- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper propose a simple yet effective method for memory conflct issues. To be specific, the authors introduce slot-indexed conversational organization for provenance-linked evidence, i.e., SCOPE, which groups extracted statements by subject and attribute while retaining links to their original dialogue. At query time, these groups guide access to source turns for an answering model to interpret. SCOPE also outperforms othe baselines on MemConflict and MemoryAgentBench.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well strcutured.
- Simple yet effective method with good performance and analysis.
Critical weaknesses
The cost-quality trade-off and robustness analysis is not discussed.
Questions for authors
Refer to weakness section
Response to Reviewer emvp
Thank you for the review. We have added the cost–quality and robustness analysis you asked for.
Cost–quality (query input per question, Appendix H.2):
Against the no-slot pipeline, SCOPE gains +5.83 [0.21, 11.67] dynamic points on the 360-question sample at 3.95× the input, and +8.03 [5.31, 10.61] on all 3,750 questions. Reading the full history uses 3.8× SCOPE's input with no detectable gain (+1.11 [−3.06, 5.42]). With the catalog bounded to 64k bytes, SCOPE reaches 60.42% at 22.6k tokens, within +1.25 [−2.08, 4.72] of a lexical pool that uses more than twice the input (Appendix H.3). Mem0 and MemOS make more LLM calls than SCOPE and score 18.7 and 17.6 points lower pooled (Appendix H).
Robustness :
The access gain holds on a second backbone, grouping helps on both backbones, ingestion order has no detectable effect, and removing superseded statements at write time costs static and conditional accuracy.
Setup. All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF. Unless stated otherwise, new experiments use the 360 questions of Sections 5.2–5.3, and numbers in brackets are 95% confidence intervals from a paired persona bootstrap. New runs use DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash under a provider system identifier that changed after submission, so we compare them only with each other. The second backbone is OpenAI gpt-6-luna.