structure with LLM-based retrieval and evidence selection, making the overall approach appear more like a combination of existing techniques. The paper also lacks direct experimental comparisons with these closely related methods, making it difficult to assess the novelty and contribution of its core design.
  2. The current ablation study does not sufficiently isolate the contribution of Slot grouping. Although the No-slot ablation shows a noticeable performance difference, it changes both query mapping and source retrieval, making it unclear whether the improvement comes from Slot grouping itself or from structured indexing and source tracing more generally. The paper reports that 88.42% of Slots contain only one record, which further raises questions about the actual contribution of grouping conflicting statements into the same Slot. A more informative baseline would retain independent fact indexing and the same downstream processing pipeline without grouping facts into Slots.
  3. The computational cost is relatively high. According to Table 22 in the appendix, SCOPE requires approximately 61K input tokens per question on average, compared with only about 5.9K for BM25. Since the Slot Catalog may also grow with conversation history, the scalability of the approach is a concern. The paper lacks comparisons under similar computational budgets, making it difficult to determine whether the accuracy improvements justify the additional overhead.
  4. Failure to map queries to any Slot is a major failure mode of the method, but the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of why these failures occur. Specifically, SCOPE fails to map 623 out of 3,750 questions to any Slot, preventing the system from retrieving the evidence needed to answer them. Although a BM25 fallback can alleviate this issue, it is not part of the original method, and the authors should provide a more thorough analysis of the causes of these mapping failures. Furthermore, the experiments are primarily based on synthetic conversations, and multi-hop accuracy on MemoryAgentBench remains relatively low. The effectiveness of the approach in more complex scenarios is therefore still unclear.
Questions for authors

n/a

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer HWwq

Thank you for the review, and for proposing the baseline that most directly tests our design; we ran it (W2).

SCOPE targets one problem: stored statements that compete for the same subject and attribute, where the valid one depends on a later question. On it, the general-purpose systems Mem0, MemOS, LangMem and Letta reach 32.73–37.17% pooled, against SCOPE's 52.07% (Table 1).

W1 — StateFuse precedent; looks like a combination; no comparison. StateFuse defers a decision over claims: it builds conflict sets and gives the answering model selected claims or an unresolved conflict. SCOPE makes no such decision in memory. It only groups extracted statements by subject and attribute so that a question can reach them, keeps each one linked to its source turn, and leaves validity to a reader that sees that turn at question time (Section 6; Appendix I). We test each decision with the rest of the pipeline fixed: keeping superseded entries (Appendix G.3), grouping (W2 below), and reader input (Appendix F.9). Reader input bears directly on StateFuse: a reader given extracted fields, the form closest to its claims, scores 5.97 points [2.78, 9.31] lower pooled than one given source quotes, which are also shorter (707 vs 1,098 bytes).

StateFuse cannot be run on MemConflict as released: it takes structured claims, and the benchmark supplies dialogue with no claim front end. If we wrote that front end, the result would test our extraction rather than StateFuse (Appendix I).

W2 — No-slot changes mapping and retrieval; 88.42% singletons; need an independent-fact baseline. The 88.42% is per group; per question, 2,336 of 3,750 map to a group with more than one occurrence. We ran the baseline you proposed (Appendix F.11): one catalog entry per extracted fact (an occurrence in our terms), each linked to its own source session; downstream stages and the selection cap of 3 are unchanged.

Grouped − occurrence-levelDynamicPooled
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash+4.58 [0.83, 8.54]+3.61 [0.97, 6.53]
gpt-6-luna+3.75 [0.63, 6.88]+2.78 [−0.14, 5.83]
Occurrence cap raised to 6 (occurrence − grouped)−3.96 [−8.54, 0.63]−2.50 [−5.83, 0.83]

Under the same cap, a group entry reaches more source sessions (3.4 vs 1.7 per dynamic question) with less query input (53,762 vs 59,901 tokens). Doubling the occurrence cap raises input to 63,285 tokens without reaching grouped access.

W3 — ~61K input tokens vs 5.9K for BM25; no budget-matched comparison. In the submitted runs, the 61,014 figure includes amortized ingestion; query input alone is 51,823 tokens per question. On the sample, about 81% of SCOPE's query input is the catalog and prompt shown to the mapper, a prefix repeated across questions. Mem0 and MemOS use under 300 query tokens but make more LLM calls (24,019 and 21,356 vs 14,383); their low input reflects question-time work they do not do. Among pipelines that do resolve conflicts, the accuracy–input frontier (Appendix H.3):

ConfigurationQuery input per questionPooled AA
No-slot BM25, 96k / 192k pool25.5k / 50.5k54.44 / 59.17
SCOPE, full catalog53.8k53.06
SCOPE, catalog bounded to 64k bytes22.6k60.42

The bounded catalog is within +1.25 [−2.08, 4.72] pooled of the 192k pool with under half its input. It also beats the full catalog by 7.36 points [4.31, 10.56], because fewer questions have empty access (65 → 17).

W4 — Empty mappings; fallback; synthetic data; multi-hop. In all 623 empty-access cases (Appendix F.5), the mapper returned an empty selection from a non-empty catalog. We audited 50: in 37 the catalog held all or part of the needed information, 6 were extraction misses, and 7 had no relevant entry. In 26 of the 27 such dynamic cases, the mapper said no entry "described a change", so in these cases the cause is the mapper instruction, not missing records. Adding one paragraph to that instruction lifts the 65 former empty-access questions from 0% to 33.85% (28 wins, 0 losses) and leaves 40 control questions unchanged. With gpt-6-luna as the mapper, only 87 of 3,750 questions have empty access. The method of record uses no fallback and scores all 623 as zero (52.07%).

MemConflict is synthetic because each question needs a label for which statement is valid, and it is prior published work built for that. Multi-hop chaining (Appendix E) is outside the target problem: on 6K and 64K histories SCOPE scores 25% and 21% (BM25: 10% and 5%), against 100% and 95% on single-hop.

Setup. All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF. Unless stated otherwise, new experiments use the 360 questions of Sections 5.2–5.3, and numbers in brackets are 95% confidence intervals from a paired persona bootstrap. New runs use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash under a provider system identifier that changed after submission, so we compare them only with each other. The second backbone is OpenAI gpt-6-luna.

Thank you for the response, but the extent to which the slot cluster has worked has not been sufficiently demonstrated through experiments. I still have concerns about the significance of the new insights gained from the proposed evaluation methods beyond this point. Therefore, I will keep my score unchanged.

Reviewer_zSByOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper advocates to not resolve conflicts when writing into conversational memory, authors emphasize how doing so can discard a nuances a later question may need. Authors instead propose to use an LLM that extracts these with their source turns. These are grouped into slots without picking a final value. At query time, an LLM picks up to 3 slots, the linked source conversations will be expanded, and an LLM packs original turns into a 24 KB budget for a fixed reader. Key results are:

-- On all 3750 MemConflict questions SCOPE reaches 52.07 pooled and 50.32 dynamic AA. BM25 gets 39.03 and 33.88; Mem0, MemOS, LangMem and Letta get 32.7 to 37.2 pooled.

-- A matched control that swaps slot access for lexical retrieval, with a selector and a reader fixed, shows SCOPE ahead by +5.91 pooled and +8.03 dynamic.

Critical strengths

The experimental controls are as expected with agent-memory systems: matched intervention keeps selector, reader, judge, cutoffs and budgets fixed; any uncertainty mainly comes from persona-clustered paired bootstrap, and a second model family judge re-scores every arm; and I appreciate reporting the negative results such as 16.6% empty mappings, and parity with a reader given the full history.

I also like how authors separate which slot an assertion belongs to from whether it applies to a question or not.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The only matched control is lexical -- LLM selector on a BM25 pool already reaches 42.29 dynamic, about half of SCOPE’s gain over BM25.
  2. A close prior design is not used as a control: LongMemEval’s extracted facts used as keys pointing back to original sessions. Dense or hybrid retrieval is also missing.
  3. Full history matches SCOPE (53.61 vs 52.50), and SCOPE uses about 10x BM25’s input tokens.
  4. The core thesis seems weak on paper’s own endpoint -- on dynamic questions, only using latest value beats keeping all occurrences (52.71 vs 48.96). When using equal evidence budgets, all-occurrence dynamic gain turns into losses of 7.08 and 4.37.
Questions for authors
  1. Did you specify empty-mapping fallback before seeing test results? Which configuration is the method of record?
  2. Given that latest-only beats all-occurrence on dynamic questions, what result would falsify the claim that retaining alternatives helps?
  3. Just a suggestion -- could you also test a second backbone and sensitivity to ingestion order?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zSBy (1/2): W1–W3

Thank you for the review.

W1 — The only matched control is lexical; the selector explains about half the gain. That is by design. The no-slot pipeline keeps SCOPE's selector, reader, judge and budgets and changes only how evidence is accessed. So the +8.03 [5.31, 10.61] dynamic and +5.91 [3.60, 8.03] pooled gain (full cohort) is what access adds once the lexical pool has the same selector. We revised Section 5.2 so it no longer attributes the whole 16.45-point dynamic gap over BM25 to slots. Grouping itself is tested under W2 below.

W2 — No control with extracted facts as keys; no dense or hybrid retrieval. We built the closest in-pipeline version of the facts-as-keys control (Appendix F.11): one catalog entry per extracted occurrence, each linked to its own source session, instead of one entry per group. Downstream stages, budgets and the selection cap are unchanged; catalog length, displayed witnesses, expansion scope and source coverage change with grouping, as it implies.

Grouped − occurrence-level accessDynamicPooled
DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash+4.58 [0.83, 8.54]+3.61 [0.97, 6.53]
gpt-6-luna+3.75 [0.63, 6.88]+2.78 [−0.14, 5.83]

Under the same cap, a group entry reaches more source sessions (3.4 vs 1.7 per dynamic question). Doubling the occurrence cap from 3 to 6 still leaves occurrence-level access below grouped access (−3.96 [−8.54, 0.63] dynamic).

For dense and hybrid retrieval (Appendix F.13), we kept the no-slot pipeline and replaced BM25 with bge-m3 (dense) or with an untuned reciprocal rank fusion of the two (hybrid).

SCOPE −DynamicStaticConditionalPooled
Dense−9.38 [−14.79, −4.17]+7.50 [−3.33, 17.50]+15.00 [3.33, 26.67]−2.50 [−6.67, 1.81]
Hybrid−5.63 [−11.67, 0.21]+0.83 [−11.67, 12.50]+1.67 [−8.33, 10.00]−3.33 [−7.64, 0.97]

Dense similarity tends to pick the turn worded most like the question. On dynamic questions, that is the update session, so dense does well; on static and conditional questions, it pulls in restatements rather than the earlier statement. The retriever is not the paper's contribution, and Sections 5.2 and 7 now state the access advantage relative to lexical retrieval. At matched input, a bounded SCOPE catalog differs from the hybrid by +0.42 [−3.19, 3.89] pooled (Appendix H.3).

W3 — Full history matches SCOPE; SCOPE uses ~10× BM25's input. Full history minus SCOPE is +1.11 [−3.06, 5.42] pooled, and full history reads 205,714 query tokens per question against SCOPE's 54,191. The difference is concentrated in empty access (Appendix D.3): on the 304 questions where SCOPE reaches evidence, it leads 62.17% to 57.89% (+4.28 [0.33, 8.23]); on the other 56, SCOPE scores zero and full history 30.36%.

The 10× figure (61,014 vs 5,898 tokens) includes amortized ingestion and compares against direct BM25, which runs no selector. Against the no-slot pipeline, which keeps SCOPE's selector and reader, SCOPE gains +8.03 [5.31, 10.61] dynamic points on all 3,750 questions (Section 5.2). On the 360-question sample, where input is broken down by stage, SCOPE uses 3.95× the no-slot query input, and about 81% of it is the catalog and prompt shown to the mapper, a prefix repeated across questions. With the catalog bounded to 64k bytes, SCOPE is within +1.25 [−2.08, 4.72] pooled of the 192k lexical pool with under half its input (Appendices H.2–H.3).

Setup. All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF. Unless stated otherwise, new experiments use the 360 questions of Sections 5.2–5.3 (240 dynamic, 60 static, 60 conditional), and numbers in brackets are 95% confidence intervals from a paired persona bootstrap. New runs use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash under a provider system identifier that changed after submission, so we compare them only with each other. The second backbone is OpenAI gpt-6-luna.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer zSBy (2/2): W4/Q2, Q1, Q3

W4/Q2 — Latest-only beats all-occurrence on dynamic questions; what would falsify the claim? This follows from how MemConflict is built (Section 4). A dynamic question is asked after the update, and every index keeps the latest statement, which gives the current state, so a latest-only index loses no entry point there. Static and conditional questions are answered by an earlier statement, and a latest-only index removes the way to it. Our claim is that the valid statement depends on the question, which a write-time rule cannot see. It predicts static and conditional losses when superseded statements are removed at write time, and no dynamic gain from keeping them (Section 7(b)); it would be contradicted if removing superseded statements left static and conditional accuracy unchanged. We tested this with predictions recorded before inference (Appendix G.3):

Latest-only index − grouped accessDynamicStaticConditional
360-question sample−0.42 [−4.17, 3.33]−10.83 [−19.17, −1.67]−10.00 [−16.67, −3.33]
All 804 static and conditional questionsnot run (no dynamic questions)−10.83 [−14.17, −7.92]−8.11 [−10.89, −5.31]
gpt-6-luna (sample)−0.63 [−5.63, 3.75]−11.67 [−17.50, −5.83]0.00 [−8.33, 10.00]

The static loss appears on both backbones. On the second backbone the conditional loss appears once the removed text is also deleted (−6.67 [−13.33, −1.67]). No dynamic interval excludes zero; the submitted +3.75 for latest-only (52.71 vs 48.96) also had an interval including zero, and on the rerun it is −0.42.

The −7.08 and −4.37 dynamic points come from showing every retained occurrence under the cap, not from keeping them (Section 5.3). SCOPE keeps them but shows them grouped by slot (see W2 above).

Q1 — Was the fallback pre-specified? No. We designed it after seeing the empty-access questions, and the paper now labels it post hoc. The method of record is SCOPE without the fallback: 52.07% pooled, with all 623 of them scored as zero (Section 5.2, Appendix F.7).

Q3 — Second backbone; ingestion order. Thank you for the suggestion; we ran both. For the second backbone (Appendix F.12), we reran SCOPE and the no-slot pipeline on all 3,750 questions with gpt-6-luna doing mapping, selection and reading, and recorded the predictions in advance. SCOPE − no-slot is +15.60 [13.89, 17.32] dynamic and +11.79 [10.31, 13.24] pooled, with the same per-type pattern as on the original backbone.

For ingestion order (Appendix F.14), we shuffled the sessions and redid binding, the only ingestion step that depends on order. Shuffled minus chronological is +0.42 [−2.08, 2.92] pooled on the original backbone and +1.94 [−0.69, 4.58] on the second; both intervals include zero, as predicted before the runs. Shuffling does change the groups (co-slot Jaccard agreement 0.58 and 0.47), but not accuracy detectably.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers,

A friendly reminder to check the authors’ responses and the other reviewers’ comments. It would be helpful to hear your thoughts on the differing assessments and whether they affect your evaluation.

Thank you for your time and effort!

AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.